Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Sherburne, New York

Exploring the culinary landscape of Sherburne, New York, promises a gastronomic journey like no other. This charming town boasts a delightful array of dining establishments that cater to every palate, making it a haven for food enthusiasts. From family-owned eateries serving hearty comfort food to trendy cafes dishing out artisanal treats, Sherburne is a treasure trove for foodies. While savoring the delectable offerings, visitors can also immerse themselves in the town’s rich history, picturesque surroundings, and vibrant community spirit. Join me as we uncover the Best Restaurants in Sherburne, NY, and dive into a dining experience that goes beyond just a meal.

1. Judy’s Coffee Shop

Situated in the vibrant town of Sherburne, Judy’s Coffee Shop is a beacon of warmth and comfort for both locals and travelers alike. Boasting a charming diner ambiance, Judy’s draws in patrons with its friendly and attentive staff who go above and beyond to make you feel right at home. The menu is a treasure trove of classic American breakfast delights, from the best omelets in town to mouthwatering biscuits and sausage gravy that will have you coming back for more. As you savor every bite, you can bask in the sense of community that permeates the air, making each visit to Judy’s a truly special experience. So, whether you’re a solo diner seeking solace or a group of friends looking for a flavorful start to the day, Judy’s Coffee Shop promises not just a meal, but a memory worth cherishing. Bon appétit!

Rating:
Price:

2. Lewis’ Restaurant

Located in Sherburne, Lewis’ Restaurant is a true gem for those seeking a hearty and satisfying meal. The stuffed shells have garnered rave reviews, with patrons praising the generous portions and unbeatable prices. One enthusiastic diner even exclaimed that the meal was so filling that leftovers were inevitable. With such high praise for their signature dish, it’s no wonder that Lewis’ Restaurant has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. Make sure to stop by and indulge in a dining experience that promises to leave you more than satisfied.

Rating:
Price:

3. Gilligan’s Island

Situated in Sherburne, Gilligan’s Island is a true gem for both locals and travelers seeking a nostalgic dining experience. Boasting an array of ice cream flavors available year-round, this charming spot is a favorite haunt for those craving a classic burger and fries combo. Stepping into Gilligan’s feels like stepping back in time, with old signs adorning the walls, creating a unique retro ambiance. The restaurant’s popularity is evident, with a constant stream of patrons coming in through the front and back doors. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty meal or a sweet treat, Gilligan’s Island delivers impeccable service and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps visitors coming back for more. With its central location on Main Street, it’s a must-visit destination that promises not just great food but a delightful trip down memory lane.

Rating:
Price:

4. Sherburne Diner

Located in the charming town of Sherburne, the Sherburne Diner is a gem that locals and visitors alike rave about. With an inviting atmosphere and top-notch service, this diner is a go-to spot for any meal of the day. The extensive menu offers delicious options, from hearty breakfast dishes available all day to mouthwatering lunch and dinner choices. Guests particularly love the homemade corned beef hash and the generous portions at reasonable prices. The friendly and attentive staff add to the overall enjoyable experience, making this diner a must-visit for those craving some comforting home cooking in a welcoming setting.

Rating:
Price:

5. Joe & Vinny’s Pizzeria

In the vibrant town of Sherburne, Joe & Vinny’s Pizzeria stands out as a culinary gem worth discovering. This quaint pizzeria exudes a welcoming charm, with friendly faces greeting you the moment you step inside. While the cozy tables may not accommodate all, the raving reviews emphasize the joy of indulging in their delectable offerings as takeout. Customers rave about the impeccably cooked pizza crust, with a special mention of the heavenly pepperoni garlic knots – a true crowd-pleaser. Despite the bustling pace, the staff’s unwavering politeness shines through, adding to the overall delightful dining experience. With top-notch service, affordable prices, and pizza that hits all the right notes, Joe & Vinny’s Pizzeria is a must-visit spot for both locals and travelers passing through Sherburne.

Rating:
Price:

6. Stewart’s Shops

Located in Sherburne, Stewart’s Shops is a hidden gem for those seeking a delightful culinary experience. Boasting a diverse menu ranging from delectable ice cream flavors like Peanut butter Pandemonium and Brew Ha Ha to savory options like the renowned chicken wing soup, this spot is a haven for food enthusiasts. With friendly staff ensuring top-notch service and a cozy ambiance, Stewart’s Shops is not just a pit stop but a destination for those craving quality coffee, satisfying snacks, and genuine hospitality. Whether you’re a local regular or a passing traveler, one visit to this charming spot will surely leave you craving for more.

Rating:
Price:

7. China King of Sherburne

Located in Sherburne, China King is a hidden gem for Chinese cuisine enthusiasts. With over three decades of serving top-notch dishes, this restaurant has recently upped its game, leaving patrons impressed and eager for more. The crunchy egg rolls, perfectly cooked fried rice, and flavorful egg foo young are just a few highlights among a myriad of delectable options. Diners rave about the generous portions and the use of full-size shrimp in dishes like sweet and sour chicken and shrimp with broccoli. If you find yourself craving exceptional Chinese food between Binghamton and Cortland, China King is a must-visit spot that promises a 5-star experience every time.

Rating:
Price:

8. Richie’s Bar & Grill

Located in Sherburne, Richie’s Bar & Grill is a vibrant hotspot that offers more than just great food. With a pool table, dart board, dance area, and a stage for live entertainment, this venue is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience. Described as a perfect spot to relax with friends over drinks and catch up with old acquaintances, Richie’s Bar & Grill is a true gem in the Sherburne dining scene. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual hangout or some lively entertainment, Richie’s Bar & Grill promises a memorable night out that combines good food with good company.

Rating:
Price: