Best Restaurants in Toms River, New Jersey

Royal Grill 37 in Toms River is a hidden gem that shouldn’t be missed! This Middle Eastern and Indian counter-serve spot has been drawing rave reviews for its bold flavors, generous portions, and welcoming atmosphere. Diners can’t stop talking about the outstanding service, with staff eagerly guiding first-timers through must-try dishes, from savory meats to flavorful veggie options. The menu is a playground of delights, with standout items like the tantalizing white sauce and heavenly baklava stealing the show. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Royal Grill 37 is a culinary oasis that promises a feast for the senses. Don’t miss out on this vibrant hotspot that promises to elevate your dining experience to new heights!

Situated in Toms River, Stone Fire Grille offers a fantastic lunch special that’s a real steal – think sliders, shoestring fries, and a cold beer for just $15! The portions are generous, with massive tacos that even the heartiest appetites will struggle to finish in one go. The burgers are cooked to perfection, and the attentive service ensures you can relax and chat undisturbed throughout your meal. With a cozy interior and a bar area perfect for catching a game, this spot is a gem for both locals and visitors. Don’t miss out on this great find for a top-notch lunch experience in Toms River!

Located in Toms River, Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta is a delightful spot that embodies the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. With a longstanding tradition of culinary excellence, this informal Italian kitchen is a gem not to be missed. Patrons rave about the wood-fired pizzas and perfectly prepared pastas that transport taste buds to a realm of pure delight. From the stuffed gnocchi to the linguine with marinara boasting fresh ingredients and tantalizing flavors, Capone’s mastery in the kitchen shines through. The unique and tasty sauce has garnered a loyal following since 1998, making each visit a cherished experience. Whether you dine in the old-fashioned dining room or opt for their swift delivery service, be sure to savor the broccoli bites and imported grated cheese for a true taste of Italy right in Toms River.

In the buzzing town of Toms River, Villa Amalfi stands out as a culinary gem offering a delightful medley of Italian flavors. Boasting a vibrant ambiance adorned with Amalfi-themed murals, this restaurant enchants diners with impeccable service and a menu that sings with authenticity. From the succulent rack of lamb to the mouthwatering pasta dishes, each plate tells a story of tradition and passion. Whether you’re savoring the Veal Parm or indulging in the Beef Short Ribs Ragu, every bite is a symphony of flavors that keeps guests coming back for more. With a loyal following and a reputation for excellence, Villa Amalfi is a must-visit destination for those seeking a true taste of Italy in the heart of Toms River.

Located in Toms River, Artisan’s Restaurant & Brewery stands out as a warm and welcoming spot that beautifully blends classic Italian and Mediterranean flavors with a modern twist. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a newly updated interior that sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. The crispy goat cheese salad has been hailed as a fan-favorite, perfectly complemented by a selection of craft beers and half-price cocktails on Mondays. The staff, like Debbie and Evan Z, are highlighted for their exceptional service, creating an inviting atmosphere that leaves patrons feeling like old friends. With a menu that caters to every palate, from simple yet satisfying dishes to more elaborate specials like the salmon with baby lentils, Artisan’s attention to detail and dedication to excellence truly shine through. It’s no wonder that this restaurant has become a beloved go-to for locals and visitors alike, promising an unforgettable culinary journey with each visit.

Located in Toms River, L Gourmet LLC is a hidden gem for lunch enthusiasts. With a variety of homemade soups like split pea and potato leek that are not only delicious but also served in generous portions, this spot is a must-visit. The paninis, like the turkey ham and swiss or grilled vegetable, are fresh, flavorful, and reasonably priced. Don’t miss their standout seeded semolina Italian bread from Staten Island, elevating their sandwiches to another level. Despite rumors, the owner exudes warmth and friendliness, engaging with customers and creating a welcoming atmosphere. Dive into their fantastic chicken barley soup and get ready to become a loyal fan of this delightful culinary spot.

Located in Toms River, the Palms Restaurant & Lounge is a gem waiting to be discovered. With a winning combination of comfort and convenience, this spot offers more than just great food – it’s a destination in itself. Dive into their menu and savor dishes that will make you want to stay all day, just like one satisfied visitor who loved the ease of transitioning from poolside relaxation to a workout session. Embrace the charm of this establishment where the delights extend beyond just food, promising a delightful experience for those seeking more than just a meal.

Located in Toms River, Water Street Bar & Grille is a vibrant riverfront American eatery that offers a feast for the senses. Boasting a menu brimming with delectable seafood and succulent steaks, this spot is a hidden gem that promises a memorable dining experience. Diners rave about the lobster bisque that’s been described as “phenomenal” and the California burger that’s cooked to perfection. With live music adding to the lively atmosphere, guests can savor their meals indoors or outdoors while taking in picturesque water views. The friendly staff, including standout members like Andrea, contribute to the welcoming ambiance, making it an ideal choice for both intimate dates and large family gatherings. If you’re looking for a place where delicious food, great service, and scenic vistas converge, Water Street Bar & Grille is a must-visit destination in Toms River.

If you find yourself in Toms River craving a slice of heaven, look no further than Mangia Brick Oven Pizza. Renowned for serving up the BEST pizza around, this gem has locals and travelers alike raving about their friendly staff and spotless venue. From accommodating gestures like cutting a little one’s pizza into bite-sized squares to impressively delicious gluten-free options like the meat lovers pie and chicken penne in vodka sauce, Mangia goes above and beyond in satisfying every craving. Dive into their dope pizza creations and experience firsthand the care and professionalism that make this place a must-visit in Toms River. Your taste buds will thank you later!

Located in Toms River, The Office Restaurant & Lounge is a vibrant hub for American fare and delectable sushi creations. Step into its old-school ambiance and treat yourself to an array of culinary delights while sipping on craft brews on the inviting patio. Dive into a world of flavors where the cheeseburger is cooked to perfection, the chicken tenders are wonderfully crispy, and the beef and barley soup warms the soul. Don’t miss out on their signature sushi rolls like the Monkey Roll topped with crab meat, the Kamikaze Roll, and the 3 Brothers Roll – all bursting with impeccable taste. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual weeknight dinner or a sushi extravaganza, The Office promises a delightful experience that blends familiarity with culinary innovation.