Best Restaurants in Rexburg, Idaho

Situated in Rexburg, Righteous Slice is a genuine gem for pizza enthusiasts passing through the area. Raved about for its made-to-order pies cooked to perfection in a wood-burning oven, this spot is a must-visit. The Margarita pizza and the creative Hang Ten pizza with customizable toppings steal the show, accompanied by decadent dessert pizzas and shakes that rival traditional ice cream shops. With generous portions and top-notch ingredients, including standout pineapple, this joint wins hearts with its friendly staff and welcoming ambiance. If you find yourself in Rexburg, make sure to swing by Righteous Slice for a slice of pizza paradise.

In the heart of Rexburg lies Valley Wide Country Store, a hidden gem that offers far more than your average convenience store. Dive into their delectable offerings, from juicy chicken to hearty breakfast burritos and oversized potato wedges – a true feast for the taste buds! The locals rave about their Wednesday drink specials, a steal at just 75 cents. With a wide array of farm equipment, clothing, and friendly service, this spot is a one-stop-shop for all your needs. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or seeking farm essentials, Valley Wide Country Store has you covered with its warm hospitality and diverse selection. Uncover this treasure trove for yourself and experience the charm of Rexburg’s culinary scene.

Located in Rexburg, Millhollow Restaurant is a cozy gem that promises a delightful culinary escapade. Renowned for its generous sandwiches and delectable frozen yogurt treats, this charming eatery radiates warmth and comfort. Patrons rave about the expansive sandwich selection, with the BBQ Chicken creation winning hearts with its flavorful allure. The festive ambiance, adorned with charming Christmas decor, adds a cheerful touch to the dining experience. Regulars cherish the personalized touch of choosing toppings without additional charges, likening the experience to that of a well-known sandwich chain but with a unique twist. The longevity of 20 years speaks volumes, testament to the enduring quality and consistency of Millhollow’s offerings. For a taste of Rexburg’s best, Millhollow Restaurant is a must-visit spot that promises a symphony of flavors and a welcoming atmosphere.

Located in Rexburg, the Red Rabbit Grill is a true hidden gem, beckoning both locals and travelers with its unassuming exterior that gives way to a modern and inviting interior. Renowned for its impeccable service, highlighted by servers like Abram, Seth, and Zac, this restaurant exudes a welcoming charm that keeps diners coming back for more. The menu boasts an array of delectable dishes, from the mouthwatering BBQ Brisket sandwich and flavorful fettuccine Alfredo to the tantalizing Carne Asada Fries and RRG Burger. Don’t miss out on the must-try fried pickles and the indulgent waffles adorned with fresh fruit and marscapone whipped cream. Red Rabbit Grill is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary experience that promises to delight and satisfy every palate that walks through its doors. Plunge into a world of flavor and hospitality at this Rexburg hotspot – your taste buds will thank you!

In the vibrant town of Rexburg, El Rancho Taqueria stands out as a beacon of authentic Mexican cuisine, drawing in locals and visitors alike with its tantalizing menu. From the mouthwatering molcajete to the flavorful array of dishes, each bite is a journey to the heart of Mexico itself. Whether you’re craving traditional favorites or looking to explore new flavors, this gem promises a culinary experience that transcends the ordinary. With rave reviews echoing the sentiment of delightful leftovers and genuine Mexican flavors, El Rancho Taqueria is a must-visit destination for those seeking a true taste of Mexico right in the heart of Idaho.

Da Pineapple Grill in Rexburg brings the flavors of Hawaii and Japan straight to your plate with a touch of tropical charm. Boasting a thatched roof sushi bar and authentic local dishes, this place is a hidden gem for those craving a taste of the Pacific. The warm hospitality shines through in every aspect, from the owners’ dedication to creating a true Ohana experience to the hand-painted murals adorning the walls. Dishes like the Nu’u sushi roll and the Mahi Mahi with veggie tempura are raved about, offering a fusion of flavors that transport diners to island paradise. For a culinary escapade that marries tradition with innovation, Da Pineapple Grill is a must-visit spot for those seeking a taste of the exotic in Rexburg.

Blister’s BBQ in Rexburg is a hidden gem for BBQ enthusiasts seeking a savory adventure. Located within a Mobil gas station, this spot boasts the title of the best BBQ joint in town, and for good reason. The reviews speak for themselves – patrons rave about the succulent ribs that practically fall off the bone with each tantalizing bite. The Cowgirl meat plate, featuring a delightful combination of two meats and a side, is a fan favorite, especially when paired with their delectable BBQ sauce that diners wish they could take home in bottles. While some lament the dwindling portion sizes, the speedy service and flavorful offerings more than make up for it. Dive into a plate of tender pulled pork, savor the crispy fries (don’t forget the fries sauce!), and revel in the satisfying flavors that define Blister’s BBQ experience. A visit here promises a mouthwatering journey through the best BBQ flavors Rexburg has to offer.

Located in Rexburg, Kiwi Loco is a vibrant hotspot for frozen yogurt enthusiasts. With a wide range of flavors and an abundance of toppings, this place truly caters to every taste bud. Whether you prefer the creamy texture of ice cream or the tangy goodness of frozen yogurt, Kiwi Loco has you covered. The DIY experience allows for endless combinations, making it a perfect spot for dates, family outings, or catching up with friends. The friendly staff and clean environment add to the overall enjoyable vibe, making it a must-visit when in town. Dive into a refreshing lychee lemonade or indulge in a Girlscout Carmella cookie creation; Kiwi Loco promises a delightful experience for all dessert lovers.

If you find yourself in Rexburg and craving a quick bite or a refreshing drink, look no further than Maverik Adventure’s First Stop. This gas-station gem has garnered a loyal following for a reason. Patrons rave about the unbeatable gas prices and the convenience of grabbing a soda on the go. One reviewer even wished for Maverik to expand to other locations, proving its popularity. With clean facilities and a range of snacks from burritos to frozen yogurt, this spot is not just your average pit stop—it’s a destination in itself. So, fuel up your car and yourself at Maverik Adventure’s First Stop for a truly convenient and satisfying experience.

In the lively town of Rexburg, Pizza Pie Cafe stands out as a must-visit dining destination. This regional gem, known for its vibrant atmosphere and laid-back charm, offers a delightful culinary experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. The diverse selection of pizzas, pastas, and salads caters to every palate, with a special mention of the creative dessert pies that leave a lasting impression. As echoed by enthusiastic reviewers, the buffet experience is a true delight, allowing diners to customize their meals in inventive ways – from crafting personalized pasta masterpieces with pizza toppings to creating unique salad combinations. The consistent quality across locations ensures a seamless dining experience, with friendly staff adding to the welcoming ambiance. Pizza Pie Cafe in Rexburg is not just a place to eat; it’s an adventure in flavor exploration and a testament to culinary creativity that promises a memorable dining experience worth savoring.