Best Restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida

Located in a charming 1927 industrial building in St. Augustine, Ice Plant Bar offers a delightful dining experience that has captured the hearts of many visitors. The ambiance is described as cool and industrial, with multiple seating areas including a front and back bar, tables, and an inviting outside patio. Diners rave about the locally sourced dishes like the flavorful Butternut Squash soup and Fish Spread served with kettle style chips. The service is top-notch, with one reviewer even dubbing their server as one of the best they’ve ever had. Whether you’re in the mood for a late-night drink or a family dinner, Ice Plant Bar comes highly recommended for its great food, excellent drinks, and wonderful atmosphere that sets it apart from the touristy spots downtown. Don’t miss out on the Hoecakes, recommended both with the chicken and on their own, for a truly delightful culinary experience in St. Augustine.

Situated in the historic Lincolnville district of St. Augustine, The Blue Hen Café is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts seeking a taste of Southern comfort with a twist. Despite the bustling atmosphere and a quirky mishap or two, this daytime eatery shines in the realm of scrumptious cuisine. The fried green tomatoes are a must-try, boasting a crispy exterior and a flavorful batter that dances on your taste buds. “The Yard Bird” is a savory delight, accompanied by collard greens that steal the show. And let’s not forget the pumpkin pancakes, described as the softest and most delicious pancakes you’ll ever savor. Whether indulging in biscuits and gravy or relishing a pastrami sandwich grilled to perfection, The Blue Hen Café promises a delightful dining experience worth the wait. Don’t miss out on their unique offerings that pay homage to Grandma’s kitchen, making each bite a nostalgic journey back in time.

In the heart of St. Augustine lies O’Steen’s Restaurant, a local gem dishing out some of the freshest seafood in town. Renowned for their mouthwatering fried shrimp and delectable clam strips, this cash-only joint is a must-visit for seafood aficionados. As you sit back and soak in the lively atmosphere, be prepared to wait a bit for a table – but fear not, the anticipation only adds to the experience. From the zesty Minorcan Clam Chowder with a hint of Datil pepper to the crispy and flavorful Famous St. Augustine Fried Shrimp, every bite at O’Steen’s is a culinary delight. And don’t forget to save room for their tempting pies, even if it means rolling out the door afterward! With its cozy charm and irresistible dishes, O’Steen’s truly embodies the essence of coastal dining in St. Augustine.

Situated in the charming town of St. Augustine, Harry’s Seafood, Bar & Grille is a vibrant gem serving up mouthwatering New Orleans-inspired dishes that will transport your taste buds straight to the bayou. With a bustling outdoor patio and a cozy indoor setting, this hip spot is a must-visit for foodies seeking a lively dining experience. Rave reviews highlight the impeccable service and the fresh, hot dishes that hit all the right notes, especially for spice aficionados. From the delightful fried green tomatoes to the incredible fondue appetizer, every bite at Harry’s is a culinary adventure worth savoring. Whether you’re enjoying a peaceful evening under the heat lamps or mingling with the friendly staff, this restaurant promises a memorable dining experience that truly captures the essence of Southern hospitality. Make sure to plan ahead for a wait during peak hours – it’s a testament to the restaurant’s popularity and well-deserved reputation for top-notch food and ambiance that will leave you coming back for more.

Nestled in St. Augustine, the St. Augustine Fish Camp is a must-visit for seafood aficionados seeking a charming waterfront dining experience. With a reputation for excellence, this harborfront gem boasts a delightful array of dishes that have left diners raving. From creamy and flavorful Shrimp & Grits to perfectly prepared broiled seafood platters and mouthwatering crab cakes, every bite is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality. The house-made tarter sauce, described as “especially flavorful,” adds a touch of homemade goodness to each dish. Boasting indoor and outdoor seating, as well as a dock for boat-up customers, this establishment offers a versatile dining experience. Whether you’re a fan of southern classics like crab fritters or looking to savor unique delicacies like gator, the St. Augustine Fish Camp promises a culinary adventure that will keep you coming back for more. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their delectable desserts, like the white chocolate cranberry bread pudding, a sweet finale to a stellar meal. With friendly and attentive staff enhancing the overall dining experience, a visit to this seafood haven is sure to leave you planning your next return trip.

Maple Street Biscuit Company in St. Augustine is a vibrant mecca for biscuit enthusiasts and Southern food aficionados alike. From the moment you step inside, you’re enveloped in an atmosphere brimming with charm and excitement. The kitchen’s bustling energy as they craft those delectable biscuits is mesmerizing, their flavors a testament to the skill and care put into each creation. It’s clear from the playful “question of the month” order call-outs that this isn’t just a meal – it’s an experience. With efficient service and a mouthwatering array of dishes, including the must-try biscuit sandwiches and Southern sides, Maple Street Biscuit Company promises a culinary adventure worth savoring in the heart of St. Augustine’s dining scene.

Catch 27 in St. Augustine is a true gem for those seeking a culinary adventure in a charming setting. Delight your taste buds with their renowned deviled eggs topped with fried oyster, a unique twist that sets the tone for an unforgettable dining experience. Dive into their blackened pasta with shrimp, expertly served on creamy risotto, or savor the tender beef brisket paired with classic sides like green beans and mashed potatoes that “cut like butter.” Don’t miss the opportunity to sip on their signature margaritas or the intriguing hot butter rum – a true hidden delight. Whether you choose to dine indoors in the cozy converted old house or opt for the picturesque courtyard, Catch 27 promises a delightful atmosphere accompanied by top-notch service. With a menu that boasts local seafood and seasonal fare, this spot is a must-visit for food enthusiasts exploring the best of St. Augustine’s culinary scene.

Located in the heart of St. Augustine, Mojo Old City BBQ is a true gem for BBQ enthusiasts. The ambiance is as soulful as the blues music playing in the background, setting the stage for a remarkable dining experience. Guests rave about the generous portions and mouthwatering dishes, like the grilled chicken smothered in cheese and bacon, the flavorful pork sandwich, and the unforgettable mashed potatoes that steal the show. Not to be missed are the delectable onion rings, a crispy delight that’s been a pleasant surprise for many diners. With a selection of sauces to tantalize your taste buds, Mojo Old City BBQ promises a flavorsome journey that will keep you coming back for more.

Located in the heart of St. Augustine, Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House is a culinary gem worth discovering. Boasting a charming deck with river views and a garden-like back patio, this cozy spot offers a delightful escape for food enthusiasts. Delve into their Cork City Curry, lauded as the best in town for its unparalleled flavor and aromatic allure. Not to be missed are the mouthwatering fish and chips, a crowd-pleaser that keeps patrons coming back for more. The attentive staff ensures a seamless dining experience, with elaborate drinks and picture-perfect Rubens adding to the overall charm. A visit to Meehan’s promises not only a culinary journey but also an unforgettable dining adventure that will leave you craving more of their delectable offerings.

The Floridian Restaurant in St. Augustine is a hidden gem for food enthusiasts craving a unique Southern culinary experience. With a modern menu boasting locally sourced ingredients and an abundance of vegan options, this eatery is a standout in the city’s dining scene. The rave reviews speak volumes, with patrons praising not only the delectable dishes like the “Biscuit and Belly,” Chicken Golden Curry, and Beef Brisket Tacos but also the exceptional service that goes above and beyond. The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between lively and cozy, making it an ideal spot for a memorable meal. And let’s not forget the innovative gluten-free options and the mouthwatering desserts like the warm gluten-free brownie with caramel drizzle that will leave your taste buds in awe. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, The Floridian Restaurant is a must-visit for a culinary journey like no other in St. Augustine.