Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Ontonagon, Michigan

Situated in the heart of Michigan, Ontonagon is a charming town brimming with culinary delights waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant food scene, making it a haven for food enthusiasts seeking the Best Restaurants in Ontonagon. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal delights to upscale eateries showcasing the finest local ingredients, this quaint town has something to satisfy every palate. Beyond its culinary offerings, Ontonagon is also a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts, with its pristine beaches, scenic hiking trails, and picturesque waterfalls drawing visitors from far and wide. Join us on a gastronomic journey through the culinary hotspots of Ontonagon, where every bite tells a story of local flavors and exceptional dining experiences.

1. The Squeeze On Main

Located in Ontonagon, The Squeeze On Main is a hidden gem that promises a delightful culinary experience. Boasting a charming patio that welcomes furry friends, this spot is a fusion of a grocery store, a trendy bar, and a food haven. From killer paninis served with local potato chips that are dubbed the best ever to refreshing margaritas, this spot caters to both health-conscious individuals and foodies seeking a unique dining adventure. With a menu featuring mouthwatering salads, flavorful flatbreads drizzled with divine balsamic, and an array of fresh smoothies and juices, The Squeeze On Main stands out as a top choice in Ontonagon. The cozy ambiance, efficient service, and community-centric vibes make it a must-visit for both locals and travelers craving a taste of the northwoods. Don’t miss out on this culinary treasure that has quickly become a favorite among Ontonagon’s food enthusiasts!

Rating:
Price:

2. Syl’s Cafe

Prepare your taste buds for a culinary journey at Syl’s Cafe in Ontonagon, a hidden gem dishing up delightful flavors that have visitors raving. From the mouthwatering fish sandwich to the impeccable burger, every bite is a testament to their dedication to quality. The star of the show? The buns, a must-try according to reviewers. And let’s not forget the tempting array of muffins and donuts that leave taste buds tingling. With a cozy ambiance adorned with local nature artwork, Syl’s Cafe offers a welcoming retreat for food enthusiasts seeking a taste of Pure Michigan. Whether you’re savoring the best pasty in town or indulging in their famed beef pot roast skillet, each dish is crafted with love and precision. Make sure to save room for dessert – the carrot cake is said to be out of this world! So, if you’re in Ontonagon, don’t miss the chance to experience the culinary magic at Syl’s Cafe.

Rating:
Price:

3. The Little Cookie Store

Located in Ontonagon, The Little Cookie Store is a hidden gem with a devoted following. Renowned for their mouthwatering pasties, this quaint spot requires pre-orders via their Facebook page, adding an exclusive touch to the experience. Patrons rave about the perfectly flaky crust enveloping a filling of beef, rutabaga, carrot, and onion – a local favorite that keeps them coming back for more. The limited but exquisite menu doesn’t disappoint, and the occasional nontraditional flavor combinations keep guests on their toes. Despite the elusive nature of the establishment, the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked muffins and cookies adds an element of surprise to each visit. With a reputation for being the best in town, The Little Cookie Store is a must-visit for those seeking a true taste of Ontonagon’s culinary delights.

Rating:
Price:

4. Sip & Snack

Sip & Snack in Ontonagon is a hidden gem for ice cream enthusiasts! With glowing reviews praising their delectable soft serves and mouthwatering flurries, this spot is a must-visit for anyone craving a sweet treat. Customers rave about the exceptional customer service, with staff going the extra mile to ensure a delightful experience, even at closing time. Indulge in their chocolate soft serve or opt for a flurry loaded with Snickers and caramel – a divine combination that keeps patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re winding down from a hike or simply satisfying your sweet tooth, Sip & Snack promises a delightful culinary escapade that is not to be missed in Ontonagon.

Rating:
Price:

5. UP North Cafe

Situated in Ontonagon, UP North Cafe is a local gem that embodies the essence of Northern Michigan dining flair. Boasting a menu that resonates with homemade comfort, this cafe has been winning hearts and appetites alike. From the rave reviews on the delectable breakfast wrap to the hearty half-pound burger that screams freshness, every dish seems to whisper a tale of culinary delight. The mention of the generous portion sizes and the delectable strawberry pie sets the stage for a dining experience that promises both satisfaction and surprise. So, if you find yourself craving a taste of home with a Northern Michigan twist, UP North Cafe promises to be the perfect stop to satiate your hunger pangs and leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

6. Roxey’s Bar & Grill

Located in Ontonagon, Roxey’s Bar & Grill is a hidden gem that embodies small-town charm and exceptional dining experiences. With a mouthwatering menu that boasts standout dishes like the bacon cheeseburger and the Reuben burger, this eatery has clearly mastered the art of crafting delicious comfort food. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere create the perfect backdrop for savoring each bite. Despite any potential wait time, the food is well worth it, coming hot off the grill and bursting with flavor. Whether you opt for the Lil Roxey burger or any other tantalizing option, a visit to Roxey’s promises a memorable culinary adventure that will have you planning your next return before you’ve even finished your meal.

Rating:
Price:

7. Holiday Stationstores

Located in Ontonagon, Holiday Stationstores is more than just your typical gas station and convenience store. Boasting a 4.1-star rating, this hidden gem has garnered praise for its friendly staff and top-notch customer service. Patrons rave about the delicious coffee, likening it to a homemade brew, and can’t get enough of the delectable cookies on offer. With a fantastic manager at the helm and dedicated employees, Holiday Stationstores is the go-to spot for a quick pick-me-up or a savory snack. Whether you’re fueling up your car or your taste buds, this spot promises a delightful experience that’ll keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

8. Godfather’s Pizza Express

In the vibrant town of Ontonagon sits Godfather’s Pizza Express, a haven for pizza aficionados seeking a slice of satisfaction. Boasting a menu brimming with thick-crusted wonders, this chain eatery delivers on its promise of culinary excellence. Rave reviews highlight the irresistible allure of their large cheese sticks, a pocket-friendly indulgence that keeps patrons coming back for more. Guests revel in the swift service, with one satisfied customer marveling at the mere 22 minutes it took to vanquish their hangriness with a delectable ‘za. Godfather’s Pizza Express emerges as a top contender in the realm of savory delights, making it a must-visit for those craving a quick fix of pizza perfection in Ontonagon.

Rating:
Price: