Best Restaurants in Westerville, Ohio

Agape Mediterranean in Westerville is a true gem in the culinary scene. With a diverse menu that offers both traditional and creative Mediterranean options, this restaurant has garnered rave reviews for its flavorful dishes and attentive service. Customers have praised the chicken shawarma bowl for its robust flavors and the falafel for its crispy perfection. The gyro is a standout, offering a delicious twist on a classic favorite. Not to be missed are the addictive Greek fries, generously topped with feta and sauce, a true delight for your taste buds. With ample portions at affordable prices, Agape Mediterranean is a must-visit for those looking for a satisfying and wallet-friendly dining experience in Westerville.

Located in the charming town of Westerville, Asterisk Supper Club is a hidden gem for those seeking a sophisticated dining experience. This upscale establishment not only offers a delightful afternoon tea but also boasts an impressive array of craft cocktails and upmarket American cuisine. As per rave reviews, patrons can expect exceptional recommendations from attentive staff members like Micah and Derek, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit. The menu is a culinary delight, featuring delectable dishes ranging from classic favorites like meatloaf and chicken & noodles to more inventive options like lemongrass and chicken potstickers. The cocktails are a work of art in themselves, with creations like the smoked old fashion leaving guests in awe. The ambiance, the food, the service – everything at Asterisk Supper Club is designed to exceed expectations and leave a lasting impression. Indulge in a Jane Austen-esque tea experience with a modern twist, and let servers like Kit elevate your dining adventure to new heights. Don’t miss out on this culinary haven in Uptown Westerville, where every visit promises to be a delightful journey for your taste buds.

Located in Uptown Westerville, Northstar Café is a modern, organic New American gem that has captured the hearts of many food enthusiasts. With rave reviews flooding in, it’s no surprise that this haunt stands out among the best restaurants in Westerville. Patrons can’t stop praising the delectable fish sandwiches, sweet potato hash, and signature cookies. The friendly staff consistently goes above and beyond, ensuring a warm and welcoming experience for all diners. From the cheerful atmosphere to the quick service and affordable, fresh dishes, Northstar Café is a must-visit spot that promises to leave you fully satisfied. Don’t miss out on this culinary delight in the heart of Uptown Westerville!

Located in Westerville, 101 Beer Kitchen is a vibrant hub for craft brew enthusiasts and food aficionados alike. Boasting a rotating menu of New American dishes, this spot has captured the hearts of diners with its delectable offerings. Dive into the world of flavors with their must-try chicken & biscuits, described as nothing short of a culinary delight by one satisfied visitor. Pair your meal with a carefully curated beer selection, as raved about by patrons who found the recommendations spot-on. The cozy ambiance, complete with a fireplace, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience, further elevated by attentive service and a scrumptious array of dishes like the crispy risotto and the housemade tater tots. Whether you’re craving comfort food with a twist or seeking a new favorite brew, 101 Beer Kitchen promises a feast for the senses that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Located in Westerville, the Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern is a must-visit spot for those seeking a casual dining experience with a vibrant sports-bar atmosphere. Boasting a diverse menu beyond typical “pub” fare, this gem offers standout dishes like the Cubano and fish tacos that have left customers raving. The accommodating staff is a true highlight, going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience, even for larger groups. Don’t miss out on their famous fish sandwich, a crowd-favorite that embodies both quality and generous portion sizes. With happy hour deals and an impressive beer list, Rusty Bucket is a top contender in Westerville’s culinary scene, delivering exceptional service and delectable comfort food favorites.

Las Margaritas in Westerville is a vibrant local favorite that truly shines in the Mexican cuisine scene. Boasting a menu filled with traditional favorites and a drink selection that includes top-notch margaritas and imported beers, this spot is a true crowd-pleaser. Raving reviewers have hailed the generous portion sizes, with one highlighting the Super Burrito as a standout dish that’s not only delicious but also a great deal, essentially offering two meals in one. The atmosphere has been described as reminiscent of a tiki hut, adding a unique and fun element to the dining experience. With service that’s described as top-tier and a star dish like the flavorful Arroz Con Pollo, Las Margaritas is a hidden gem that has survived the test of time, making it a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Mexican flavors in the Westerville area.

Located in the vibrant town of Westerville, Local Cantina is a gem that promises a fiesta for your taste buds. With a wide array of gluten-free taco options that are not only clearly listed but also scrumptiously delicious, this spot caters to every diner’s delight. The salsa verde adds a zesty kick that elevates the flavors to a whole new level. And let’s not forget about their margaritas selection that is as diverse as it is delightful. Boasting a spacious dining area that can easily accommodate a bustling crowd, this place exudes a lively ambiance perfect for any meal. While the guacamole may come at a premium, the overall experience at Local Cantina is nothing short of fabulous. Don’t miss out on this taco haven in Westerville!

Located in Westerville, BRU Burger Bar is a must-visit gem where gluten-free options shine without compromising on taste, as raved about by patrons. The efficient and friendly service here ensures a seamless dining experience, with a unique touch of allowing guests to wait comfortably until their table is ready. Dive into their delectable burgers, highlighted by the tantalizing Fontana sauce that reportedly takes flavors to a whole new level. The ambiance upstairs in the round room adds a special charm to family gatherings or casual outings. Pair your meal with a refreshing cider or explore their diverse draft beer selection for a well-rounded culinary adventure. BRU Burger Bar is a promising spot for those seeking quality fare in a welcoming setting, as echoed by eager diners eager to make return visits.

In the bustling town of Westerville lies China Garden Buffet, a hidden gem offering a culinary experience worth savoring. Guests rave about the flavorful dishes like the jalapeno chicken, salt and pepper shrimp, baked seafood casserole, and stuffed mushrooms, each leaving a lasting impression on discerning palates. With quick and efficient service, patrons are never left waiting, ensuring a seamless dining experience. The ambiance, described as “soothing” with a charming retro decor that exudes a unique allure, sets the stage for a delightful evening. If you’re seeking an affordable yet delectable meal in a relaxed setting, China Garden Buffet is a top contender in the realm of Chinese cuisine in Westerville.