Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Riverhead, New York

Riverhead, New York, sits at the gateway to the twin forks of Long Island, merging the charm of a small town with the culinary ambition often found in more metropolitan areas. This unique position not only offers picturesque views but also a rich tapestry of local produce and seafood that chefs in the area skillfully incorporate into their dishes. Riverhead’s dining scene shines with an array of options, from cozy, farm-to-table eateries reflecting the agricultural bounty of the surrounding areas to waterfront restaurants serving up the freshest catches from the Peconic Bay. Moreover, the town’s revival has brought with it a wave of innovative dining establishments, making Riverhead a must-visit for foodies exploring the flavors of New York State.

1. Feelin O2 Good

Nestled in the east end of Long Island, this remarkable establishment is a haven for those looking to indulge in a healthier lifestyle without sacrificing the joy of eating out. Despite its unassuming exterior, which could do with a touch more pizazz to truly showcase its inner marvels, this place is much more than a simple juice bar. It’s a holistic experience, blending delicious, organic meals like the vegetable wrap that comes highly recommended, with a plethora of wellness services. Imagine detoxing with foot baths, aligning your chi, or rejuvenating in an oxygen bar, all followed by a refreshing smoothie or acai bowl that’s as tasty as it is nutritious. The staff, including the knowledgeable and friendly Patricia, Naeem, and Matt, elevate the experience with their helpful insights and warm conversations. It’s not just a meal; it’s an affordable spa day, a wellness retreat, and a delicious eatery all rolled into one. A true gem for those in pursuit of well-being, this venue masterfully combines the art of healthy living with the pleasure of fine dining.

Rating:
Price:

2. Turkuaz Grill

Situated along the picturesque Peconic River in Riverhead lies Turkuaz Grill, a vibrant gem offering a taste of authentic Turkish cuisine. With a delightful outdoor patio, diners can soak in the serene ambiance while savoring Middle Eastern staples. The menu boasts mouthwatering dishes like Turkish cigars, Adana specials, and falafel platters, each prepared with care and bursting with flavor. Customer favorites include the spinach pie and the delectable Chicken Adana, elegantly presented and full of taste. With accommodating staff, spacious dining options inside and out, and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, Turkuaz Grill is the perfect spot to unwind and indulge in a culinary journey that will keep you coming back for more. Whether you’re a local or willing to take a drive, this spot is a not-to-be-missed culinary experience in Riverhead.

Rating:
Price:

3. Haiku Sushi

Located in Riverhead, Haiku Sushi is a vibrant gem for sushi enthusiasts. With a delightful patio setting, this spot is praised for its expertly crafted sushi, tempura, and teriyaki dishes. Patrons rave about the owner’s warm hospitality and the meticulously prepared take-out orders, with one reviewer hailing the Miso soup as a standout. Regulars commend the extensive menu, with the Mango Tuna Tar tar emerging as a crowd favorite. A recurring theme is the genuine care shown by the husband-and-wife team, creating a welcoming atmosphere that keeps diners coming back for more. Haiku Sushi’s dedication to using fresh ingredients and supporting local vineyards elevates the dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for sushi aficionados in search of a memorable culinary adventure.

Rating:
Price:

4. The Birchwood of Polish Town

Located in the vibrant town of Riverhead, The Birchwood of Polish Town is a culinary gem offering a delightful blend of Polish classics and American eats in a cozy 1920s tavern setting. The menu boasts mouthwatering dishes like sauerbraten and stuffed flounder, which have left diners raving about their exceptional flavors and quality. Patrons have praised the attentive and friendly staff, with one reviewer even highlighting the memorable experience with their server, Amanda. Whether you’re there for a festive Easter Brunch or a leisurely Mother’s Day celebration, this restaurant promises a remarkable dining experience filled with delicious food, warm service, and old-world charm. If you’re looking to embark on a culinary journey that combines tradition with innovation, The Birchwood of Polish Town is a must-visit destination in Riverhead.

Rating:
Price:

5. Cucina 25

Nestled in a cozy corner with rustic charms aplenty, this family-friendly eatery offers more than just a meal; it provides an experience. From the mouth-watering Chicken Parm to a smorgasbord of Italian classics, it’s a haven for those eager to indulge in culinary delights. While the pizza might not hit the mark for everyone, the overall consensus leans heavily towards a delightful dining adventure. With fantastic deals that tantalize not just the palate but also the wallet, and service that makes you feel like part of the family, it’s no wonder patrons are eager to return. Whether you’re looking for an intimate dine-in, a swift takeaway, or a reliable delivery, this gem offers it all, complete with ample parking for a hassle-free visit.

Rating:
Price:

6. Sarikopa Organic Coffee house, Tea, Juice Bar, Smoothies, Açaí bowl and Eatery

Nestled in the heart of Baiting Hollow, this charming cafe has quickly become a sanctuary for both locals and vacationers alike, seeking refuge in its organic coffees and wholesome delights. From the generous açaí bowls brimming with fruit to the flavorful mushroom and goat cheese omelettes, each dish is a testament to the cafe’s commitment to fresh, tasty food. The strong, specially selected organic coffee pairs perfectly with their moist scones, making it a must-try for anyone who appreciates the finer things in life. While the owner’s personality may be as robust as the coffee he serves, it’s clear that passion and high standards are the true essence of this establishment. With an inviting outdoor seating area surrounded by pear trees, this cafe is not just a place to eat but an experience to savor. It’s a delightful spot where the food is not only good for the soul but also kind to the body, offering a range of vegan options and dairy alternatives. This homey cafe stands as a beacon of culinary excellence and a testament to what happens when quality ingredients meet heartfelt hospitality.

Rating:
Price:

7. Maple Tree BBQ

Located in Riverhead, Maple Tree BBQ offers a delightful escape into the world of traditional American BBQ with a Southern twist. As you step into this lofty dining spot with charming exposed-wood beams, you’re immediately greeted by a culinary experience like no other. Rave reviews highlight the impeccable customer service, fantastic atmosphere, and an array of mouthwatering dishes. From the tantalizing burnt ends and flavorful brisket to the divine St. Louis Pork Ribs and smoked delicacies like the half chicken and brisket, each bite is a savory journey. The extensive selection of local craft beers adds an extra layer of delight to your dining experience. With generous portions and reasonable prices, Maple Tree BBQ promises a memorable meal that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your plate. Whether you’re a BBQ aficionado or just looking for a delicious meal, Maple Tree BBQ is a must-visit hotspot in Riverhead for an unforgettable dining adventure.

Rating:
Price:

8. Jerry and The Mermaid

Nestled beside the picturesque waterfront, a stone’s throw from the vibrant life of downtown Riverhead and the Hyatt hotel, Jerry and the Mermaid beckons food enthusiasts with its casual charm and delightful karaoke evenings. It’s not just the fresh seafood and simple fish dishes that have patrons raving, but also the unexpected pleasure of biting into one of Long Island’s most marinated Angus burgers, served with the crispiest, most “potatioest” waffle fries. Whether it’s the Mermaid combo platter, teeming with fried clams, scallops, shrimp, and haddock, or the uniquely flavored duck wings, every dish is a testament to the culinary mastery housed within. With a cozy atmosphere complemented by great service, this spot ensures a delightful dining experience, making it a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of the sea or a perfectly cooked burger in Riverhead.

Rating:
Price:

9. Dark Horse Restaurant

Nestled amidst the bustling vibe of Riverhead’s Main Street, with its art deco flair and towering high ceilings, this eclectic American gem offers a culinary adventure that’s not to be missed. From my first step inside, I was greeted with a warmth that only a knowledgeable and, dare I say, humor-infused wait staff can provide, setting the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The farm-to-table offerings, from the tender Merlot beef to crispy duck and creamy mashed potatoes, left no doubt that the attention to detail here borders on the obsessive, with a clear focus on quality and a knack for making even those with dietary restrictions feel thoroughly pampered. Whether it’s a delightful end to a day spent exploring local attractions or a sought-after destination for a special occasion, the rich tapestry of flavors, coupled with a commitment to accommodating gluten-free needs without a hitch, ensures that every visit here is poised to exceed expectations. And when the meal concludes with an espresso creme brulee that could very well be the talk of the town, it’s clear: this vibrant corner of Riverhead is where culinary dreams come alive.

Rating:
Price:

10. Tweed’s Restaurant

Stepping into Tweeds is like taking a step back into a plush, vintage era that enthusiasts of Teddy Roosevelt and admirers of 1920s hunting lodges would find utterly charming. The ambiance is completed with a meticulously preserved mahogany and marble bar and wall-mounted game that adds a touch of irony, especially when one opts for their game-centric menu. Their celebrated bison burgers and steaks are more than just a meal; they’re an experience, with each bite of their elk steaks and duck wings promising an explosion of flavor that brings patrons back time and again. The service at Tweeds matches the quality of its dishes — attentive, friendly, and truly enhancing the overall dining experience in this historic Riverhead tavern. Whether you’re there for the critically acclaimed steaks or to indulge in the surprisingly tender and flavorful duck wings, Tweeds ensures every visit is an occasion to remember, urging you to make reservations to secure a spot in this illustrious eatery.

Rating:
Price: