Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Newington, Connecticut

Situated in the heart of Connecticut, Newington is a culinary haven waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant dining scene, offering a diverse array of eateries that cater to every palate. From cozy cafes to upscale bistros, Newington is a food lover’s paradise. Beyond its gastronomic delights, this charming town is also home to a rich history, scenic parks, and bustling shopping districts. Join me on a culinary journey as we uncover the best restaurants in Newington, where flavors and experiences intertwine to create unforgettable dining experiences.

1. Casa Mia on the Hill

Located in Newington, Casa Mia on the Hill is not just a restaurant but a hub for creating unforgettable memories. With glowing reviews spanning from intimate weddings to staff Christmas parties, it’s evident that Casa Mia knows how to leave a lasting impression. Guests can’t stop raving about the food – from the mouthwatering appetizers like bruschetta and mozzarella sticks to the perfectly cooked steak that leaves patrons in awe. The dedicated staff, including Aida, Yvette, Helen, and Lynda, go above and beyond to ensure every event – whether it’s a post-funeral luncheon or a volunteer appreciation dinner – is exceptional. The personal touch extended to guests, like preparing a special plate of mac and cheese balls for a groom or surprising newlyweds with a platter of assorted pies, showcases the genuine care and attention to detail that sets Casa Mia apart. For an experience that combines delectable cuisine with unmatched hospitality, Casa Mia on the Hill is the go-to destination for any special occasion.

Rating:
Price:

2. GoldBurgers

In the vibrant town of Newington, GoldBurgers stands out as a must-visit spot for burger aficionados. As you step inside this cozy counter-serve joint, you are transported back in time, invoking a sense of nostalgia that sets the stage for a culinary journey like no other. With a menu overflowing with options, including their flagship GoldBurger, topped with juicy, flavorful ingredients, each bite is a symphony of taste and texture. Don’t miss the waffle fries that disappear in the blink of an eye, a testament to their irresistible appeal. The prices might lean towards the higher side, but the quality and taste make it a worthwhile indulgence, ensuring you’ll be back for more of their delectable offerings. GoldBurgers truly shines as a gem in the realm of gourmet burger experiences, beckoning all food enthusiasts to savor the magic within its colorful surrounds.

Rating:
Price:

3. Mykonos Mediterranean Restaurant

Located in the vibrant town of Newington, Mykonos Mediterranean Restaurant is a culinary gem that transports diners to the shores of Greece with its authentic and generous dishes. The menu, filled with Greek and even Italian options, has garnered rave reviews for its flavorful offerings and ample portions. From the classic Moussaka that delighted a nostalgic guest to the array of appetizers and entrées that impressed even the pickiest of eaters, Mykonos delivers a dining experience that is both satisfying and delightful. Whether you opt for the cozy indoor seating or the inviting patio, the impeccable service and top-notch food will leave you longing for your next visit. An absolute must-visit for those craving a taste of the Mediterranean in the heart of Newington.

Rating:
Price:

4. Bella Gourmet Pizzeria

Bella Gourmet Pizzeria in Newington is a true gem for those seeking classic Italian flavors with a modern twist. Serving up delectable pizzas, mouth-watering grinders, and decadent lasagna, this low-key counter-serve spot is a must-visit for foodies. With a wide variety of toppings to choose from, their pizzas are a slice of heaven, as highlighted by satisfied diners who rave about the fresh ingredients and perfect crust. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or opting for a relaxing dinner, Bella Gourmet Pizzeria promises a delightful culinary experience that will have you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

5. Cisco’s Restaurant

Located on the outskirts of Newington, Cisco’s Restaurant is a hidden gem for those craving authentic Mexican cuisine. With everything homemade, including the tantalizing hard and soft shells, their chorizo steals the show, fried to crispy perfection. Guests rave about the flavorful salsa and homemade hot sauce, offering a kick to every bite. The friendly owner, Francisco, ensures a warm welcome, while the laid-back ambiance makes it a perfect spot for both a casual meal or a productive work session. Don’t miss out on the chorizo enchiladas with over easy eggs—a true delight that leaves patrons coming back for seconds and thirds. Cisco’s is a must-visit for those seeking a genuine Mexican dining experience in Newington.

Rating:
Price:

6. Italian Gourmet Deli & Catering

Italian Gourmet Deli & Catering in Newington is a culinary gem not to be missed in the realm of Italian cuisine. With an array of delectable offerings, customers rave about the incredibly fresh and authentic dishes that are nothing short of picture-worthy. From mouthwatering chicken cutlet grinders that are unparalleled in the region to customizable sandwiches that cater to your every whim, this deli goes above and beyond. The accommodating staff adds a touch of warmth to the experience, making it a must-visit spot for those craving a taste of Italy right in the heart of Newington. Whether you’re indulging in their signature chicken cutlet grinders or savoring a bowl of hearty chicken noodle soup, Italian Gourmet Deli & Catering promises a delightful culinary journey that won’t disappoint.

Rating:
Price:

7. El Pollo Guapo

Located in Newington, El Pollo Guapo is a vibrant gem filled with Latin American flair. The star of the show? The mouthwatering rotisserie chicken drenched in sauces that will transport your taste buds to a fiesta. Diving into the reviews, the “Dazed & Confused” rice bowl seems to be a fan favorite, with its flavorful rice base, crispy Brussel sprouts, and pico de Gallo creating a symphony of flavors. Customers rave about the generous portions, ensuring you get bang for your buck, and the presentation is nothing short of Instagram-worthy. With a menu that surprises and delights, El Pollo Guapo promises a culinary experience that will have you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

8. Yannis Pizza Restaurant

Yannis Pizza Restaurant in Newington is a culinary gem that shines bright with its delectable offerings. From the best buffalo chicken wraps to mouthwatering grinders and huge salads, this spot is a haven for foodies seeking flavorful experiences. The French fries are a must-try, crispy on the outside and soft inside, while the meatballs are moist, tender, and bursting with flavor. Let’s not forget the pepperoni pizza, boasting a good crust and flavorful sauce that leave taste buds dancing with delight. With friendly staff and fast service, Yannis Pizza Restaurant promises a delightful dining experience that will have you coming back for more of their generous portions and scrumptious dishes.

Rating:
Price:

9. Rooster Co.

In the heart of Newington lies Rooster Co., a vibrant gem that boasts locally sourced roast chicken as its pièce de résistance. This New American hotspot exudes a charming industrial ambiance that sets the stage for an exceptional dining experience. Revel in the praise of delighted diners who rave about the buffalo cauliflower appetizer, a crowd-pleaser that kickstarts the meal with flair. The lasagna steals the spotlight with its smoked mozzarella and chicken bolognese sauce, earning accolades as the ultimate comfort food indulgence that leaves taste buds singing. Pair this with the unforgettable garlic bread, a side dish that transcends the ordinary and catapults your culinary journey to new heights. Rooster Co. promises not just a meal but a culinary escapade that promises to delight and satisfy in equal measure.

Rating:
Price:

10. The Honey Baked Ham Company

Located in Newington, The Honey Baked Ham Company offers a delightful array of ready-to-serve smoked hams and more, earning a solid reputation among gluten-free diners for their delicious, gluten-free options. Patrons rave about the generous portions, with one reviewer excitedly sharing about the meaty surprise found on their ham bones perfect for soup making. Amidst the pandemic, this spot has shone brightly with its well-organized service, making holiday feasting a breeze with their Thanksgiving essentials. From their top-notch lunch sandwiches to the mouthwatering ham and turkey half’s perfect for festive occasions, this family-owned gem promises reliability and excellence. Don’t miss out on the scrumptious cookies and quality meats that make every visit a flavorful adventure.

Rating:
Price: