Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Tiffin, Ohio

Set in the heart of Ohio, Tiffin is a delightful town brimming with culinary delights and charming attractions waiting to be explored. Known for its diverse dining scene, Tiffin boasts an array of eateries that cater to every palate, making it a haven for food enthusiasts. From cozy cafes serving up mouthwatering pastries to upscale bistros offering gourmet cuisine, this quaint town is a paradise for foodies. But Tiffin is not just a haven for food lovers; it also offers a rich tapestry of history and culture, with attractions like museums, parks, and historic sites dotting the landscape. Get ready to discover the Best Restaurants in Tiffin, Ohio, and indulge in a culinary journey like no other.

1. MST Pub & Grub/ Sauce Company

Located in Tiffin, MST Pub & Grub/ Sauce Company is a vibrant hangout known for its mouthwatering boneless wings and hearty burgers that keep patrons coming back for more. With a stellar 4.8 overall rating, this gem has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. The unique selection of sauces, like the Kitchen Sink and M&M, adds a delightful twist to every dish, making it a flavorful experience like no other. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere, combined with the owner Chase’s personal touch, create a sense of belonging that keeps customers returning time and time again. From loaded chunks to bologna sandwiches with grilled onions, the menu offers a diverse range of options that cater to every taste bud. Don’t miss out on their signature chicken chunks and tater tots, paired with the blazing garlic parm sauce for a truly unforgettable culinary journey. MST Pub & Grub is a must-visit spot in Tiffin for those seeking quality, value, and a memorable dining experience that hits all the right notes.

Rating:
Price:

2. Sabaidee Coffee And Crepes

Sabaidee Coffee And Crepes in Tiffin is an absolute gem for those seeking a delightful culinary experience. Known for their exceptional coffees and teas, the crepes steal the show with flavors like Nutella and banana, Chocolate chip, Chicken bacon ranch, and Potato, alongside a scrumptious omelet with crispy bacon and cheese. The friendly owners add a personal touch that elevates the already fantastic atmosphere. It’s no surprise that this spot garners rave reviews, with customers praising the welcoming vibe and top-notch service. Whether you’re savoring a cup of their house blend or indulging in their delectable crepes, Sabaidee Coffee And Crepes is a must-visit destination for any food enthusiast exploring Tiffin.

Rating:
Price:

3. Casa Express Mexican FOOD AND BEER GARDEN

Located in Tiffin, Casa Express Mexican Food and Beer Garden is a vibrant gem that has quickly captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a stellar 4.7 rating, this place buzzes with excitement and flavor. Diners rave about the swift service, with plates arriving promptly despite the bustling ambiance. The enchilada platter seems to be a star on the menu, served sizzling hot with generous toppings, leaving patrons both satisfied and impressed. The generous portions and thoughtful takeaway offerings, like packing up leftover chips and salsa, showcase the restaurant’s commitment to customer delight. So, if you’re craving a delightful Mexican dining experience with a side of warmth and efficiency, Casa Express is the spot to savor in Tiffin!

Rating:
Price:

4. Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery

Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery in Tiffin is a hidden gem that exudes local charm and culinary excellence. With a plethora of TVs adorning the cozy space, this spot is perfect for catching the game while indulging in top-notch comfort food. The menu boasts a variety of standout dishes, from the mouthwatering chicken wrap to the delectable cheese and bacon fries drizzled with ranch. The All American Burger and Fries combo has been hailed as a must-try, a true crowd-pleaser that promises great value. The welcoming staff, daily specials, and delivery service further elevate the dining experience at Benchwarmers, making it a go-to destination for families and foodies alike in Tiffin.

Rating:
Price:

5. Reino’s Pizza & Pasta

Reino’s Pizza & Pasta in Tiffin is a true gem that promises a delightful dining escapade. The menu boasts a tempting array of dishes, including the renowned Gyro Pizza that has guests raving about its unique flavors. Patrons are drawn not only by the delicious food but also by the warm and welcoming ambiance that exudes a charming family-friendly vibe. The attentive waitstaff further elevate the dining experience, ensuring that every visit leaves a lasting impression. With generous portions that don’t break the bank, this casual Italian eatery is indeed a local favorite where every bite feels like a comforting hug. A must-visit spot for those craving a taste of authentic Italian fare in Tiffin.

Rating:
Price:

6. Pioneer Mill of Tiffin

Situated in the historic Pioneer Mill of Tiffin, this steakhouse gem boasts a unique setting that blends history with culinary excellence. Boasting a delightful salad bar and an array of mouthwatering dishes, from perfectly cooked steaks to scrumptious pastas and delectable seafood, this place offers a flavorful journey for your taste buds. The Moscow Mule cocktail comes highly recommended for a refreshing sip. The attentive staff, like Brock, adds a personal touch to your dining experience. Despite occasional hiccups like running out of items, the overall vibe of this place, with a fresh soup and salad bar, is a hit with locals and visitors alike. With a picturesque river flowing under the deck, Pioneer Mill of Tiffin is a must-visit spot for those craving great food, friendly faces, and a charming ambiance.

Rating:
Price:

7. Clover Club Sports Tavern & Eatery

In the heart of Tiffin stands the Clover Club Sports Tavern & Eatery, a vibrant hub for those craving a taste of nostalgia and hearty American fare. With a welcoming atmosphere that embraces both sports enthusiasts and food aficionados alike, this throwback watering hole serves up a winning combination of pub classics and friendly service. From the savory Turkey burger paired with creamy mashed potatoes to the finger-licking BBQ pulled pork sandwich with a side of crispy sweet potato fries, each dish is a flavorful journey worth savoring. Guests rave about the speed of service and the accommodating staff, ensuring that even a bustling crowd of 10, including 3 little ones, feels right at home. Don’t miss out on the garlic mushroom Swiss burger or the tantalizing Blake’s caramel cider. Whether you’re a seasoned regular or a first-time visitor, Clover Club promises a dining experience that exceeds expectations and leaves you eager to return for more culinary delights.

Rating:
Price:

8. AJ’s Heavenly Pizza- Tiffin

If you find yourself in Tiffin craving a slice of perfection, look no further than AJ’s Heavenly Pizza. This casual pizzeria has captured the hearts (and stomachs) of locals and travelers alike with its classic and inventive pies. The pepperoni roll has been hailed as a masterpiece, boasting an airy, bubbly, and flaky dough that leaves taste buds in pure delight. Not to mention their ability to please a crowd – serving a party of 6 for just $30 with leftovers to spare! With outstanding customer service and lightning-fast order fulfillment, it’s no surprise that this gem is gaining popularity and turning heads in the pizza world. AJ’s Heavenly Pizza is a true standout in Tiffin’s culinary scene, a must-visit for anyone seeking a slice of pizza paradise.

Rating:
Price:

9. Cinemark Tiffin Mall 8

Located in Tiffin, Cinemark Tiffin Mall 8 is not just your average movie theater; it’s a haven for movie buffs and foodies alike. With an easy-to-navigate app for ticket and food purchases, seamless integration with Apple Wallet, and self-service kiosks, the experience starts even before the movie does. Guests have raved about the comfortable stadium seats that recline, ensuring a cozy viewing experience. But it’s not just about the movies; the yummy popcorn and fair prices make snacking a joy. The super-friendly service adds that extra sprinkle of delight to your visit, making Cinemark Tiffin Mall 8 a must-visit for both locals and visitors looking for a delightful cinematic and culinary adventure in Tiffin.

Rating:
Price:

10. The Wall Street Pub & Grille

Located in the vibrant town of Tiffin, The Wall Street Pub & Grille exudes charm and culinary excellence. Renovated from an old factory, this restaurant resonates a unique ambiance that sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. Their menu boasts a tantalizing array of options, from wraps and burgers to fresh, flavorful salads. Don’t miss out on their signature seasoned tater tots and the irresistible beer cheese that patrons rave about. And let’s talk about those boneless wings – boasting a soft texture and bursting with flavor, they’ve been hailed as some of the best around. With a vast selection of draft beers to complement your meal, this gem is a must-visit spot for food enthusiasts seeking a memorable culinary adventure in Tiffin.

Rating:
Price: