Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Situated in the picturesque town of Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, culinary enthusiasts are in for a treat with a vibrant dining scene that showcases a delightful mix of flavors and cuisines. This lovely town is not only a haven for foodies but also boasts a rich maritime history, offering visitors a unique blend of gastronomic delights and cultural experiences. From charming cafes to upscale eateries, Sturgeon Bay is a paradise for those seeking the Best Restaurants in Wisconsin, where local ingredients shine and culinary creativity knows no bounds. Explore this quaint town’s culinary gems and immerse yourself in a delightful journey through flavors and aromas that will leave you craving for more.

1. Healthy Way Market, LLC

Located in Sturgeon Bay, Healthy Way Market, LLC is a hidden gem for health-conscious foodies seeking a vibrant culinary experience. With a diverse array of vegan options and a commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients, this market-turned-restaurant has captured the hearts of visitors and locals alike. From made-to-order delights that surpass the ordinary to a wide selection of supplements, snacks, and produce, Healthy Way Market offers a unique dining experience that is both delicious and wholesome. The warm and helpful staff, coupled with amenities like baby carts and a changing table, add an extra layer of convenience and comfort to your visit. Whether you’re a visitor exploring Sturgeon Bay or a local looking for a nourishing meal, Healthy Way Market is a must-visit destination that will leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

2. Get Real Cafe

Located in the charming town of Sturgeon Bay, Get Real Cafe is a culinary gem that has sparked a sensation among locals and visitors alike. Boasting a casual and laid-back ambiance, this all-day cafe is a must-visit for those craving a delightful dining experience. The reviews speak for themselves – from the mouthwatering French toast with local pork sausage to the gluten-free BLT and spicy chai, every dish is crafted to perfection. Whether you opt for the Free Bird on gluten-free bread or the Cuban on a spinach wrap, freshness and flavor reign supreme here. And let’s not forget about the friendly staff who add an extra sprinkle of warmth to your meal, making every visit a memorable one. Don’t miss the chance to savor their delicious offerings – Get Real Cafe is truly a culinary treasure waiting to be discovered in Sturgeon Bay!

Rating:
Price:

3. 5th and Jefferson Coffee House

Located in the heart of Sturgeon Bay, 5th and Jefferson Coffee House is a delightful gem that has captured the hearts of many visitors. Step into this warm and charming coffee house to indulge in their artisanal espresso drinks and delectable baked goods. From their aromatic lattes to their mouthwatering breakfast burritos, every bite and sip is a flavorful journey worth savoring. The eclectic decor and cozy outdoor seating area add to the inviting ambiance, making it a perfect spot to relax and unwind. With fantastic service, fantastic food, and a fantastic atmosphere, this coffee house is a must-visit for both locals and tourists alike. Don’t miss the chance to experience the magic of 5th and Jefferson Coffee House – where every cup and bite is filled with charm and flavor!

Rating:
Price:

4. Scaturo’s Baking Co & Cafe

In the heart of Sturgeon Bay lies a culinary gem, Scaturo’s Baking Co & Cafe, a vibrant local spot that embodies the essence of homestyle Italian-American cuisine with a touch of comfort and creativity. Renowned for their mouthwatering meatball sub sandwiches, robust turkey wraps, and an array of delectable baked goods that will tempt even the most discerning sweet tooth, this charming establishment has diners coming back for more. With a cozy atmosphere and a friendly staff that exudes warmth and hospitality, Scaturo’s offers a delightful dining experience whether you opt for their indoor, outdoor, or enclosed patio seating. The rave reviews speak for themselves – from the heavenly cherry pie to the thick-cut French toast crowned with cherries, each dish is crafted with care and precision, leaving a lasting impression. Whether you’re a local looking for your new go-to spot or a visitor seeking an unforgettable culinary adventure, Scaturo’s is a must-visit destination that promises an unforgettable gastronomic journey. Unveil a world of flavors and delights at Scaturo’s Baking Co & Cafe, where every bite tells a story of passion and culinary excellence.

Rating:
Price:

5. Morning Glory by the Bay

Located in Sturgeon Bay, Morning Glory by the Bay is a true breakfast gem that has visitors raving about their exceptional dishes and top-notch service. With a delightful Hash Brown Omelette stealing the spotlight, patrons have found solace in the perfectly cooked and seasoned hash browns that elevate the dining experience. The cozy ambiance of the restaurant invites guests to dine both indoors and outdoors, providing a comfortable setting to enjoy flavorful meals and excellent coffee. From their friendly and attentive staff to the well-executed breakfast meats and potatoes, Morning Glory by the Bay promises a memorable culinary adventure that will have you planning your next visit before you even leave. Don’t miss out on this Sturgeon Bay treasure!

Rating:
Price:

6. Bluefront Cafe

Dive into the culinary oasis of Bluefront Cafe situated in the vibrant town of Sturgeon Bay! This cozy gem has captured the hearts and taste buds of many food enthusiasts with its artful ambiance and specialty sandwiches that leave a lasting impression. Picture yourself savoring the exquisite flavors of the Asian Pork Belly Rice Bowl, a fan-favorite that promises a delightful explosion of taste in every bite. For the plant-based enthusiasts, the vegan options here are a true standout, with the zesty cauliflower sandwich and tofu bahn mi stealing the show. With menu offerings that cater to all palates, exceptional service, and a welcoming vibe, Bluefront Cafe beckons you to indulge in a dining experience like no other. Ready to elevate your culinary journey? Make sure to add this gem to your must-visit list for a delightful escapade into flavor paradise!

Rating:
Price:

7. Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub

In the heart of Sturgeon Bay lies Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub, a lively haunt that prides itself on offering a fusion of Irish pub favorites and American classics. Patrons rave about the hearty burgers and savory lobster rolls, showcasing a tempting mix of flavors that go beyond traditional Irish fare. The outdoor patio, adorned with real grape vines and equipped with heaters, provides a charming spot to savor your meal, while inside exudes a vibrant sports bar vibe. Pair your dish with a Guinness or opt for their unique Dragon Eggs and Lobster Tacos, as recommended by loyal customers. With a welcoming staff, generous portions, and standout dishes like the loaded Bloody Mary, Kitty O’Reillys promises a delicious experience that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your meal.

Rating:
Price:

8. Nightingale Supper Club

Located in Sturgeon Bay, the Nightingale Supper Club is a quintessential Wisconsin gem that beckons diners with its charming old-school vibes and mouthwatering steakhouse offerings. Stepping into this cozy space feels like a nostalgic journey, where the classic nautical decor and rope chandeliers set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. From savoring the delectable fish fry to indulging in perfectly cooked ribeyes with a delightful char, every dish is crafted to perfection. The extensive menu doesn’t disappoint, offering a plethora of options from juicy prime rib to crispy fried shrimp. Don’t miss out on their unique sides and toppings for the steak, making each bite a savory delight. With exceptional service and a warm ambiance, Nightingale Supper Club is a must-visit spot for anyone craving a taste of Wisconsin culinary tradition.

Rating:
Price:

9. Old Mexico Cantina and Grill

Located in Sturgeon Bay, Old Mexico Cantina and Grill is a vibrant gem offering a wide array of Mexican and Tex-Mex delights that will tantalize your taste buds. With a menu that boasts fresh guacamole made tableside, mouthwatering chimichangas, and flavorful tacos, this restaurant has quickly become a local favorite. Guests rave about the generous portions, reasonable prices, and the friendly service that adds a special touch to the dining experience. From the massive margaritas to the charming Mexican decor, Old Mexico Cantina and Grill is a must-visit spot for those craving a delightful culinary adventure in Sturgeon Bay. Whether you’re a longtime local or a first-time visitor, this hidden culinary treasure promises an unforgettable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more. Cheers to discovering this culinary goldmine!

Rating:
Price:

10. Inn at Cedar Crossing

Situated in Sturgeon Bay, the Inn at Cedar Crossing boasts a quaint restaurant that promises a delightful culinary experience. With dishes like the creamy and flavorful chicken risotto and the mouthwatering Buttermilk fried chicken sandwich, this place is a haven for food enthusiasts. The cozy yet elegant atmosphere adds an extra layer of charm, making it perfect for any occasion, whether dressed up or in casual attire. The menu offers a variety of options, including the must-try goat cheese lemon dip appetizer with naan bread. Top-notch service, like that provided by Vicky and Andrea, elevates the dining experience, leaving guests raving about the generous portions and delectable flavors. For a refreshing cocktail, the Door County Cherry Cosmopolitan is a winner. Make sure to save room for a slice of their cherry pie, a delightful finale to a memorable meal at this hidden culinary gem in Sturgeon Bay.

Rating:
Price: