Best Restaurants in Old Saybrook, Connecticut

Located in Old Saybrook, Mirsina’s Restaurant offers a delightful fusion of homestyle Greek and American comfort foods that have diners raving. From the enticing aroma that beckons passersby to the sumptuous dishes, this spot is a gem awaiting discovery. Savor the Irish Eggs Benedict or indulge in the Philly steak omelet, where the crispy home fries and homemade corned beef hash truly shine. A haven for winter dining, Mirsina’s warm hospitality and delectable fare, like the flavorful eggs Florentino with fresh spinach, ensure a return visit is a must. Don’t miss this culinary haven if you find yourself in the area!

Located in the charming town of Old Saybrook, TJ’s Restaurant & Pizza is a culinary gem that promises a delightful experience for food enthusiasts. With a diverse menu featuring specialty pies, mouthwatering sandwiches, and hearty Italian and American entrees, this eatery captures the essence of comfort dining in down-to-earth surroundings. The raving reviews speak volumes about the impeccable service and delectable dishes offered at TJ’s. Patrons are particularly fond of the generous portions, with one reviewer praising the massive and well-seasoned chicken in their Caesar salad, while another savored the perfectly executed Grandma’s pizza with its light and airy crust. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or craving a flavorful meatball dish, TJ’s Restaurant & Pizza is a must-visit destination in Old Saybrook for a top-notch culinary experience that exceeds expectations.

In the vibrant culinary scene of Old Saybrook, Liv’s Oyster Bar & Restaurant stands out as a gem for seafood enthusiasts. Boasting a spacious, high-ceilinged room with a bar and raw bar, Liv’s exudes a trendy yet cozy vibe that sets the stage for a remarkable dining experience. Diving into the reviews, it’s evident that Liv’s excels not only in its delectable seafood offerings but also in its exceptional service. The ability to accommodate special dietary needs, like a dairy allergy, showcases the chef’s dedication to ensuring all guests feel not just welcome but truly cared for. From the tantalizing Black Pearl cocktail to the impeccably prepared dishes like BLT salad, tuna, and creme brûlée, Liv’s culinary prowess shines through each plate. Guests rave about the creativity and innovation of Executive Chef Mikey, whose culinary wizardry never fails to impress. Whether you’re savoring shrimps, mussels, seared tuna with drunken noodles, or indulging in a decadent chocolate dessert, Liv’s promises a symphony of flavors that will leave you eagerly planning your next visit. With an ambiance that strikes the perfect balance between comforting and exciting, Liv’s Oyster Bar & Restaurant is a must-visit destination for an unforgettable dining escapade in Old Saybrook.

Located in Old Saybrook, Penny Lane Pub is a vibrant gem offering a fusion of English-style bar fare and classic American comfort food that will tantalize your taste buds. Renowned for their scrumptious nachos and delectable Alfredo pasta, this gastropub is a must-try hotspot for foodies venturing through the area. Patrons rave about the cozy pub vibes, friendly staff, and the diverse seating options, including a charming outdoor area for those who prefer al fresco dining. Don’t miss out on their Guinness draft paired with a Roasted Beet salad topped with Cajun chicken, a delightful recommendation from satisfied customers. With an inviting atmosphere and well-crafted drinks, Penny Lane Pub promises a delightful dining experience that will leave you craving more of their famous buffalo chicken wrap and flavorful dishes.

If you find yourself in Old Saybrook craving a slice of heaven, look no further than Pizza Works! This vibrant Italian eatery boasts a sprawling patio perfect for basking in the sun while savoring their specialty pies and pasta creations. The love for this spot is palpable, with guests raving about the impeccable service, family-friendly ambiance, and, of course, the mouthwatering pizzas. The Rosemary Chicken pizza seems to be the star of the show, with its tender chicken, mushrooms, and onions on a delectable white base. With a nod to inclusivity, patrons are eager for a modern vegan pizza menu to join the ranks. Pizza Works is not just a restaurant; it’s a culinary experience that’s bound to leave you coming back for more. Unleash your inner foodie and embark on a flavor-packed journey at this gem in Old Saybrook!

Located in the charming town of Old Saybrook, The Essex is truly a gem when it comes to fine dining experiences. With an impressive 7-course tasting menu that promises a journey of exciting culinary creations, this restaurant is a must-visit for food enthusiasts looking to indulge in a gastronomic adventure. Guests have raved about the impeccable service and the delight of witnessing the chefs in action, adding an element of excitement to the dining experience. The lobster dish, described as perfect and generously portioned, stands out among the menu highlights, along with the fresh and indulgent salads that leave a lasting impression. The Essex’s dedication to culinary excellence shines through in every detail, from the expertly crafted cocktails to the exquisite desserts. It’s no wonder that visitors are left impressed and eager to return for another exceptional meal. If you’re seeking a culinary journey that transcends the ordinary, The Essex is the perfect destination to elevate your dining experience in Old Saybrook.

Aspen Restaurant in Old Saybrook offers a delectable array of New American cuisine, perfectly marrying seasonal flavors with a modern touch. Guests rave about the intimate ambiance, where branches from the eponymous tree add a whimsical charm to the decor. From succulent salmon to exquisite sea scallops, the menu boasts a variety of standout dishes that leave diners delighted. The attention to detail doesn’t stop at the food – impeccable service and a warm atmosphere elevate the dining experience to new heights. Treat yourself to the chowder, a crowd favorite, or indulge in the pan-seared tuna for a truly unforgettable meal. Whether you’re planning a special occasion or simply craving a memorable dining experience, Aspen Restaurant promises to deliver excellence in every bite.

Situated in Old Saybrook, Skippers Seafood Restaurant is a hidden gem for seafood aficionados. Renowned for its mouthwatering lobster roll that boasts a perfect balance of tenderness, heat, and buttery goodness, this spot is a definite must-visit. The fish and chips are hailed as the house special and a definite crowd-pleaser, while the fried mushrooms and crispy yet fluffy fries add a delightful crunch to every bite. With a refreshing Greek salad option and fast service to boot, Skippers Seafood Restaurant offers a casual dining experience with top-notch freshness and value that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this unassuming spot is sure to surprise and satisfy your seafood cravings.

Johnny Ad’s in Old Saybrook is a culinary gem not to be missed. This casual eatery boasts a menu filled with delights that will tantalize your taste buds and keep you coming back for more. From their famed Fish Tacos to the mouthwatering lobster bisque, each dish is crafted with care and precision, earning them a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re in the mood for some classic fish and chips, a hearty steak and cheese sandwich, or a juicy cheeseburger, Johnny Ad’s has something for everyone. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, coupled with top-notch service, makes this spot a must-visit for anyone seeking a delicious meal in Old Saybrook. Make sure to swing by and experience the magic for yourself!

Situated in the charming town of Old Saybrook, Parthenon Diner is a culinary gem not to be missed. With a cozy atmosphere and top-notch service, this diner offers a delightful dining experience that will leave you craving more. Dive into their mouthwatering turkey club sandwich, hailed as the best in town, accompanied by a fresh side salad that’s a refreshing twist. The attentive staff, like the standout waitress Andrea, ensure your visit is nothing short of exceptional. Don’t miss out on this hidden culinary treasure when searching for the best restaurants in Old Saybrook.