Best Restaurants in Starkey, New York

In the charming town of Starkey, Tabora Bakery and Deli shines brightly as a culinary gem that shouldn’t be missed. With a stellar reputation for their mouthwatering baked goods, delectable deli sandwiches, and tantalizing salads, this spot is a true haven for food enthusiasts. Guests rave about the finger-licking quiches that redefine indulgence and the diverse selection of baked treats that are nothing short of heavenly. Don’t forget to pair your meal with a glass of their divine wine for a truly unforgettable dining experience. Tabora Bakery and Deli is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a delightful feast that will leave taste buds singing with joy.

Situated in the quaint town of Starkey, Tabora Farm & Winery is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. With a deep passion for wine-making evident in every pour, the experience here is nothing short of extraordinary. The warm and knowledgeable staff, led by the talented winemaker Matthew, offer a VIP experience like no other, sharing insights into the intricate process of crafting exceptional wines. From their exquisite dry whites that tantalize the taste buds to the luscious reds that rival the best in the region, Tabora Farm & Winery is a must-visit for any wine aficionado. But the delights don’t stop at wine – their deli offers a delectable range of dishes, from hearty soups to refreshing salads, all served with a side of hospitality that feels like a warm embrace. Whether you’re a seasoned sommelier or a casual wine enthusiast, a visit to Tabora Farm & Winery promises an unforgettable experience that will have you returning for more.

Located in the charming town of Starkey, Crossing Diner stands out as a must-visit gem along Route 14. Boasting an impressive array of breakfast options, including the mouthwatering garbage omelette loaded with a savory mix of ham, sausage, bacon, and more, this diner truly takes the omelette game to a whole new level. The quirky railroad theme adds a touch of nostalgia, creating a cozy and welcoming ambiance for diners. With efficient and friendly staff who keep the place spotless, the Crossing Diner offers a seamless dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re craving homestyle classics like French toast or a hearty breakfast platter, this diner promises not just delicious food but also a slice of small-town hospitality that makes every visit unforgettable. Don’t miss out on savoring their signature home fried potatoes or indulging in a bowl of flavorful ham and bean soup – Crossing Diner is a culinary haven worth every cash-only penny spent!

Located in Starkey, F.L.X. Wienery offers a unique dining experience that’s more about flavor than frills. Embracing a casual and laid-back vibe, this spot surprises patrons with locally sourced hot dogs, hamburgers, and sausages that pack a punch. The sausages steal the show here, accompanied by crispy fried potatoes that are a must-try. Not to mention, the impressive beer list, featuring even the coveted Pappy van Winkle. Despite varying opinions, the standout bratwurst and the delectable German mustard steal the spotlight, making it a worthwhile stop for those craving a flavorful roadside feast. Whether you’re a local or making a drive up from Watkins Glen, F.L.X. Wienery promises a culinary adventure that’s worth the visit.