Best Restaurants in Olean, New York

Clark’s Subs in Olean is a must-visit gem for sub enthusiasts within a 50-mile radius. Renowned for their original steak sub that’s a game-changer – boasting tender, flavorful meat nestled within a perfectly toasted roll alongside crisp, fresh veggies. The passion of the owner, Chris, shines through in each bite, making it clear why this spot is always buzzing with online orders and eager foodies. From the huge, mouthwatering portions to the speedy service and friendly staff, Clark’s delivers an exceptional dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to indulge in the best subs in the area at this bustling hotspot!

Located in Olean, Beef-N-Barrel is a carnivore’s paradise, renowned for its signature roast beef that has diners raving about one of the best meals ever. The old-fashioned eatery exudes charm with its wood and stained-glass fixtures, creating an excellent atmosphere for indulging in expertly prepared dishes. Guests praise the huge portions that leave them satisfied and the attentive servers who enhance the overall dining experience. Standout items like the cheeseburger wrap and the irresistible honey mustard dipping sauce for fries add a flavorful touch that keeps patrons coming back for more. With polite staff, great quality food, and an atmosphere that invites you to savor every moment, Beef-N-Barrel is a must-visit gem for those seeking an unforgettable dining adventure in Olean.

Brother’s Bistro in Olean is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts seeking a local culinary adventure. The charming atmosphere and knowledgeable staff set the stage for a dining experience that promises to exceed expectations. Start your journey with the oil/vinegar dipping sauce paired with homemade bread, followed by the tantalizing salsa and chips appetizer that leaves taste buds buzzing. Indulge in the scallops with lemon couscous and the tenderloin dish, both celebrated for their impeccable flavors. Cap off your meal with the mixed berry tart that is nothing short of amazing. Don’t miss the chance to savor the Chicken Parmesan over penne, a crispy delight that promises a portion generous enough for a second meal. Brother’s Bistro stands out not just for its delectable dishes but also for its exceptional service, making it a must-visit spot for locals and travelers alike.

Located in Olean, Mirchi Bar n Grill is a gem for those craving authentic Pakistani/Indian cuisine. The Tandoori Tawa Fish steals the show, described as incredibly flavorful and a must-try. Customers rave about the generous portions, with the lamb/chicken gyro plate being highlighted as a standout dish. The unique charm of this spot, situated in a converted house, adds to the experience. Dive into the best coconut shrimp you’ve ever had and savor warm naans with melted butter while enjoying the excellent lentil soup. Mirchi Bar n Grill is a local business worth supporting for its flavors that truly transport you to the heart of South Asia.

Situated in Olean, Rafi’s Kitchen is a culinary marvel that promises a dining experience like no other. With a diverse menu boasting tantalizing dishes such as tandoori chicken, beet salad, and loaded hummus with pita, every bite is a symphony of flavors that will leave you craving more. The recent renovations to the outdoor dining area have only added to the charm of this family-owned gem, where the hospitality is as warm as the Mediterranean sun. The staff, including the attentive waiter Will and the friendly server Treshina, ensure that every guest feels like a VIP. Don’t miss out on the cocktails and the upcoming hookah night with Tarot card readings – Rafi’s Kitchen is not just a restaurant, it’s an experience that beckons you to indulge in a culinary journey like no other.

Located in Olean, The Old Library Restaurant is a hidden gem waiting to be explored. Boasting a historic charm with its Carnegie library setting, this restaurant has been revamped to offer a delightful dining experience that is sure to impress. The standout feature? A mouthwatering 30oz prime rib special available on Fridays and Saturdays that has left diners raving about its perfect medium rare cook and generous portions. Not only does The Old Library excel in serving top-notch dishes like prohibition Burgers, smoked mac and cheese, and pesto pasta, but their attention to detail in accommodating dietary needs, such as celiac disease, showcases their dedication to customer satisfaction. With a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, this restaurant is a must-visit for locals and travelers alike looking to indulge in an unforgettable culinary journey at an affordable price point. A visit to The Old Library is not just a meal, it’s an experience worth savoring time and time again.

Tasta Pizza in Olean has been dishing up nostalgia and deliciousness since 1970, becoming a local legend for its tray pies, subs, and baked chicken wings. As one reviewer reminisced about the historical connection of Tasta Pizza to another town, it’s clear that this place is not just about food but also a slice of cherished memories. Known for their customizable pizzas with a wide variety of toppings, this spot caters to every pizza lover’s dream. The rave reviews about the excellent sauce and quality cheese speak volumes about the dedication to taste and consistency. Whether you’re a first-timer looking to explore a piece of Olean’s culinary heritage or a regular seeking the best pizza in town, Tasta Pizza promises a flavorful journey that keeps customers coming back for more.

Nestled in the historic town of Olean, Century Manor Grillhouse effortlessly marries old-world charm with a contemporary dining experience, earning its spot as one of the best restaurants in town. Guests rave about the French Onion Chicken, a dish so divine that one reviewer couldn’t resist trying almost everything on the menu! The ambiance exudes casual elegance, making it the perfect setting for a memorable meal. From the attentive staff to the well-priced menu, Century Manor Grillhouse promises a culinary journey that satisfies both the palate and the soul. Don’t miss the chance to savor this delightful gem in Olean!

Located in Olean, A&Js pizza, subs & grill is a gem not to be missed for food enthusiasts. The BLT sub is a must-try according to one happy customer who couldn’t resist taking a bite before remembering to snap a pic! Consistency seems to be the name of the game here, as another satisfied patron praises the accuracy of their carry-out orders. Ready to elevate your lunch game? A&Js promises to hit the spot with their flavorsome offerings, making it a top contender on the list of Best Restaurants in Olean.

In the vibrant town of Olean, 3rd Base Bar & Grill stands out as a gem among local joints, offering a welcoming and friendly atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back for more. With piping hot dishes and generous portions, this spot is a must-visit for both flavor enthusiasts and those seeking a hearty meal. From the irresistible Bourbon wings to the out-of-this-world chicken tender sub, every bite at 3rd Base Bar & Grill is a culinary adventure worth savoring. With rave reviews praising the attentive service and diverse menu options like pizza, flatbreads, and burgers, this restaurant is a definite standout in Olean’s food scene. Whether you’re a local looking for your new go-to spot or just passing through town, 3rd Base Bar & Grill is undoubtedly a top contender for a satisfying dining experience.