Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Southampton, New York

Nestled in the picturesque landscapes of New York, Southampton is more than just a scenic retreat; it’s a culinary haven for food enthusiasts. This town, steeped in a rich historical ambiance, offers a diverse array of dining experiences, from upscale gourmet eateries to charming, rustic bistros. The local cuisine is heavily influenced by its coastal location, with seafood restaurants offering the freshest catches that are a delight to the palate. Moreover, Southampton’s commitment to using locally sourced ingredients highlights the town’s strong connection to its agricultural roots, making each meal not just a feast for the taste buds but also a celebration of local farm-to-table practices. Whether you’re in the mood for an exquisite fine dining experience or a cozy meal by the fire, Southampton promises an unforgettable culinary journey.

1. T Bar Southampton

T Bar Southampton in Southampton is a culinary gem that’s making waves in the local dining scene. Boasting a chic black and white decor that exudes sophistication with a mix of Hamptons charm and European flair, this restaurant is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable meal experience. The menu is a tantalizing blend of classics and innovative dishes, with standout offerings like the perfectly cooked 24oz Rib-eye steak accompanied by a decadent Bearnaise sauce. Guests rave about the attention to detail in each dish, from the flavorful Caesar salad to the exceptional banana parfait dessert. And let’s not forget the carefully curated cocktail selection, with delights like the Mezcal Mule to elevate your dining experience. Although the service may have a seasonal hiccup, the overall dining experience at T Bar Southampton is sure to leave a lasting impression. Plan your visit and indulge in a culinary journey that promises to delight your taste buds and leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

2. Main Prospect

Located in the bustling town of Southampton, Main Prospect is a culinary gem that leaves a lasting impression on all who step through its doors. Boasting a stunning decor that spans from the elegant dining room to the vibrant bar and cozy smoking lounge, this restaurant promises an unforgettable dining experience. The staff, including the attentive manager Dylan and friendly waitstaff, ensure top-notch service that elevates the entire visit. With raving reviews about the fantastic food and drinks, Main Prospect stands out not only for its delectable dishes but also for its reasonable pricing, making it a must-visit spot for both locals and visitors. From a delightful Sunday brunch featuring an array of pastries to mouthwatering Crème Brûlée stuffed French Toast and Eggs Benedict, the menu delights even the most discerning palates. Add in the charming ambience with live jazz performances and an arcade for entertainment, and Main Prospect becomes the ultimate dining destination in Southampton. Whether you’re planning a romantic date night or a gathering with friends and family, Main Prospect promises an experience that will have you coming back for more, creating cherished memories that will linger for years to come.

Rating:
Price:

3. The Plaza Café

Nestled off the bustling streets, the Plaza Café emerges as a serene sanctuary for seafood aficionados and wine enthusiasts alike, offering a culinary journey that’s both simple and luxuriously sophisticated. Under the masterful helm of Chef Doug, this gem provides an unparalleled dining experience where consistency in excellence is the cornerstone. With a menu that’s evidently a testament to the chef’s prowess, dishes like the Macadamia Crusted Mahi Mahi, Lobster and Shrimp ‘Shepard’s Pie’, and the unique seafood pot pie sing harmonies of flavors that could very well make your taste buds dance in delight. The warmth and professionalism of the staff, including the memorable service by Samantha and Maryelle, elevate the overall experience, ensuring each visit is as memorable as the last. Whether you’re in for a heartwarming evening or a romantic dinner, the Plaza Café, with its meticulous attention to detail from ambiance to plate, promises an unforgettable culinary escapade in the heart of Southampton.

Rating:
Price:

4. Sip ‘N Soda

Tucked away in the charming town of Southampton, Sip ‘N Soda is a delightful gem for those seeking a taste of nostalgia with a modern twist. This family-owned luncheonette, known for its old-fashioned soda fountain, serves up a delectable array of American fare and ice cream treats that will transport you back in time. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty breakfast with mouthwatering omelets and pancakes or craving a comforting bowl of cream of tomato soup during the winter months, Sip ‘N Soda has something for everyone. The cozy booth seats and friendly staff add to the inviting atmosphere, making every visit a memorable experience. Don’t miss out on their famous lemon custard ice cream, and be sure to bring cash as this spot is a cash-only joint. So, if you’re looking for a spot that combines delicious food, top-notch service, and a touch of old-world charm, Sip ‘N Soda is the place to be in Southampton!

Rating:
Price:

5. Sant Ambroeus Southampton

Sant Ambreous dazzles with its authentic Italian flair, where every dish feels like a culinary masterpiece straight out of Italy. From the best avocado toast that seems to redefine breakfast to pasta dishes and Branzino that leave patrons in awe, this eatery is a testament to consistency and excellence across its locations. The ambiance, with its airy setting, elegantly complements the refined dishes, paninis, gelati, and espressos on offer, making every visit an exquisite experience. Whether you find yourself at the Madison Avenue or Southampton spot, expect to be wowed by both the food and the atmosphere, proving Sant Ambreous is a must-visit destination for those seeking an authentic Italian dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

6. La Hacienda Mexican Grill

If you find yourself in Southampton craving a taste of Mexico, look no further than La Hacienda Mexican Grill! This vibrant eatery is a hidden gem, serving up tantalizing tacos, hearty burritos, and mouthwatering tortas that will transport your taste buds south of the border. Noteworthy mentions from diners include the unbeatable Horchata, a sweet and creamy delight that perfectly complements the flavorful dishes. The friendly service and generous portion sizes have left patrons singing praises, with some even raving about the free parking available for guests. So, whether you’re a local looking for a quick breakfast bite or a visitor wanting to savor authentic Mexican flavors, La Hacienda Mexican Grill is an absolute must-try for a fiesta in your mouth!

Rating:
Price:

7. The Fudge Company

Nestled in an easily accessible spot, perfect for a late evening treat after dinner or a beach day, this gem of a dessert destination is a must-visit for families and sweet-toothed adventurers alike. The ambience is pristine and welcoming, setting the stage for a delightful experience that goes beyond just savoring their sumptuous ice cream. With a menu that boasts a scrumptious mix of candy and a kaleidoscope of ice cream flavors, it’s no wonder why both kids and adults leave with smiles as bright as the venue itself. The staff’s friendly and courteous demeanor adds a cherry on top of the already delightful experience. And while your taste buds are dancing to the rhythm of their exquisite flavors, don’t let their awesome fudge escape your notice – it’s a silent contender for the highlight of your visit. Whether you’re in the area with family or simply seeking a sweet escape, this spot is a beacon of happiness for anyone with a penchant for indulging in life’s little pleasures.

Rating:
Price:

8. Hampton Coffee Company

Tucked away in a cozy corner with a quirky parking situation due to its shared lot with a BMW dealership, this relaxed culinary haunt impresses with its dedication to providing a delightful dining experience. From the rich, aromatic lattes that promise to elevate your morning to the generously portioned, delectable lobster rolls served both hot and chilled, there’s an evident commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The outdoor tables invite diners to linger over breakfast and lunch, enjoying pastries that are as fresh as the coffee. The staff’s congeniality and efficiency shine through, making each visit memorable. Whether you’re here for the “best coffee” you’ve ever tasted or to savor the scrumptious paninis, you’re in for a treat that’s thoroughly worth the minor parking inconvenience.

Rating:
Price:

9. La Parmigiana

Tucked away in South Hampton since 1972, this beloved Italian restaurant has been dishing out heaping portions of comfort food to bustling crowds, making it a must-visit for both locals and travelers alike. Whether it’s the slightly unconventional yet tantalizing pepperoni pizza that draws you in, or the rich, creamy delight of their fettuccine Alfredo that’s hailed as a masterpiece, this establishment does not shy away from impressing its guests. The interior exudes beauty, matched only by the warmth and attentiveness of the staff, ensuring every dining experience feels personalized and cozy. The complimentary bread, served hot and fresh, alongside their acclaimed rigatoni and perfectly dressed Greek salad, completes the feast. And let’s not forget, it’s a paradise for both pasta and pizza lovers, offering an array of dishes that cater to every palate, including the little ones, making it a family-friendly gem that’s not just about dining, but about creating memorable experiences around generous, delectable meals.

Rating:
Price:

10. Tutto Il Giorno South

Nestled in the heart of Southampton, Tutto Il Giorno stands as a testament to inventive Italian cuisine, set against a backdrop of modern decor, distressed wood, and an enchanting garden that promises a swanky dining adventure. This gem has consistently delighted palates, catering to even the pickiest of eaters with dishes that beckon for a repeat experience. From the welcoming embrace of the staff to the meticulous involvement of the owner/manager, the service here is as remarkable as the gourmet offerings. Regulars and newcomers alike rave about the must-have pastas, the fresh, signature drinks, and the divine finish of cappuccino and tiramisu under the stars. It’s a culinary experience where the ambiance outside matches the excellence of the food, crafting memorable evenings that urge you to make early reservations to secure a spot in this piece of Southampton’s dining paradise.

Rating:
Price: