Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Paltz, New York

Situated in the scenic Hudson Valley region of New York, New Paltz is a culinary oasis waiting to be explored. This charming town boasts a vibrant food scene, making it a haven for foodies seeking the Best Restaurants in New Paltz. From trendy cafes serving artisanal coffee to upscale eateries offering farm-to-table fare, this lovely town has something to satisfy every palate. In addition to its gastronomic delights, New Paltz is also renowned for its outdoor adventures, including hiking in the Shawangunk Mountains and exploring the historic Huguenot Street. Whether you’re a local looking to indulge in a culinary treat or a traveler passing through, New Paltz promises a memorable dining experience amidst its picturesque surroundings.

1. Garvan’s Gastropub

Located in the vibrant town of New Paltz, Garvan’s Gastropub is an absolute delight for those seeking a unique dining experience. Housed in an 18th-century colonial building, this gem stands out for its warm and welcoming atmosphere that exudes charm and history. The menu, crafted with care by the family-owned business, offers a diverse selection that caters to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian, gluten-free, and dairy-free options. Dishes like the braised short ribs, scallops & risotto, and the mouthwatering gf lemon polenta cake showcase the culinary excellence that awaits you at Garvan’s. With a staff that greets you like an old friend and a cozy, fun ambiance, this gastropub is a must-visit for a memorable dining experience in the Hudson River Valley. Don’t miss the chance to discover this sweet spot and indulge in the delicious fare that has garnered rave reviews from delighted patrons.

Rating:
Price:

2. Main Course Marketplace

In the vibrant town of New Paltz, Main Course Marketplace stands out as a gem for discerning foodies seeking a farm-to-table experience. This casual yet charming counter-service cafe boasts a menu that has won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Diving into their offerings, the curried chicken salad emerges as a standout, capturing the essence of culinary creativity. Dessert enthusiasts will rejoice in the Coconut Panda Petit Gateau, a delightful treat that showcases the chef’s prowess. With a dedication to quality evident in each dish, Main Course Marketplace exudes a welcoming atmosphere where every visit feels like a culinary adventure waiting to unfold.

Rating:
Price:

3. Main Street Bistro

Situated in the vibrant town of New Paltz, Main Street Bistro is a gem that beckons all food enthusiasts. With a reputation for serving some of the best breakfast delights in town, this unassuming eatery has garnered quite the following— and for good reason. Patrons rave about the hearty and wallet-friendly dishes, such as the mouthwatering Trailblazer and the satisfying chicken and waffles. The menu, expansive and enticing, caters to both breakfast and lunch cravings, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The friendly and dedicated staff only enhance the dining experience, making each visit a delight. Whether you’re gearing up for a day of adventure or seeking a post-hike refuel, Main Street Bistro promises a culinary journey that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

4. B-Side Grill

Located in the vibrant town of New Paltz, B-Side Grill is a must-visit gem for food enthusiasts seeking a quirky and delicious dining experience. This colorful eatery seamlessly combines a love for music with a passion for mouthwatering food, as echoed by enthusiastic reviewers. From the tempting “Ring of Fire” burger to the indulgent disco fries, the menu promises a culinary adventure like no other. The rock and roll theme adds a nostalgic charm, while the attentive and speedy staff ensure a seamless dining experience. With a vast array of unique dishes and diner classics, B-Side Grill stands out as a top-notch spot for both quality and value. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, don’t miss the chance to swing by this retro-cool joint for a dining experience that hits all the right notes!

Rating:
Price:

5. Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters

In the heart of New Paltz, Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters stands as a beloved gem for both locals and travelers alike. Boasting over two decades of excellence, this family-owned establishment has cemented its status as an iconic destination. From the perfectly roasted beans to the energizing cappuccinos with that unmistakable “Puddle” touch, every sip here is a flavorful adventure. Pair your drink with a “James Sandwich” and prepare to be wowed by the explosion of taste. With a cozy atmosphere, riverside views, and a selection of hot sauces that pack a punch, Mudd Puddle is not just a coffee shop – it’s an experience. Embrace the chill vibes, soak in the great music, and let the magic of Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters transport you to a caffeinated paradise that lingers long after your visit. This is not just a coffee stop; it’s a lifestyle.

Rating:
Price:

6. Lola’s Cafe

Lola’s Cafe in New Paltz is a culinary gem that beckons both locals and visitors alike with its inventive menu and welcoming ambiance. From perfectly cooked burgers to crave-worthy Buffalo Chicken Salad, this casual eatery serves up dishes that keep patrons coming back for more. The friendly staff ensures a seamless dining experience, whether you’re dining solo or with a group. Don’t miss out on their delectable cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. With ample parking and both indoor and outdoor seating options, Lola’s Cafe provides the perfect pitstop for a delicious meal before or after your hiking adventures in New Paltz. Get ready to indulge in quality fare at a reasonable price – Lola’s is a must-visit hotspot for food enthusiasts in search of a memorable dining experience.

Rating:
Price:

7. IPho

Tantalizing taste buds in the heart of New Paltz, IPho is a gem not to be missed! Known for magically transforming Pho skeptics into Pho lovers, their grilled pork, seasoned to perfection, is a savory symphony you won’t want to miss. With plentiful portions and a laid-back atmosphere, this spot promises a top-notch dining adventure. Indulge in their bánh mì, boasting tender steak and flavorful nuances that will have you planning your next visit before the last bite. Friendly faces and scrumptious sips like bubble teas and strawberry lemonades add to the charm of this culinary hotspot. Get ready to embark on a flavor-filled journey at IPho!

Rating:
Price:

8. Bangkok Cafe New Paltz

Situated in New Paltz, Bangkok Cafe is a gem for those craving a flavorful adventure. Offering classic Thai dishes alongside a selection of wines and craft beers, this cozy spot has garnered rave reviews for its accommodating service and generous portions. Dive into the pineapple fried rice or savor a spicy curry – both dishes have left patrons raving. Whether you’re a local looking for a change from the usual or a visitor from upstate New York seeking authentic Thai flavors, Bangkok Cafe promises a memorable culinary experience. Don’t miss out on this recommended spot for a taste of Thailand right in New Paltz.

Rating:
Price:

9. Los Jalapeños

Located in the vibrant town of New Paltz, Los Jalapeños is a hidden gem that has quickly become a local favorite. With a colorful and fun atmosphere, this Mexican restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic flavors and exceptional service. From the mouthwatering Avocado Tofu Tacos to the delectable Chile Relleno and refreshing Horchata drink, every dish is a culinary delight. Whether you’re a meat-lover or a vegetarian, there are plenty of options to tantalize your taste buds. The friendly staff goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience, making Los Jalapeños the perfect spot for a family dinner or a romantic date night. So, if you’re searching for the best restaurants in New Paltz, look no further than Los Jalapeños for a fiesta of flavors that will leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

10. P&G’s

P&G’s in New Paltz is a timeless gem that has been a local favorite since 1900, serving up classic pub fare and a wide selection of beers on tap in a cozy, rustic setting. Renowned for its consistently excellent food and top-notch service, this third-generation restaurant is a must-visit spot for both newcomers and regulars alike. From the mouthwatering Nachos with Sour Cream and Guacamole to the juicy Burgers with crispy Fries, every dish is a celebration of American comfort food done right. Diners rave about the generous portions, friendly staff, and quick service that make every visit a delight. Make sure to try the unforgettable French onion soup and the flavorful chicken and shrimp pesto for a truly exceptional dining experience at P&G’s.

Rating:
Price: