Best Restaurants in Old Lyme, Connecticut

Papi’s Taqueria in Old Lyme is a hidden gem for Mexican cuisine enthusiasts on the lookout for flavorful delights. The buzz around their chicken quesadilla and crunch wrap is no joke, drawing in crowds that pack the place on Fridays. Their Carne Asada fries are legendary, with portions that will leave you in awe. And let’s not forget the secret weapon – tamales off the menu that are nothing short of authentic magic. From the heavenly short rib tacos to the delightful plaintains, every dish at Papi’s is a symphony of flavors worth savoring. With prices that won’t break the bank and service as warm as their salsa, this spot is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of Mexico in the heart of Connecticut. Say “gracias” to Papi’s and dive into a culinary fiesta that will keep you coming back for more!

Located in the charming town of Old Lyme, The Hangry Goose is a hidden gem that has quickly become a favorite breakfast spot for many. With a staff described as “attentive and sweet” and food deemed “top-notch”, it’s no wonder patrons keep coming back for more. The menu boasts delights like Belgian waffles with a decadent topping of strawberries, cream, chocolate chips, and banana, ensuring a delightful start to your day. The ambiance, complete with a beautiful view of the water, adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your dining experience. Don’t miss out on this delightful breakfast haven that promises not only delicious dishes but also exceptional service.

Situated in Old Lyme, Cafe Flo is a culinary gem that boasts not only exceptional food but also breathtaking views of the Lieutenant River. The menu offers a variety of delights, from the must-try mushroom soup and lobster BLT to the indulgent shrimp risotto and apple fritters that will leave you craving for more. Guests rave about the attentive staff, with special mentions for servers like Jessica and Diane, who elevate the dining experience. With a charming atmosphere and garden paths to explore, Cafe Flo is a perfect spot for a leisurely lunch or a memorable dinner. So, if you find yourself in the area, be sure to make a reservation and experience this hidden culinary paradise.

Located in Old Lyme, The Stumble Inne is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Patrons rave about the happy hour nachos that are said to be simply awesome, paired perfectly with half-priced bottles of wine on Wednesdays – a true win-win situation! The menu shines with highlights like mouthwatering fish tacos and a delectable fish sandwich with sweet potato fries that are bound to tantalize your taste buds. With friendly bartenders and exceptional service, this spot not only offers great food but also serves as a vibrant hub for live music and good times. Whether you’re a local looking for a burger fix or a visitor seeking a memorable meal, The Stumble Inne comes highly recommended as the go-to spot for exceptional fare in Old Lyme.

Located in the charming town of Old Lyme, the Old Lyme Inn is not just a place to stay but a culinary gem waiting to be discovered. The restaurant within this elegant lodging stands out for its exceptional service and delectable dishes. As one delighted reviewer highlighted, the warm welcome from Tash sets the tone for a memorable dining experience, where every bite is a testament to the chef’s skill and creativity. Whether you’re enjoying a cozy evening by the fireplace or indulging in their famous Jazzy Brunch, each visit to Old Lyme Inn promises to be a delightful journey for your taste buds. Don’t miss out on this culinary oasis that effortlessly blends coastal charm with top-notch hospitality – a must-visit for both locals and travelers seeking a true culinary delight in Old Lyme.

Located in the charming town of Old Lyme, the Hideaway Restaurant & Pub is a true culinary delight waiting to be discovered. Renowned for its American classics like juicy burgers, hearty sandwiches, and finger-licking wings, this hidden gem promises a dining experience like no other. The raving reviews speak volumes – from the exceptional service provided by staff members like Cindy and Kristen to the mouthwatering dishes that leave guests coming back for more. Don’t miss out on their must-try New England clam chowder, seafood bisque, calamari, and a variety of seafood dinners that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re a local looking for a regular spot or a visitor seeking a memorable meal, Hideaway Restaurant & Pub is a culinary paradise that promises a 5-star experience every time you walk through its doors.

Located in Old Lyme, Hong Kong II is a gem for Chinese cuisine enthusiasts. Renowned for its exceptional offerings, this spot stands out as a go-to destination for delectable dishes such as General Tso’s Chicken, garlic chicken, pork lo mein, and flavorful dumplings. The rave reviews speak volumes about the impeccable service and generous portions that keep customers coming back for more. If you’re craving authentic Chinese flavors that are a cut above the rest, Hong Kong II is a must-visit dining establishment in Eastern CT. Indulge in their crispy yet tender General Tso’s Chicken and prepare for a culinary experience that will tantalize your taste buds like never before.

Situated in Old Lyme, the iconic Dunkin’ franchise continues to charm visitors with its signature breakfast fare and an array of aromatic coffee blends. With a dedicated team and steaming cups of freshly brewed coffee, this spot encapsulates the quintessential Dunkin’ experience. While some patrons noted that arriving late in the day might lead to slightly less crispy donuts, the overall consensus remains positive, emphasizing the warm service and the comforting appeal of Dunkin’s classics. Experience a slice of Dunkin’s timeless charm in the heart of Old Lyme.