Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in West Milford, New Jersey

Set in the picturesque landscapes of New Jersey, West Milford boasts a vibrant culinary scene that beckons food aficionados from near and far. This lovely town, known for its scenic beauty and outdoor recreational opportunities, also hides a treasure trove of gastronomic delights. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, the Best Restaurants in West Milford cater to diverse palates, promising a culinary adventure like no other. Nestled amidst lush greenery, this quaint town offers not only a feast for the eyes but also a feast for the taste buds. Whether you’re a local exploring new flavors or a traveler seeking authentic dining experiences, West Milford has something special in store for you.

1. Koon Thai Restaurant

Located in the vibrant town of West Milford, Koon Thai Restaurant is a gem not to be missed. With an impressive rating, this spot is praised for its generous portions and mouthwatering dishes. Delight in favorites like the “Drunkin noodle” and “Singapore noodles”, or savor the Crunchy Bowl featuring Orange chicken and Thai rice. The menu boasts standout items like Red and green curry, leaving visitors eager for more. Guests rave about the warm hospitality and the flavorful tom kha soup, setting this restaurant apart as a must-visit culinary destination in the heart of West Milford. With a diverse and intriguing menu, Koon Thai is sure to satisfy any Thai food craving!

Rating:
Price:

2. Cibo e Vino Ristorante

In the vibrant town of West Milford, Cibo e Vino Ristorante is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. With an impressive array of dishes like the delectable oysters rockefeller, arugula salad, and savory chicken piccata, this place is a haven for Italian food aficionados. The Italian bread and Olive Tapenade are hailed as culinary masterpieces, setting the stage for a memorable meal. Guests rave about the warm and welcoming service, with mentions of a hilarious yet attentive Tall Mentor and a dedicated waiter named Meti. The community has found a true culinary treasure in Cibo e Vino Ristorante, a must-visit spot for those craving exceptional Italian cuisine in a friendly and inviting atmosphere.

Rating:
Price:

3. Amore Italian pizza Westmilford

In the vibrant town of West Milford, Amore Italian Pizza stands out as a culinary gem that beckons both locals and travelers alike. With portions that defy expectations, this cozy eatery ensures that even small dishes are plentiful enough for sharing. From the tantalizing angel hair pasta adorned with a medley of herbs and cheeses to the heavenly grandma pie, each bite here is a testament to Italian flavors done right. The menu caters to all tastes, offering an array of choices that promise satisfaction for everyone who walks through the door. Whether you’re craving a traditional pie or hearty entrees like chicken and veal dishes that earn rave reviews, Amore Italian Pizza guarantees a dining experience that transcends the ordinary. Join friends and family in this culinary haven that delivers not just a meal, but an unforgettable feast for the senses. Discover a taste of Italy right here in West Milford.

Rating:
Price:

4. Momento Restaurant

Nestled in the vibrant town of West Milford, Momento Restaurant is a gourmet gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons rave about the impeccable service that transforms every visit into a special occasion – a true testament to their dedication to creating memorable moments. The menu, albeit limited, boasts exquisite Italian pasta, succulent meat dishes, and fresh seafood delights that have left diners in awe. From the sizzling steaks to the creamy ravioli and the heavenly pistachio and ricotta cake, each dish is crafted to perfection. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, complete with cozy fireplaces and stunning outdoor views, sets the stage for a culinary journey like no other. For those seeking a refined dining experience with exceptional cuisine and hospitality, Momento is the ultimate destination in West Milford.

Rating:
Price:

5. Luc’s

Located in West Milford, Luc’s is a culinary adventure waiting to be discovered. With a diverse menu that effortlessly blends flavors and styles, this spot is hailed as one of the best-kept secrets in the area. Specializing in mouthwatering fajitas that have patrons raving, Luc’s offers a fusion of fresh and delicious dishes. The atmosphere, complete with cozy couches and inviting outdoor seating, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a fan of specialty fajitas, fresh guacamole, or creative cocktails, Luc’s has something for everyone. From the creative dishes crafted by Chef L.J. Koch to the astonishingly accommodating staff, this gem on Greenwood Lake Tpke promises a delightful culinary journey that will keep you coming back for more. A hidden oasis with a motorhead theme, Luc’s surprises and delights with every bite, making it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in West Milford.

Rating:
Price:

6. Paul’s Place

In the vibrant town of West Milford, Paul’s Place is making waves with its mouthwatering burgers and hot dogs that have diners raving. Visitors can’t get enough of Paul’s signature sauce, often taking extra portions home to savor later. With a diverse menu offering something for everyone, it’s easy to see why this spot has quickly become a local favorite. The enthusiastic reviewer even went as far as to purchase a souvenir tee shirt, showcasing their newfound love for the place. Don’t miss out on the excellent service and affordable prices that make Paul’s Place a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in West Milford.

Rating:
Price:

7. Smoke Shack BBQ & Burgers West Milford Food Truck

In the bustling town of West Milford, Smoke Shack BBQ & Burgers Food Truck is a mouthwatering delight waiting to be discovered. Dive into a world of flavor as each dish promises an explosion of taste and generous portions, just as reviewers rave about. The fall-off-the-bone ribs and creamy Mac and Cheese are said to be instant classics, while the Dirty Bird, Crispy Clucker, and Chopped BBQ Chicken Mac Stack are hailed as must-tries for any BBQ enthusiast. And who can resist the allure of enjoying your meal alongside a Lockheed Tristar plane? This hidden gem is sure to satisfy all your BBQ cravings and more, making it a top contender in the search for the best restaurants in West Milford.

Rating:
Price:

8. West Milford Thai Restaurant

Located in West Milford, the West Milford Thai Restaurant is a hidden gem that has locals raving. Regulars love the personalized touch from Molly, the owner, who has a knack for remembering orders. Their menu caters to all, with standout dishes like the Pad Thai with chicken and broccoli and the vegan Spicy Eggplant with mixed vegetables and tofu receiving high praise. Customers also adore the friendly service, with Julie being highlighted for her warmth and attentiveness, even winning over a young diner with a hug. From appetizers to desserts like the luscious mango sticky rice, every bite at this spot is a flavor-packed delight. Don’t miss the Pad Ginger, curries, Thai tea, or Thai coffee – all contributing to a memorable dining experience at this West Milford favorite. With fresh ingredients and reasonable prices, this place stands out as a must-visit for Thai cuisine enthusiasts.

Rating:
Price:

9. Bagel Town Cafe

Welcome to Bagel Town Cafe in West Milford, where every bite tells a story of flavor and warmth. The bagels here are the true stars, earning rave reviews for their freshness and delicious fillings. Whether you’re craving a classic tuna sandwich or a hearty breakfast bagel, this spot has you covered. With a reputation for kindness and exceptional service, it’s no surprise that visitors find themselves touched by the genuine hospitality. Come for the bagels, stay for the heartwarming experience – Bagel Town Cafe is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by all food enthusiasts in West Milford.

Rating:
Price:

10. Pop’s Bagelry

If you’re on the hunt for the ultimate bagel experience in West Milford, look no further than Pop’s Bagelry. Situated in a charming old bank space, this gem is a true culinary delight. With a menu boasting made-to-order sandwiches using fresh, quality ingredients, Pop’s Bagelry is a haven for bagel enthusiasts. From the perfectly cooked chicken options to the mouthwatering scallion cream cheese and generous breakfast sandwiches, every bite is a flavor explosion. The friendly staff and inviting ambiance add to the overall appeal of this spot, making it a must-visit for bagel aficionados in search of a top-notch deli experience. Whether you opt for the classic lox bagel or indulge in a THE&C, prepare for a foodie adventure that promises to exceed all expectations. Don’t miss out on what could easily be the best bagels in all of New Jersey – Pop’s Bagelry is where memorable flavors and inviting spaces converge, creating a dining experience you won’t soon forget.

Rating:
Price: