Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Newton, Ohio

Situated in the heart of Ohio, Newton exudes charm and character, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts. This lovely town boasts a vibrant culinary scene that caters to diverse tastes, offering a plethora of dining options to satisfy even the most discerning palates. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Newton is a haven for foodies in search of delectable delights. As you explore the streets lined with historic buildings and quaint shops, you’ll discover why Newton is a hidden culinary gem in Ohio. Join us as we unravel the Best Restaurants in Newton, Ohio, and embark on a gastronomic journey like no other.

1. Broken Leaf Cafe

Located in Newton, the Broken Leaf Cafe is a gem that shines bright in the culinary scene. With a plethora of rave reviews, this cafe is praised for its welcoming atmosphere and top-notch beverages that are described as “to die for.” From the whimsical Pink Starburst Lotus to the comforting Lavender Vanilla Caffeinator, their drink menu is a delightful adventure for the taste buds. Not to be outdone, their food offerings like the Garden Croissant and Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Beagle are hailed as scrumptious delights that hit the spot. Patrons appreciate the friendly service and the uplifting positivity that radiates in this cozy cafe, making it the perfect spot to brighten any day. If you’re in Newton and seeking a place to uplift your spirits and tantalize your palate, the Broken Leaf Cafe is a must-visit hotspot that promises a memorable experience.

Rating:
Price:

2. Guns ‘N Hoses Cafe and Catering

Located in the vibrant town of Newton, Guns ‘N Hoses Cafe and Catering is a culinary gem that promises a journey back in time with its nostalgia-inducing decor and hearty, homemade dishes. The menu boasts a tantalizing array of comfort foods, with standout items like the mouthwatering meatloaf and the loaded baked potato that is a portion paradise. The rave reviews speak volumes about the exceptional quality of the food and the welcoming service that accompanies it. Whether you’re craving a classic like Salisbury steak or feeling adventurous with parmasean crusted chicken, this cozy cafe promises to be a delightful culinary retreat worth a detour off the main roads. Prepare to be pleasantly surprised and utterly satisfied at this best-kept secret that’s bound to become your new favorite spot in town.

Rating:
Price:

3. Sub Stop

Sub Stop in Newton is a must-visit gem for all food enthusiasts in the area. Boasting the title of the best sub spot around, this restaurant’s fresh and delicious creations have won the hearts of many. From the mouthwatering Buffalo Chicken sub to the cheesy and comforting Chicken Philly, each sandwich is crafted to perfection. The friendly owner, Nick, ensures a warm welcome, while the cozy seating area adds to the charm. Don’t miss out on their Mac and cheese bowls or loaded fries that have left patrons raving about the experience. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Sub Stop is guaranteed to leave a lasting impression with its outstanding bread and top-notch service.

Rating:
Price:

4. Big D’s Newton Grill

Nestled in the vibrant town of Newton, Big D’s Newton Grill is a culinary gem not to be missed. With rave reviews highlighting the melt-in-your-mouth deliciousness of their dishes, generous servings, and a variety of mouthwatering options like the spicy Cuban Burger and PB&JJ Burger, this family-owned restaurant truly stands out as one of the best in town. Don’t miss out on their famous wings, crispy fries, and Wednesday Pasta Night specials. The cozy atmosphere and innovative menu make Big D’s a must-visit spot for both locals and out-of-towners alike. Treat your taste buds to a delightful experience at Big D’s Newton Grill!

Rating:
Price:

5. Bistro on Broad Street

Located in Newton, Bistro on Broad Street is a gem waiting to be discovered in the town. Satisfying travelers and locals alike, this charming spot offers a delightful array of options, from the flavorful bacon and cheese wrap to the refreshing parfait. The accommodating nature of the staff shines through, ensuring that dietary needs are met with a smile. With a cozy and welcoming dining area, it’s easy to see why patrons would want to linger and savor the top-notch coffee drinks. Bistro on Broad Street truly stands out for its delicious food and hospitable atmosphere, making it a must-visit for anyone in search of a memorable dining experience in Newton.

Rating:
Price:

6. Tiger Den Pizza

Located in Newton, Tiger Den Pizza is an absolute gem that has pizza aficionados singing its praises. With a stellar reputation for exceptional service and delectable dishes, this spot has become a local favorite. Dive into their pepperoni pizza, a true standout that has patrons raving about its flavorful goodness. Pair it with their cheesy bread, a hidden treasure waiting to be discovered. The Stromboli here is not to be missed, with options like pepperoni and sausage that will leave you craving more. As a family-owned business, Tiger Den Pizza radiates warmth and hospitality, making every visit a delightful experience. Don’t miss out on this culinary treasure trove in Newton – your taste buds will thank you!

Rating:
Price:

7. Covered Bridge Inn

Located in the charming town of Newton, Covered Bridge Inn is a delightful culinary gem that promises a memorable dining experience. Offering an array of delectable options, this restaurant is praised for its generous portions and flavorful dishes. Guests rave about the friendly and attentive service, ensuring each visit is a warm and inviting one. Diners particularly enjoy the Italian fare, with the lasagna being a standout dish that keeps patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re craving a cozy family dinner or a romantic night out, Covered Bridge Inn is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts seeking top-notch quality and hospitality in Newton.

Rating:
Price:

8. Mi Amigo Mexican Restaurant

Located in Newton, Mi Amigo Mexican Restaurant is a true gem in the world of Mexican cuisine. Renowned for its exceptional margaritas crafted with love and care, this spot stands out as the best Mexican restaurant in town, according to its loyal patrons. From the phenomenal shrimp cocktail to the mouthwatering burrito and taco plates, every dish served here is a pure delight for the taste buds. The staff’s politeness and quick service add an extra layer of charm to the whole dining experience, making every visit feel like a warm embrace from old friends. With an inviting atmosphere and a commitment to top-notch service, Mi Amigo truly knows how to leave a lasting impression on its guests. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to this restaurant promises a culinary journey you won’t soon forget.

Rating:
Price:

9. Sam’s Pizza Shop

In the lively town of Newton, Sam’s Pizza Shop is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered by pizza aficionados and wing enthusiasts alike. Patrons rave about the delectable cheese pizza that melts in your mouth and the flavor-packed wings that have gained a well-deserved reputation. From surprising lunch treats to wallet-friendly feasts, this local joint hits the mark with its fantastic food offerings. Whether you’re a local looking for a reliable go-to spot or a visitor seeking a flavorful experience, Sam’s Pizza Shop promises an affordable and scrumptious dining adventure that won’t disappoint.

Rating:
Price:

10. Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

Located in Newton, Dairy Queen Grill & Chill is a burger and fries haven for those seeking a delightful culinary experience. With soft-serve ice cream and signature shakes stealing the spotlight, this fast-food gem has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering offerings. Customers are captivated by the hot, fresh burgers and baskets of chicken that are bound to satisfy any craving, followed by the perfect sweet ending with a cone or a delectable blizzard. The newly constructed building boasts a welcoming atmosphere, complemented by the friendly staff that adds to the overall charm of this establishment. A win-win situation indeed for food enthusiasts searching for a tasty meal in Newton.

Rating:
Price: