Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in West Cape May, New Jersey

Situated in the heart of New Jersey, West Cape May is a haven for foodies and explorers alike. This quaint town may be small in size, but it packs a flavorful punch when it comes to its culinary offerings. From charming cafes to upscale eateries, this lovely town is a treasure trove of gastronomic delights waiting to be discovered. Beyond its delightful cuisine, West Cape May also boasts captivating attractions such as pristine beaches, historic sites, and vibrant local shops. Join me on a journey to uncover the Best Restaurants in West Cape May and indulge in a culinary adventure unlike any other in New Jersey.

1. Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

Located in West Cape May, Cape May Peanut Butter Co. is a delightful gem for both peanut butter aficionados and furry friends alike. Boasting a variety of gourmet nut butters, this cozy café has been praised for its friendly staff and delectable treats. Visitors rave about the unique flavors, from honey-infused spreads to ghost pepper peanuts that pack a spicy punch. Families and couples alike can enjoy customizing their peanut butter experience, with options like almond and cashew butter adding a gourmet touch to the traditional favorite. With online ordering options available, this spot is a must-visit for those craving a peanut butter paradise in the heart of Cape May.

Rating:
Price:

2. Cape May Fish Market

In the vibrant town of West Cape May, Cape May Fish Market stands out as a must-visit culinary gem. Boasting a cozy ambiance and a menu brimming with surf ‘n’ turf delights, this spot is a seafood lover’s paradise. The raving reviews speak volumes – from the tantalizing oyster shooters to the delectable cold smoked salmon, each dish is a testament to freshness and flavor. Don’t miss out on their Cowboy Burger, a fan favorite that promises a mouthwatering experience. With a friendly staff that goes above and beyond to cater to guests of all ages, including the tiniest diners, Cape May Fish Market truly earns its spot as a top contender in the Best Restaurants in West Cape May lineup.

Rating:
Price:

3. Elaine’s Cape May

In the vibrant town of West Cape May, Elaine’s Cape May is a gem worth discovering for a culinary experience like no other. Boasting an elegant venue that combines a restaurant, a pub, and an outdoor bar, this hotspot is a must-visit. From the generous portions of the Eggs Benedict with crab to the delightful seafood entrees like stuffed flounder and red snapper, every bite at Elaine’s is a flavor-packed journey. With a lively sports bar atmosphere indoors and year-round al fresco dining with live music, this venue offers more than just a meal – it provides an unforgettable dining escapade. Situated just a block away from Washington Street, Elaine’s Cape May is a magnet for both locals and tourists, beckoning with its alluring food, friendly service, and festive ambiance. Get ready to indulge in the fun and flavorful offerings of Elaine’s Cape May, where every visit promises a gastronomic adventure to remember.

Rating:
Price: