Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Stillwater, New York

Situated in the heart of New York, Stillwater is a culinary paradise waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant food scene with an array of top-notch eateries that cater to every palate. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal coffee to upscale bistros offering fine dining experiences, Stillwater is a haven for food enthusiasts. Beyond its gastronomic delights, this charming town is steeped in history, with attractions like historic landmarks and picturesque parks that draw visitors from far and wide. Join me on a gastronomic journey through the Best Restaurants in Stillwater, where every meal is a delectable experience worth savoring.

1. Bucciero’s Pizzeria

Situated in the charming town of Stillwater, Bucciero’s Pizzeria has quickly become a local gem, drawing in pizza enthusiasts and foodies alike. With a string of rave reviews praising their delectable fare and top-notch service, it’s no wonder this spot is making waves. From the tantalizing garlic knots that have patrons singing their praises to the mouthwatering eggplant parm and chicken riggies that keep customers coming back for more, Bucciero’s is a culinary delight. The cozy neighborhood vibe, coupled with the excellent service and family-run ambiance, creates the perfect setting for enjoying their unique dish-style pizzas or grabbing a satisfying sub made with love and care. Whether you’re a local looking for your new go-to spot or a visitor seeking an authentic dining experience, Bucciero’s Pizzeria is a must-visit destination for a taste of Stillwater’s finest flavors.

Rating:
Price:

2. Moreno’s Pizza

Located in Stillwater, Moreno’s Pizza is a hidden gem serving up top-notch tavern-style pizza that keeps patrons coming back for more. Known for their delicious pepperoni pizza and mouthwatering french fries, this spot is praised for its perfect crust, bomb toppings (especially the bacon), and superb cheese. The standout dish that steals the show? Their garlic knots, hailed as the best on the planet. With a welcoming and friendly staff, including the nicest owner you’ll ever meet, Moreno’s Pizza ensures a memorable dining experience with consistently great food. Make sure to try their crispy wings and flavorful calzones for a taste of perfection in every bite. If you’re in Stillwater, this is a culinary destination not to be missed!

Rating:
Price:

3. Stewart’s Shops

Nestled in Stillwater, Stewart’s Shops is a gem for those seeking a delightful treat or quick bite. Boasting an array of mouthwatering ice cream flavors, like the tempting campfire s’more’d, this spot is a crowd-pleaser. Not just your average convenience store, Stewart’s surprises with quality pizzas that won’t break the bank. The friendly staff adds a welcoming touch to your visit. Whether you’re craving a creamy milkshake or a budget-friendly snack, Stewart’s is your go-to spot for a satisfying culinary experience in town.

Rating:
Price:

4. Dom’s Pizza Subs & Wings

Located in Stillwater, Dom’s Pizza Subs & Wings is a culinary gem that has locals and visitors raving. The menu is a delightful blend of classic favorites and innovative creations, with their signature pizzas stealing the show. Reviewers can’t stop talking about the perfectly crispy wings and the mouthwatering subs that are packed with flavor. The friendly staff and cozy ambiance make this spot a must-visit for anyone craving a satisfying meal in Stillwater.

Rating:
Price: