Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Windsor, New York

Situated in the vibrant state of New York, New Windsor is a culinary playground waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a diverse food scene that rivals larger cities, making it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. From charming cafes to upscale eateries, the Best Restaurants in New Windsor cater to every palate. Beyond its gastronomic delights, visitors can explore historic landmarks like the New Windsor Cantonment State Historic Site or take a leisurely stroll through the picturesque Storm King Art Center. Get ready to embark on a culinary journey like no other in this dynamic town.

1. Hot December Café

Unveiling a culinary gem in the vibrant heart of New Windsor, Hot December Café is a must-visit for those craving a delightful fusion of flavors and community spirit. This café has quickly become a beloved hub for locals, offering a diverse menu that includes freshly made pancakes, waffles, French toast sticks, and creamy avocado dishes that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. The ambiance is a perfect blend of chill vibes and beautiful surroundings, making it an ideal spot to unwind and savor every bite. With a calendar brimming with engaging events, it’s evident that Hot December Café isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a place to connect and celebrate the essence of New Windsor. Come for the amazing food and coffee, stay for the warm welcome and community love that permeates every corner of this culinary haven. Get ready to experience a slice of paradise in each visit to Hot December Café!

Rating:
Price:

2. Foodie Lounge

Located in New Windsor, Foodie Lounge is a culinary gem that has quickly captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a vibrant atmosphere and a menu filled with tantalizing options, this restaurant is a must-visit hotspot for food enthusiasts. From the savory wings to the mouthwatering Rasta pasta, each dish is crafted to perfection, leaving diners craving for more. The Sunday brunch experience is elevated with delights like chicken and waffles, shrimp and grits, and homemade Mac and cheese that will transport you to a downtown oasis. The friendly staff and cozy decor add a welcoming touch, making every visit a memorable one. Whether you’re a fan of hot wings, snow crabs, or flavorful tacos, Foodie Lounge caters to all palates with its diverse menu offerings. Indulge in the warm hospitality, flavorful dishes, and inviting ambiance at Foodie Lounge – a true haven for food lovers in New Windsor.

Rating:
Price:

3. Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria

Located in the vibrant town of New Windsor, Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria is a gem that has captured the hearts of many food enthusiasts. With a menu that boasts delightful offerings like the Corned beef & cabbage dinner, Supreme Pizza, and chicken francese dinner, this spot is a culinary playground for those seeking a diverse range of flavors. The friendly service and inviting atmosphere make it a favorite spot for regulars who enjoy the tasty specials, such as the spaghetti and meatballs dinner or the pancakes deluxe brunch. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty Italian meal or a delicious pizza, Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria is the perfect stop to satiate your cravings. Don’t miss out on experiencing the warmth and deliciousness this restaurant has to offer – it’s a true standout in the New Windsor dining scene!

Rating:
Price:

4. El Paso Los Contreras

Located in New Windsor, El Paso Los Contreras is a gem of a restaurant that has food enthusiasts buzzing. With a warm and bilingual welcome, this family-owned eatery serves up piping hot dishes bursting with fresh ingredients. The portions are not only generous but also incredibly satisfying. From authentic tacos that rival those in LA to homemade tortillas and real refried beans, each bite is a flavorful journey. The salsa verde is a must-try, adding an extra kick to already delicious dishes. If you’re craving authentic Mexican cuisine that’s a cut above the rest, El Paso Los Contreras is the place to indulge in the Hudson Valley.

Rating:
Price:

5. Ducktown Restaurant

Situated in the vibrant town of New Windsor, Ducktown Restaurant is a culinary masterpiece waiting to be explored. Renowned for its hospitable staff and delectable dishes, this restaurant is a true gem in the Newburgh-New Windsor area. From the mouthwatering homemade pizza to the tantalizing chicken francese and exquisite poison tacos, every bite at Ducktown is a flavor-packed adventure. Chef Alex’s specials, like the Corned beef and cabbage on St. Patrick’s day, are simply divine. Impeccable service and a lively atmosphere, coupled with must-try cocktails and sumptuous Surf and Turf dinners, make Ducktown a top choice for any food enthusiast. With excellent food, friendly ambiance, and new ownership taking the helm, Ducktown Restaurant promises an unforgettable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

6. Sofrito 787 NY

Located in New Windsor, Sofrito 787 NY is a gem that serves up authentic Puerto Rican cuisine that has food enthusiasts raving. From their huge food portions to the delightful Cuban sandwich and crispy glazed fried chicken sandwich, every dish at Sofrito 787 NY is a flavor-packed adventure for your taste buds. Standout items like the empanadas, tripleta fries, and coconut flan keep patrons coming back for more, while their unique take on fried cheese and plantains adds an exciting twist to traditional favorites. The friendly and attentive service complements the delicious food perfectly, making Sofrito 787 NY a must-visit spot for anyone craving a taste of Puerto Rican and Dominican comfort food in Orange County.

Rating:
Price:

7. Hoagie Barmichaels

Located in New Windsor, Hoagie Barmichaels is a hidden gem that promises a nostalgic experience with a modern twist. Boasting a charming old-school bar and grill vibe, this local haunt exudes warmth and character that keeps patrons coming back for more. The bartenders here are not just mixologists; they are purveyors of friendliness, adding a personal touch to every drink they serve. The menu is a treasure trove of culinary delights, with each dish crafted to perfection. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, the inviting atmosphere and fantastic food at Hoagie Barmichaels will make you feel right at home. So, if you’re in search of a fun hangout spot with good vibes and great food in New Windsor, this is the place to be!

Rating:
Price:

8. Gus’s Restaurant & Tavern

Located in New Windsor, Gus’s Restaurant & Tavern is a gem that seamlessly blends hearty German and American cuisine, creating a delightful culinary fusion. Rave reviews highlight their mouthwatering Hungarian goulash, a dish that promises to tantalize taste buds with its rich flavors. The homemade rye bread is touted as a must-try, adding a perfect accompaniment to the savory menu offerings. With a welcoming staff led by names like Richard, Keri, and Debbie, Gus’s radiates warmth and hospitality, making it an ideal spot for a weekend dinner rendezvous or even a Kiwanis meeting. The commitment to fresh, scratch-made dishes ensures a consistently great dining experience, cementing Gus’s reputation as the go-to spot for authentic and delicious fare in the area.

Rating:
Price:

9. Ivana’s

Located in the bustling town of New Windsor, Ivana’s is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Patrons rave about the delicious daily specials, showcasing the chef’s creativity and dedication to freshness. With a cozy ambiance perfect for catching up with friends, this spot is where great food and memorable moments converge. While the service might take its time, the friendly staff and outstanding dishes make every minute worthwhile. Join the locals in savoring the amazing food that keeps this small restaurant abuzz with activity.

Rating:
Price:

10. Midway’s Villa Roma

Located in New Windsor, Midway’s Villa Roma is a culinary gem that shines bright in the realm of deliciousness. With a diverse menu that includes mouthwatering pizza, flavorful wings, and tantalizing pasta dishes, this spot is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking a delicious escape. Patrons rave about the hot hero sandwiches and breakfast options, particularly the hobo, bobo, or sobo creations that are bound to delight your taste buds. The deli offerings are not to be missed either, with cold cuts that promise a satisfying meal. Dive into the flavors at Villa Roma, where every dish is crafted with love and flavor-packed freshness, ensuring a dining experience that will leave you feeling like a satisfied cowboy on a culinary adventure.

Rating:
Price: