Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Sherrill, New York

Situated in the heart of New York, Sherrill is a culinary paradise waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant dining scene that caters to every palate, making it a haven for food enthusiasts. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Sherrill is home to some of the Best Restaurants in New York, offering a diverse range of flavors and gastronomic experiences. Beyond its culinary delights, this quaint town also features charming boutiques, picturesque parks, and historic landmarks, making it a must-visit destination for travelers seeking a perfect blend of dining and exploration.

1. Lakeside Landing Restaurant

Located in the charming town of Sherrill, Lakeside Landing Restaurant offers a culinary experience that is nothing short of delightful. Boasting a picturesque view of the water, this gem has captivated diners with its diverse menu and attentive service. Guests have raved about the mouthwatering Deli Board option, featuring a selection of sandwich wraps, salads, and delectable desserts, all expertly prepared. The Blackened Chicken Salad has emerged as a crowd favorite, earning accolades for its flavorful preparation. While the service might experience the occasional hiccup due to understaffing, the warm and friendly waitstaff more than make up for it with their hospitality. Lakeside Landing Restaurant is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience in Sherrill.

Rating:
Price:

2. Sweet Life of a Baker

Located in Sherrill, Sweet Life of a Baker is not just a bakery, it’s a slice of culinary paradise. With a menu as diverse as it is delicious, this place is a must-visit for food enthusiasts. From the Ding Dong cake to the Peanut Butter white chocolate brownie, each bite is a flavor explosion. The bakery’s attention to detail and customer service shine through in every review, showcasing their dedication to creating not just tasty treats, but memorable experiences. Whether you’re craving a savory breakfast sandwich or a decadent dessert, Sweet Life of a Baker has something to satisfy every craving. So, if you’re in search of a delightful dining experience where every morsel is crafted with love and skill, look no further than this charming gem in Sherrill.

Rating:
Price:

3. Taste of China Sherrill Inc

Located in the vibrant town of Sherrill, Taste of China Sherrill Inc is a culinary gem that has food enthusiasts driving for miles to savor its exquisite Chinese cuisine. With an array of dishes ranging from the flavorful General Tso’s chicken to the delightful crab Rangoon and everything in between, this restaurant has truly mastered the art of Chinese cuisine. Guests rave about the freshness of the vegetables, the perfect texture of the dishes (never soggy!), and the exceptional service that goes above and beyond. Whether you’re a Chinese food aficionado or a first-time explorer, this restaurant promises a delectable experience that will leave you craving more. Experience the magic of Taste of China Sherrill Inc and let your taste buds thank you later!

Rating:
Price:

4. Corner Diner Too

Located in Sherrill, the Corner Diner Too is a breakfast haven that shines brightly in the local dining scene. With rave reviews praising their attention to detail, like perfectly crispy hash browns and generous portions, this spot is a must-visit for breakfast enthusiasts. Diving into their menu reveals unique delights such as omelets with greens and scrumptious options for both vegetarians and meat lovers. The Farmyard special seems to be a crowd favorite, leaving patrons satisfied with its flavors and portion sizes. If you find yourself in Sherrill, make sure to swing by this gem of a diner for a delightful culinary experience that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price:

5. Marble Hill Inn

Located in Sherrill, the Marble Hill Inn is a vibrant hub for food enthusiasts seeking a lively atmosphere and top-notch service. Patrons rave about the mouthwatering burgers, crispy fish fry, and tantalizing weekly specials that never disappoint. The bar delights with a wide selection of craft beers and the added bonus of Guinness stout on tap, expertly poured by knowledgeable bartenders. The happy hour steals the show, offering buy one get one drinks daily, making it a must-visit spot for locals and visitors alike. Join the friendly staff and patrons for a truly unforgettable dining experience at Marble Hill Inn.

Rating:
Price:

6. East Sushi

Located in Sherrill, East Sushi is a hidden gem that promises a delightful culinary experience. With a stellar rating, this sushi haven is praised for its fast and friendly service, alongside delicious and unique rolls that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Standout dishes like the spicy salmon roll offer a delightful crunch, while the complimentary miso soup sets the stage for a memorable sushi feast. The menu boasts a variety of options, including the must-try spicy tuna and Tokyo roll, ensuring that every visit leaves a lasting impression. Don’t miss out on this local favorite where great food and kind service converge to create a truly exceptional dining adventure!

Rating:
Price:

7. Joe’s Jerky, Pizza, Deli & Corner Market

If you find yourself in Sherrill craving a diverse culinary experience, look no further than Joe’s Jerky, Pizza, Deli & Corner Market. With a reputation for top-notch service and a menu that caters to all tastes, this spot is a true gem. Dive into their specialty NY Strip steaks that have been raved about for their tenderness and flavor, or opt for the fresh and crisp salads that perfectly complement their deli offerings. The weekly lunch buffet promises a rotating selection that keeps diners coming back for more, while the variety of prepared meals and specialty items like beef jerky and spices add an extra flair to your visit. Joe’s is not just a dining spot; it’s a hub of community support and culinary delight that promises a memorable experience for locals and visitors alike.

Rating:
Price:

8. Ye Olde Pizza Pub

Ye Olde Pizza Pub in Sherrill is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts looking for a top-notch dining experience. Boasting a friendly and attentive staff, this establishment ensures that every visitor feels right at home from the moment they walk through the doors. The menu is a delightful mix of classic favorites and innovative creations, with standout dishes like the mouthwatering riggies stealing the show. Served piping hot and bursting with flavor, accompanied by delectable garlic bread that hits all the right notes. The attention to detail in both service and food quality shines through, making Ye Olde Pizza Pub a must-visit spot for both locals and travelers alike looking for a memorable culinary adventure in Sherrill.

Rating:
Price:

9. Lakeview Restaurant

Located in the charming town of Sherrill, Lakeview Restaurant is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Boasting a diverse menu that caters to various dietary needs, this restaurant stands out for its gluten-free options that don’t compromise on taste. Diners rave about the Chicken Francaise and perfectly cooked prime rib, showcasing the chef’s skill in crafting delectable dishes. The serene ambiance, situated right on the golf course with picturesque views of the 18th green and Sunset Lake, sets the stage for a memorable meal. Whether you’re planning a special event or simply looking for a delicious meal, Lakeview Restaurant comes highly recommended for its impeccable service and exquisite presentation. Indulge in their carefully crafted meals and savor the flavors that make this restaurant a must-visit in Sherrill.

Rating:
Price:

10. Sherrill New York Pizzeria

Located in the charming town of Sherrill, Sherrill New York Pizzeria is a hidden gem for pizza aficionados. Boasting a wide selection of single slice options, this spot is perfect for a quick, flavorful lunch. The star of the show? The everything sauce chicken wing pizza, dubbed the best of its kind by patrons. With a reputation for lightning-fast service and a staff that exudes friendliness, it’s no wonder customers rave about their experiences. Whether you’re a local looking for a go-to slice or a traveler passing through, this pizzeria is a must-visit for a unique culinary delight in Sherrill.

Rating:
Price: