Best Restaurants in Suttons Bay, Michigan

Located in Suttons Bay, Gilchrist Farm is a culinary gem that certainly knows how to leave a lasting impression on its patrons. As you step into this new winery hotspot, you’re greeted with a welcoming and cozy atmosphere that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The Highlander wine, a standout selection from their tasting menu, is just the beginning of a journey into unique and delectable flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. The farrow salad and baked brie are just a glimpse of the culinary artistry that awaits you at Gilchrist Farm. The passion and love put into each dish, like the Sacchetini and Bison gumbo, shine through in every bite, leaving you craving more. And let’s not forget the cheesecake – a dreamy finale that will have you reminiscing long after your visit. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Gilchrist Farm is a must-visit destination for those seeking an exceptional dining experience filled with warmth, innovation, and culinary delights that will leave you wanting to return for more.

Located in Suttons Bay, Taqueria Las Lagunas is a culinary gem not to be missed. With rave reviews flooding in, this vibrant spot is a must-visit for food enthusiasts. Indulge in their savory steak burrito, flavorful barbacoa, and mouthwatering chicken tacos, all served on freshly made corn tortillas. The hot salsa is a fan favorite, adding an extra kick to already sensational dishes. Not only is the food outstanding, but the service is equally top-notch – friendly and fast, ensuring a delightful dining experience. Taqueria Las Lagunas has truly set the bar high in Suttons Bay’s culinary scene, offering amazing food at great prices. So, next time you’re craving authentic and delicious tacos, make sure to swing by this hidden culinary paradise!

Nestled in the charming town of Suttons Bay, Lylah’s is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. With a stellar 4.7 rating, this restaurant has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering sandwiches and impeccable service. Patrons praise the special turkey wrap, packed with flavorful goodness, and the tantalizing Tuna Schauby, a favorite among regulars. The inviting decor and friendly staff create a warm atmosphere, while the outdoor seating option offers a relaxing al fresco dining experience during the summer months. Whether you’re craving a hearty breakfast sandwich like the Eggscelenta or a satisfying lunch option like the Morning Hambition, Lylah’s is sure to impress even the most discerning food enthusiasts. Don’t miss out on their top-notch coffee and delectable cookies, making it a must-visit spot for a truly unforgettable culinary journey in Suttons Bay!

Situated in Suttons Bay, Hop Lot Brewing Co. & Beer Garden is a gem for beer enthusiasts and foodies alike. Boasting an expansive outdoor oasis, this establishment offers a unique experience with fire pits, cozy igloos, and even a sand pit for families. The menu is a delightful surprise, with standouts like the beef brisket nachos that have patrons raving. Pair these delectable dishes with their craft beers like the Smash Face pumpkin ale or the Uncle Green Guy session IPA for a match made in culinary heaven. With a chill vibe and a welcoming atmosphere, Hop Lot Brewing Co. & Beer Garden is a must-visit destination for those in search of great brews and a memorable dining experience.

Martha’s Leelanau Table in Suttons Bay is a culinary gem that beckons both locals and wanderers alike to savor its scratch-made delights with European flair. The inviting ambiance, highlighted by live music and cozy fire pits, sets the stage for a dining experience that promises warmth and sophistication. Dishes like the perfectly cooked fish tacos with a tantalizing jalapeno kick, or the steak in lobster sauce accompanied by dreamy scalloped potatoes, showcase the chef’s dedication to quality and flavor. And let’s not forget about the divine desserts that leave a lasting impression, from the mouthwatering tiramisu to the coconut cream pie that tantalizes taste buds. With a staff that goes above and beyond, like the attentive David crafting the perfect Old Fashioned, Martha’s Leelanau Table is a must-visit destination for those seeking an exceptional culinary journey in Suttons Bay.

In the heart of Suttons Bay lies Wren, a culinary oasis serving up rustic bistro fare and tantalizing cocktails in a laid-back atmosphere perfect for both locals and visitors alike. This gem has garnered quite the reputation, with patrons raving about the farm-to-fork experience and culinary mastery showcased in each dish. From a personalized cheese board that’s a must-try to the innovative use of local ingredients paired with diverse spices, Chef Adam’s creations never fail to impress. The cozy ambiance and attentive staff, including the standout Hannah behind the bar, add an extra layer of charm to an already unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re a food snob with high expectations or just seeking a memorable meal, Wren is a hidden culinary treasure worth discovering in the Leelanau Peninsula. Don’t miss out on the squash dish that’s bound to have you reminiscing until your next visit!

Located in Suttons Bay, Bay Burrito Co is a vibrant gem for food enthusiasts seeking a burst of flavor. Patrons rave about the Bruce burrito with a tantalizing mix of chicken, pork, and an array of fresh toppings, paired perfectly with the in-house sauces that elevate the taste experience. The nachos are hailed as the best in town, featuring a symphony of flavors with every bite, making them an absolute must-try. With a friendly and efficient staff, generous portions, and a charming patio facing the Bay, Bay Burrito Co promises a delightful culinary escape for both locals and visitors alike. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their scrumptious offerings for a quick, satisfying bite while exploring Suttons Bay!

Suttons Bay’s culinary scene shines with the vibrant gem, V.I. Grill, a must-visit for those craving American comfort chow with a side of local charm. Nestled in the heart of town, this grill dazzles patrons with an array of delectable dishes and local brews on tap, earning it a well-deserved spot in the spotlight. From the addictive jumbo perch bites to the mouthwatering pulled pork sandwich, each bite tells a story of culinary excellence. The Sunday family dinner special, complete with live music and an array of comforting dishes, is a steal deal that promises a symphony of flavors. With a staff as warm as their dishes are delicious, V.I. Grill is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience waiting to be savored and revisited. Come hungry, leave delighted – this place is simply irresistible.

In the vibrant town of Suttons Bay, Roman Wheel Pizza & Subs stands out as a local favorite for classic Italian and American comfort foods. This bustling eatery has garnered a loyal following for its mouthwatering pizza that keeps patrons coming back for more. Customers rave about the delicious flavors, from the buttery cheese to the sesame crust that steals the show. Whether you opt for a savory sub or dive into a cheesy pizza, Roman Wheel delivers on taste and quality. With friendly and efficient service, along with a cozy patio for dining, this gem is a must-visit for food enthusiasts exploring the culinary scene in Suttons Bay. Don’t miss out on this hidden culinary treasure on your next visit!

Boone’s Prime Time Pub in Suttons Bay is a gem worth discovering in the culinary scene. This cozy cabin-style spot not only offers a warm and inviting atmosphere but also serves up some seriously mouthwatering dishes. From the hefty and juicy burgers to the delightful fried fish and the perfect onion rings, every bite at Boone’s is a flavor explosion waiting to happen. The Reuben soup with rye croutons is a must-try for a spectacularly flavorful crunch. And let’s not forget the prompt and attentive service that adds to the overall experience. Whether you choose to sit near the inviting fireplace or up on the deck, every corner of this restaurant exudes charm and a welcoming vibe. So, if you’re in Suttons Bay, make sure to swing by Boone’s Prime Time Pub for a dining experience that will leave you smiling and satisfied.