Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Newbury, Indiana

Exploring the culinary landscape of Newbury, Indiana reveals a delightful array of dining options that cater to every palate. Situated in the heart of this charming Midwestern town are some of the Best Restaurants in Newbury, where a fusion of flavors and innovative dishes awaits both locals and visitors. From cozy cafes serving up hearty breakfast fare to upscale eateries offering a taste of refined dining, Newbury’s dining scene is a testament to its gastronomic prowess. Beyond its culinary delights, this lovely town also boasts scenic parks, historic sites, and a welcoming community that adds to its allure.

1. Shawna Rae’s Bakery & Cafe

Located in the charming town of Newbury, Shawna Rae’s Bakery & Cafe is a hidden gem that promises a delightful culinary experience. With an array of delectable cupcakes and cheesecakes on offer, this cozy spot has won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Indulge in the sweetness of the wedding cake and hoho cupcakes, which are described as “very sweet, but that’s how cupcakes should be” – a sentiment echoed by many. From the rotating menu featuring salads, soups, sandwiches, and more, to the upcoming excitement of the new restaurant, the Black Sheep, Shawna Rae’s creativity and talent shine through in every dish. Don’t miss the chance to savor the “best cupcakes” and “amazing” cheesecakes that keep patrons coming back for more. With offerings like the irresistible potato soup and tomato soup that have garnered rave reviews, Shawna Rae’s Bakery & Cafe is a must-visit destination for food lovers in Newbury seeking a taste of culinary perfection.

Rating:
Price:

2. Ben’s Soft Pretzels

Located in the vibrant town of Newbury, Ben’s Soft Pretzels is a must-visit gem that promises a divine culinary experience. The atmosphere, described as “godly” by one delighted patron celebrating an anniversary, sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. Indulge in their famous jalapeño cheese pretzel or buttery soft pretzel bites, perfectly complemented by Leroy’s Lemonade, an absolute showstopper according to one reviewer. The friendly staff, always sporting welcoming smiles, adds a touch of warmth to the experience, making it a top choice for a quick bite. With a variety of delectable treats to savor and an inviting ambiance, Ben’s Soft Pretzels is a savory stopover that promises to leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

3. Yoder’s Hand-Rolled Pretzels

Yoder’s Hand-Rolled Pretzels in Newbury is a hidden gem for pretzel enthusiasts looking for a unique twist on this classic snack. Nestled in the heart of town, this spot is a must-visit for those craving a delightful treat that packs a flavorful punch. With pretzels that are described as “melting in your mouth” and “unlike any other,” Yoder’s is clearly a standout in the pretzel game. The recommendation to skip the sauces and opt for butter and salt showcases the simplicity and quality of their products. Pair your pretzel with their hand-mixed cream soda for a perfect combination that will leave your taste buds singing. And don’t forget to try their famous sandwich for a satisfying meal that you may even need to save some for later. Yoder’s Hand-Rolled Pretzels promises a culinary experience that’s worth the visit for any foodie in search of something truly exceptional in Newbury.

Rating:
Price:

4. Jojo’s Pretzels

Located in the charming town of Newbury, Jojo’s Pretzels is a hidden gem that promises an unforgettable culinary experience. With a stellar reputation for their mouthwatering soft pretzels, this spot has won the hearts of many food enthusiasts. From the irresistible smoked chicken salad croissant to the delectable pretzel bites paired with their signature sweet mustard, every bite at Jojo’s is a flavor-packed adventure. The menu boasts a variety of options, including the crowd-favorite parmesan and cinnamon sugar pretzels that are sure to leave you craving for more. The cozy ambiance and affordable prices make it a perfect spot for a quick bite or a leisurely snack. Jojo’s Pretzels is a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly satisfying and delicious treat in Newbury.

Rating:
Price:

5. Shipshewana LaGrange County Visitors Bureau

Step into the charming world of Shipshewana LaGrange County Visitors Bureau, situated in the vibrant town of Newbury. With a stellar 4.7 rating, this gem is a must-visit spot for both locals and travelers alike. Guests rave about the exceptional service provided by the friendly staff, who go above and beyond to make your experience memorable. Whether you’re there for the Pajama Day sale or to explore the area, you’ll be delighted by the wealth of information available. Don’t miss the opportunity to immerse yourself in the local culture with a tour of an Amish milking farm – an unforgettable experience that truly sets this place apart. Indulge in the warm hospitality and wealth of resources at Shipshewana LaGrange County Visitors Bureau, where every visit promises to be a delightful adventure.

Rating:
Price:

6. Shipshewana Trading Place

Situated in the vibrant town of Newbury, Shipshewana Trading Place is a gem waiting to be discovered by avid foodies and explorers alike. The buzz around this place is undeniable—imagine a bustling flea market creating a lively backdrop for your dining experience. As you navigate through the unique offerings, from Amish couple vendors to a plethora of home décor treasures, the eclectic charm of the restaurant is truly palpable. Indulge in flavorful snacks amidst the gravel roads and immerse yourself in the spirited atmosphere praised by both vendors and customers. Shipshewana Trading Place beckons you to savor not just the food but the entire experience, promising a visit that is nothing short of unforgettable.

Rating:
Price:

7. Blue Gate Hospitality

Located in the vibrant town of Newbury, Blue Gate Hospitality is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered. With a plethora of menu options that will leave you spoiled for choice, this restaurant promises a dining experience like no other. Guests rave about the attentive service, showcasing a deep understanding of hospitality. The standout dishes include the mouthwatering meatloaf with a special sauce that elevates it to another level, alongside sides like corn and green beans that perfectly complement each bite. And let’s not forget the delightful desserts that are a must-try, making it the perfect ending to a satisfying meal. With over two decades of satisfied customers, Blue Gate Hospitality truly embodies the essence of good food and comfort dining. Make sure to visit the bakery for a sweet treat, as recommended by patrons. Indulge in this Newbury favorite, where every visit promises to be a memorable culinary journey.

Rating:
Price:

8. Country Corral Restaurant

Located in Newbury, Country Corral Restaurant is a true gem praised by both locals and visitors alike. Guests rave about the homemade bread used in their sandwiches, describing it as “soft and yummy.” The western omelette seems to be a crowd favorite, with one reviewer specifically mentioning its amazing flavor. The menu is filled with delights like French toast, cinnamon rolls, and perfectly cooked omelettes, all at great prices. The friendly staff adds to the charm of this establishment, making everyone feel right at home. Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or just passing through the area, Country Corral Restaurant promises a delightful dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

9. Shipshe Pizza & Mini-Golf, Inc.

In the vibrant town of Newbury, Shipshe Pizza & Mini-Golf, Inc. is making waves with its delectable offerings and charming ambiance. Patrons rave about the mouthwatering pizza, with standout options like the bacon cheese and the innovative baked potato pizza featuring hash browns as a topping – a true delight for the taste buds. The unique cheese dip that accompanies the breadsticks has garnered high praise, adding an extra layer of savory goodness to the dining experience. Beyond the food, visitors appreciate the warm and friendly service provided by the family-run establishment, creating a welcoming atmosphere that keeps guests coming back for more. Whether you’re a pizza enthusiast or a mini-golf aficionado, Shipshe Pizza & Mini-Golf promises a delightful culinary journey that will leave you craving a return visit to savor their delicious offerings.

Rating:
Price:

10. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

Located in Newbury, the Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery is a charming family-owned gem that promises a delightful culinary adventure. With a 4.5 overall rating, this country kitchen and bakery are hailed for their Amish-style cooking, earning raving reviews for their diverse buffet offerings. Patrons praise the unexpected delight of the fish, hearty dishes like shrimp, chicken, and roast beef, and the must-try smoked pork and fried chicken. The inclusive pie and abundance of gluten and dairy-free options showcase their commitment to catering to all palates. The welcoming staff, cozy atmosphere with a hint of Amish Country flair, and the added bonus of a bakery make this a must-visit spot for those craving a wholesome dining experience. So, set your GPS for a culinary journey filled with warmth, flavor, and a touch of country charm at the Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery!

Rating:
Price: