Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Plymouth, Idaho

Situated in the heart of Idaho, New Plymouth is a charming town brimming with culinary delights waiting to be explored. Boasting a vibrant food scene, this lovely town is home to a diverse array of eateries, making it a haven for food enthusiasts. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal coffee to upscale restaurants dishing out farm-to-table fare, the Best Restaurants in New Plymouth promise a culinary journey like no other. Beyond its gastronomic offerings, this welcoming town also offers captivating attractions such as scenic parks, historic landmarks, and recreational activities, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and travelers alike.

1. BB’s Cruisin’ Coffee

BB’s Cruisin’ Coffee in New Plymouth is a hidden gem just waiting to be discovered. This charming spot has garnered a loyal following for its innovative waffee creations. From the bacon, egg, and cheese waffee served in a convenient cone for on-the-go indulgence to the tantalizing cinna-waffee and Logan’s special, each bite is a delightful adventure for your taste buds. The local touch shines through in every dish, with homemade whipped cream and a diverse range of sweet and savory options. Pair your waffee with a robust cup of coffee, and you’re in for a treat. With friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere, BB’s Cruisin’ Coffee is a must-visit for any food enthusiast exploring the culinary scene in New Plymouth.

Rating:
Price:

2. Garbonzo’s Pizza

Located in the vibrant town of New Plymouth, Garbonzo’s Pizza is a local gem that has tongues wagging with excitement. Boasting hand-tossed pies, tantalizing salads, and scrumptious subs, this establishment is a haven for foodies seeking a taste of excellence. Rave reviews speak of house-made meatballs, luscious pizza sauce, and fresh grated mozzarella, creating a symphony of flavors that dance on your palate. The friendly staff, including the “young, curly-haired redhead,” elevate the dining experience with impeccable service and a touch of humor. And let’s not forget the colossal calzones that have patrons raving about their size and delectable taste. With a clean ambiance, reasonable prices, and options like the salad bar, Garbonzo’s Pizza is a must-visit for those in search of a memorable culinary adventure in New Plymouth.

Rating:
Price:

3. Double Diamond Saloon

If you find yourself in New Plymouth and craving a taste of local flavor, look no further than Double Diamond Saloon. Known for their legendary taco Tuesdays featuring mouthwatering smoked pork tacos at unbeatable prices, this gem tucked in the heart of town offers more than just good food – it’s a hub of community warmth and hospitality. With a bustling atmosphere where friendliness is the special of the day, this spot is a one-stop-shop for entertainment, from pool and bingo to belting out your favorite tunes. Despite the occasional surly service, the experience is elevated by a dedicated team that goes above and beyond, ensuring that your visit exceeds expectations. Don’t miss their burgers – a true delight that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table. Double Diamond Saloon is a must-visit destination for both locals and travelers alike, adding a touch of character and culinary excellence to the New Plymouth dining scene.

Rating:
Price: