Best Restaurants in Shelley, Idaho

Rockin Russet in Shelley is not your average restaurant. Boasting the title of the best bar in Eastern Idaho, this spot is a hidden gem among local diners. The menu features affordable and delicious pizzas that are a must-try, according to patrons. The welcoming environment and friendly staff make it a perfect spot for a date night or a casual hangout with friends. And let’s not forget about the hot pastrami sandwich, which one reviewer raved about as one of the best they’ve ever had! It’s clear that Rockin Russet is a must-visit for those seeking great food, cold beverages, and a fantastic atmosphere without breaking the bank. A small-town treasure that’s worth the visit for a memorable dining experience.

Step into the warm embrace of Mick’s Home Cooking, located in Shelley, where local flavors and unbeatable hospitality collide to create a dining experience worth writing home about. Dive into their signature Thursday special, a burger-fry-pie combo that promises to tantalize your taste buds. From freshly grated hash browns to hearty bacon and substantial ham steaks, each dish at Mick’s is a testament to the commitment to quality ingredients and attention to detail. The cozy, family-friendly ambiance adds a touch of nostalgia to your meal, while the friendly staff, like the ever-polite and attentive server Katy, ensure that your dining experience is nothing short of delightful. Whether you’re a local looking for a taste of home or a traveler passing through, Mick’s Home Cooking is a hidden culinary gem waiting to be discovered. Don’t miss out on this down-home dining delight that won’t break the bank but will undoubtedly leave you coming back for more.

Located in Shelley, Mr Pizza is a culinary gem that embodies the true spirit of community and delicious eats. With a warm family atmosphere and genuine care, this spot is hailed as the Best Pizza in town, drawing patrons back for its outstanding quality and remarkable service. Regulars reminisce about childhood memories and summer days spent savoring each slice, creating a nostalgic ambiance that is truly heartwarming. Don’t miss out on their signature ranch dressing, which adds a unique touch to their delectable pizzas. Plus, with affordable prices and a wide array of options, including personal pizzas and breadsticks, Mr Pizza is a steal worth savoring. For a taste of local pride and a slice of culinary delight, Mr Pizza is a must-visit destination in Shelley.

Sauce Take ‘N’ Bake, situated in Shelley, is a hidden gem worth uncovering in the culinary scene of south Idaho Falls. With a focus on great pizza and delectable sauce, this spot stands out for its commitment to flavor and quality. The reviews rave about the Hawaiian and combo pizzas, showcasing fresh ingredients, well-balanced flavors, and a standout sauce that truly sets them apart. Beyond the pizzas, the menu offers a delightful surprise with a rare yet impressive Reuben pizza. The warm ambiance of the bar room, coupled with a great beer selection, adds a touch of fun to the dining experience. Whether opting for take and bake or enjoying a freshly baked pie on-site, Sauce delivers on both taste and value, making it a top choice for a satisfying meal that won’t disappoint. If you find yourself in Shelley, Sauce Take ‘N’ Bake is a must-visit for a flavorful journey through their delightful offerings.

Located in Shelley, El Jaliciense #3 Mexican American Restaurant is a vibrant culinary gem that promises a delicious fusion of Mexican and American flavors. Dive into their menu and savor the savory chicken taquitos that have been raved about for their tasty appeal. Amidst the classic Mexican vibes and colorful ambiance, indulge in a dining experience that balances authenticity with a welcoming atmosphere. While service may have the occasional hiccup due to busyness, the overall charm and delectable offerings of El Jaliciense #3 make it a must-visit for those craving a culinary adventure in Shelley.

Champs Chicken in Shelley is a hidden gem for all food enthusiasts looking to tantalize their taste buds with some seriously flavorsome chicken delights. The menu offers a delightful variety that will leave you spoiled for choice. Whether you’re in the mood for classic crispy chicken or craving a zesty BBQ twist, this place has got you covered. The cinnamon apples are a must-try, adding a touch of sweetness to your meal. Patrons rave about the friendly service, making each visit a delightful experience. Don’t let the gas station location fool you; Champs Chicken is a true culinary surprise that will have you coming back for more.

Located in Shelley, Arctic Circle is a local gem serving up a delectable array of Black Angus burgers, halibut sandwiches, milkshakes, and fries. With a reputation for friendly service and hot, well-prepared food, this place is a hit with families and foodies alike. From the perfectly cooked bacon burger to the gyro that packs a flavorful punch, each dish promises a satisfying experience. And let’s not forget the indulgent milkshakes and perfectly crispy fries that keep customers coming back for more. Whether you’re in for a quick bite or a hearty meal, Arctic Circle promises a memorable dining experience that’ll have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the drive-thru.