Best Restaurants in Palmyra, New York

Welcome to the culinary gem of Palmyra, Mickey’s Restaurant, a cozy spot beloved by locals and visitors alike. This charming eatery exudes a welcoming atmosphere, drawing in hunters and sports enthusiasts alike, creating a vibrant community hub where everyone feels at home. With a reputation akin to the legendary Cheers bar, Mickey’s offers not just delectable dishes but also a sense of camaraderie that makes every meal a memorable experience. Whether you’re seeking a hearty meal after a day out or simply craving a familiar spot where “everyone knows your name,” Mickey’s Restaurant in Palmyra is a must-visit destination that promises good food and even better company.

Located in Palmyra, Black Hart BBQ is a carnivore’s paradise that consistently leaves patrons singing its praises. With a stellar reputation for mouthwatering dishes, this BBQ gem boasts a fan-favorite Hart Attack plate that showcases an array of delights, including standout pulled brisket and delectable coleslaw. Raving reviews mention the tender pulled pork that’s bursting with flavor, rendering sauce optional, along with must-try sides like the irresistible fried salt potatoes. The high-quality ingredients and friendly staff elevate the dining experience, making it worth the journey from near and far for a taste of their smoked Mac and cheese or the renowned brisket beans. Black Hart BBQ is undeniably a top contender in Palmyra’s culinary scene, beckoning BBQ enthusiasts to indulge in a gastronomic adventure that promises to satisfy every craving.

Palmyra’s culinary gem, Muddy Waters Café, is a delightful haven for food enthusiasts seeking an exceptional dining experience. Boasting a charming location with picturesque canal views, this recently renovated café exudes warmth and coziness in every corner. The friendly staff and regulars create a welcoming atmosphere that enhances the enjoyment of the scrumptious sandwiches, hailed as the best in town. The paninis, particularly the #2 and #4, are lauded for their juiciness, chewiness, and divine sauce, making them a must-try for any visitor. From the incredible staff to the well-appointed rooms for rent downstairs, Muddy Waters Café captures the essence of a hidden culinary oasis that promises not just a meal but a memorable dining escapade. Whether you stumble upon it serendipitously or seek it out deliberately, this café is a top recommendation for those craving a delectable experience in Palmyra.

Situated in Palmyra, Happiness Garden is a beacon of culinary delight, drawing in patrons with its wonderful food and great service. Renowned for its top-tier Chinese cuisine, this gem offers a menu filled with delicious options that won’t break the bank. The egg rolls are a must-try according to locals, described as some of the best around. Known for their generous portions, signature dishes like Cashew Chicken and Ming Ho Fun are bound to leave you satiated and craving more. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, it’s no wonder why patrons keep coming back to this hidden culinary paradise. Happiness Garden is a definite must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking an authentic Chinese dining experience in Palmyra.

Located in Palmyra, Yellow Mills Diner is a gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts. With a vast menu offering delectable breakfast and lunch options, this spot is a must-visit for both locals and travelers alike. From the rave reviews about the attentive service, exemplified by Pam, to the perfectly cooked dishes served piping hot, it’s evident that this diner prides itself on delivering top-notch experiences. Dive into a cup of their steaming hot coffee and savor each bite of their fare, all at prices that won’t break the bank. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Yellow Mills Diner promises a delightful culinary journey worth embarking on every time you find yourself in Palmyra.

In the vibrant town of Palmyra, Akropolis Restaurant rises as a beacon of culinary delight, embodying a fusion of comfort and exceptional flavors that beckon both locals and wanderers. Dive into a world where the pancakes reign supreme, with a baklava iteration that defies expectations, combining the sweet crunch of baklava within fluffy pancake perfection. But Akropolis offers more than just pancakes; the fish dishes emerge as stars, boasting generous portions that leave taste buds singing with satisfaction. From the full haddock sandwich surprise to the clam chowder brimming with clams, each bite carries the essence of dedication to quality and warmth, mirrored in the friendly service and inviting ambiance that welcomes all. As the flowers outside bloom with beauty, Akropolis blooms as a must-visit gem in Palmyra’s culinary landscape, promising a dining experience that lingers in memory and draws you back time and time again.

Situated in the charming town of Palmyra, Mark’s Pizzeria is a true gem for food enthusiasts. Boasting a diverse menu of classic and innovative pies, along with tantalizing wings and subs, this outpost is a must-visit for a delightful culinary experience. With glowing reviews showcasing the exceptional service and mouthwatering offerings, it’s no surprise that patrons rave about the large supreme pizza, elevating it to the realm of the “best ever.” Not to be missed are the buttery crusts and flavorful spices that adorn their old world pan pizza, expertly paired with a delectable ranch dressing that takes the experience to new heights. The attention to detail doesn’t stop at the food, as the restaurant’s incorporation of local history adds a unique touch, fostering a sense of community that keeps diners coming back for more. For a slice of perfection in Palmyra, Mark’s Pizzeria is the ultimate destination that promises a culinary adventure worth savoring.

Located in Palmyra, Nima’s Pizzeria is a culinary gem not to be missed. Renowned for its delectable meatball subs, mouthwatering pizzas, and flavorful fish sandwich, this eatery is a true standout in the area. With a focus on freshness and taste, Nima’s impresses diners with its well-seasoned dough, fresh cheese, and impeccable service. Patrons rave about the remarkable quality that sets this location apart from others, making it a must-visit spot for any food enthusiast in search of an unforgettable dining experience.

Situated in Palmyra, Lock 29 Tavern stands out as one of the best bars in town, offering a fantastic dining experience highlighted by the famous Evie Burger that garners rave reviews. The atmosphere is described as colorful and welcoming, with consistently cold beers and a menu that promises sumptuous delights. Delight in friendly service from the staff, like the renowned bartender Sarah, who elevates the experience with her warm demeanor. Whether you’re there for a quick bite, a round of pool, or some pinball fun, Lock 29 Tavern seems to have it all, making it a must-visit spot for food and fun enthusiasts alike.

In the vibrant town of Palmyra, Dunkin’ emerges as a beacon of breakfast delight and coffee excellence. This long-standing chain has woven itself into the fabric of the community, drawing in locals and visitors alike with its signature breakfast offerings and an array of coffee concoctions. Nestled amongst the hustle and bustle, this Dunkin’ location has garnered praise for its impeccable service, as highlighted by patrons who laud the swift corrections and dedication of the team. While the drive-thru may be cozy during peak hours, the charm of this spot lies in its efficiency and the warm welcome extended by the friendly staff. With a clean ambiance, timely closing hours, and consistently scrumptious fare, this Dunkin’ spotlights the essence of a beloved neighborhood gem. Whether you’re seeking a grab-and-go breakfast or a comforting cup of joe, Dunkin’ in Palmyra promises a delightful experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.