Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Rochelle, New York

New Rochelle, nestled in the state of New York, boasts an impressively diverse culinary landscape that mirrors its rich cultural tapestry. This vibrant town, with its picturesque views of the Long Island Sound, offers a plethora of dining experiences, ranging from cozy, family-owned trattorias serving authentic Italian fare to innovative eateries that fuse traditional flavors with modern culinary techniques. New Rochelle has not only established itself as a hub for arts and culture within Westchester County but also as a destination for food enthusiasts in search of unique and memorable dining experiences. Whether you’re in the mood for freshly caught seafood, meticulously prepared sushi, or a hearty farm-to-table meal, New Rochelle’s dynamic food scene is sure to satisfy even the most discerning palates.

1. Dubrovnik

Nestled in an old-world charm that beckons with a siren’s call, Dubronik offers a culinary journey worth charting a course for. From the moment one steps through the door, the warmth of the welcome sets the stage for an evening of delectable dining. The menu, a homage to traditional Croatian delicacies, seems to whisper tales of the Adriatic with every dish. Whether it’s the seafood platter that boasts a symphony of octopus or the seared dry sea scallops that dance on the palate, each meal is a masterpiece complemented by the soulful embrace of Croatian wine or the robust cheer of a Croatian pilsner. The service, akin to the guiding stars, ensures a voyage filled with culinary delight and discovery. And for those new to Croatian cuisine, Dubronik promises an enchanting introduction that, much like the first discovery of a hidden cove, leaves one yearning for more.

Rating:
Price:

2. Pizzeria La Rosa

Dive into a culinary experience like no other at Pizzeria La Rosa in New Rochelle. Known for their mouthwatering pizza that’s been hailed as “cooked to perfection,” this quaint spot serves up a slice of nostalgia with every bite. The ambiance, filled with indie rock vibes and a lively staff, sets the stage for a dining adventure you won’t soon forget. Special shoutout to their Thursday Smash Burger night – an absolute must-try according to local food aficionados. With a menu that boasts fresh ingredients and homemade cheeses, Pizzeria La Rosa has firmly established itself as a gem in Westchester’s food scene. It’s time to treat your taste buds to a crispy, wood-fired delight that’s bound to leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

3. Colombian House

Situated in the vibrant town of New Rochelle, Colombian House is a must-visit dining destination for those craving a taste of authentic Colombian cuisine. Boasting a colorful interior that mirrors the lively flavors of its traditional recipes, this gem on Main Street has garnered rave reviews for its stellar service and wallet-friendly prices. From mouthwatering grilled chicken with shrimp in garlic butter sauce to the tempting sangria, each dish is a flavorful journey that leaves patrons coming back for more. With live music adding to the already buzzing atmosphere, Colombian House offers a delightful experience where every visit promises to be as satisfying as the last. Whether you’re a local foodie or just passing through, this Spanish spot is a culinary oasis waiting to be explored.

Rating:
Price:

4. AJ’s Burgers

Stepping into AJ’s feels like being enveloped in a warm, American comfort food embrace, complete with the quintessential burgers, shakes, and an ambiance that effortlessly marries casual dining with a family-friendly setting. From the moment you cross the threshold, the staff welcomes you with open arms—an experience that can only be matched by the delectable offerings whisked to your table. The garlic bread transcends the ordinary, the burgers are a testament to culinary excellence, and even the simple act of ordering truffle fries becomes a memorable event. The owner’s personal touch at tables adds a layer of genuineness rare in today’s dining scene, making you feel not just like a guest, but part of AJ’s family. Whether you’re a local, a college student in the area looking for a regular haunt, or just passing through, AJ’s promises not just a meal, but an experience that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left.

Rating:
Price:

5. Posto 22

Nestled in the heart of New Rochelle, Posto 22 emerges as a compact, but mighty trattoria, dazzling guests with its straightforward Italian eats, an impressive array of gluten-free options, and a wine selection that boasts over fifty varieties. The charm of this establishment isn’t just in its menu but in its ability to host memorable events, from bridal showers to birthday dinners, with guests raving about the unparalleled service, exquisite food, and the seamless organization that makes every occasion feel exceptionally special. The culinary delights such as the chicken parm that has been declared the best ever, the generously portioned pasta dishes, and tantalizing appetizers like the chicken scarp wings, all leave guests yearning for a return visit. Moreover, the welcoming atmosphere, coupled with friendly and efficient service, ensures that whether you’re a local or just passing through, Posto 22 is the go-to destination for a taste of Italy in New Rochelle.

Rating:
Price:

6. Edo Restaurant

At Edo, a vibrant and traditionally decorated Japanese steakhouse, the excitement begins the moment you step in. The teppanyaki chefs don’t just cook; they create an immersive, delightful culinary show right before your eyes, making every visit memorable. From first-timers celebrating special occasions to long-time patrons returning for the consistently flavorful and perfectly cooked dishes, the consensus is clear: Edo delivers an unparalleled dining experience. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, including the remarkable waitress Carson and the accommodating chef Erwin, ensure every need is met with a smile, making both adults and children feel exceptionally welcomed. With generous portion sizes ensuring you have a tasty reminder of your visit the next day and a commitment to cleanliness that extends from the dining area to the restrooms, Edo stands out as a must-visit destination for anyone craving an authentic Japanese meal in a family-friendly atmosphere. Whether it’s the succulent steak or the strong, satisfying drinks, Edo promises and delivers a feast both for the palate and the eyes, making every visit not just a meal, but an event to remember.

Rating:
Price:

7. Coromandel Cuisine of India

Set amidst the bustling culinary scene, Coromandel emerges as a beacon of traditional Indian cuisine, captivating food lovers with its upscale yet relaxed ambiance. My recent foray into their offerings left me smitten, not just by the culinary delights such as the savory Lamb Saag and the perfectly spiced Rogan Josh but also by their exemplary service and attention to detail. Their butter chicken and aloo naan stood out, embodying the rich flavors and heritage of India. Moreover, the warmth extended during Diwali with a complimentary dessert adorned with blessings was a testament to their commitment to fostering connections beyond the plate. Whether you’re a long-time enthusiast of Indian cuisine or embarking on your culinary exploration, Coromandel is a gem that promises an experience as flavorful and heartwarming as its dishes.

Rating:
Price:

8. Shirley’s India

Located in the vibrant town of New Rochelle, Shirley’s India is a culinary gem that has been garnering rave reviews from delighted patrons. Renowned for its delectable Indian cuisine, this restaurant has become a hot spot for food enthusiasts seeking a memorable dining experience. Standout dishes like the butter chicken empanadas and chicken tikka wraps have been described as nothing short of incredible, leaving taste buds tingling with delight. The Vindaloo, praised for its flavorful punch, continues to entice diners with its perfect blend of spices. With a menu that promises a delightful array of options, Shirley’s India has swiftly become a favorite for those craving authentic Indian flavors. Don’t miss out on this hidden culinary treasure in New Rochelle, where every bite tells a story of passion and culinary mastery.

Rating:
Price:

9. Modern Restaurant & Lounge

Tucked away in what might first appear as an unassuming location, Modern is a culinary gem that transports its visitors to a chic, Tuscan-inspired world as soon as they step inside. With its swanky vaulted ceilings and a brick oven that hints at the magic to come, this restaurant is a haven for those seeking not just a meal but an experience. From the Garlic Bread Bruschetta that will have your taste buds dancing, to the truffle chicken over angel hair pasta that promises a journey of flavors in every forkful, every dish is a testament to the modern twist on Italian classics this place proudly serves. The bar, a sophisticated highlight, offers craft cocktails that are sure to impress even the connoisseur in you, with the Spicy Margarita and the exceptional Hendricks martini standing out as must-tries. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone birthday or just in search of a memorable Monday dinner, Modern’s blend of delicious food, impeccable service, and a vibrant atmosphere makes it a standout destination in the culinary scene.

Rating:
Price:

10. Spadaro Roman Kitchen

Stepping into this lively trattoria, one is immediately enveloped in an ambiance that promises an authentic Italian dining experience with a unique Roman twist. From the first bite of their exquisitely stuffed zucchini flowers to the last sip of their meticulously selected wines, it’s clear that this restaurant doesn’t just serve food; it crafts an unforgettable epicurean journey. The rave about their family-style servings isn’t just talk; whether you’re navigating dietary restrictions or you’re in for a culinary adventure, the variety and quality of the dishes will leave you spoilt for choice— and possibly planning your next visit before the meal is over. The service is personal and warm, making you feel less like a customer and more like a guest at a family feast. It’s a place where each dish tells a story, each glass of wine sings a tune, and every visit feels like coming home to an Italian feast that rivals the best in New Rochelle and beyond. In a realm where authenticity and culinary excellence converge, this trattoria stands out as a must-visit for anyone seeking the best pasta and Italian delicacies on this side of the Atlantic.

Rating:
Price: