Best Restaurants in New Haven, Kentucky

In the heart of New Haven, lies a gem known as New Haven’s Pizza Shoppe. Known for its mouthwatering made-from-scratch pizzas and calzones, this cozy spot is a haven for foodies seeking an authentic local dining experience. Step inside through the kitchen, where the owner, Blane, is a charismatic one-man-show, delighting guests with his love for what he does and occasional musical interludes. From delicious cheese sticks to creative pizza combinations, every bite is a flavor explosion that will uplift your spirits. Whether you’re visiting the nearby rail museum or just wandering the town, a stop at this pizza shop is a must for a unique and unforgettable culinary adventure. Your taste buds will thank you!

In the vibrant town of New Haven, Old Gringo’s A-Mex is a culinary gem not to be missed. Boasting a menu filled with traditional Mexican delights, this locally owned restaurant has left diners raving about their flavorful dishes and generous portions. From the mouthwatering AL pastor to the delectable ceviche, each bite is a journey to the heart of Mexico. The friendly service and cozy atmosphere add an extra layer of charm to this dining experience, making it a must-visit spot for both locals and tourists alike. Whether you’re craving tacos with a twist or a refreshing margarita, Old Gringo’s A-Mex promises an unforgettable dining adventure in the heart of New Haven.

Located in the heart of New Haven, the LongBranch Saloon is a vibrant spot that captures the essence of the Old West with a modern twist. From mini wrestling matches to live music performances, there’s never a dull moment at this saloon. The diverse drink selection and delicious food options offer a true taste of local flavor, while the welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect stop for both travelers and locals alike. Whether you’re looking to unwind with a cold brew or challenge a fellow patron to a game of pool, the LongBranch Saloon is a must-visit gem in the lively town of New Haven.

Located in New Haven, Smoke Show Barbecue is a hidden gem beloved by locals and visitors alike. The friendly and attentive staff ensure a warm welcome, making every dining experience a delight. Known for their mouthwatering grilled ham & cheese, paired perfectly with crispy tater tots, this spot offers comfort food that hits the spot every time. Guests rave about the down-home hospitality and reasonable prices, making it a must-visit spot for anyone craving a taste of genuine Southern charm. Despite its unassuming location, once you discover Smoke Show Barbecue, you’ll find yourself coming back for more of their irresistible dishes and welcoming atmosphere.

Located in the vibrant town of New Haven, Sherwood Inn is a hidden gem that surprises even the most skeptical diners. Initially masquerading as a bar, this historic establishment unfolds into a charming restaurant, delighting patrons with its stunning architecture and warm ambiance. The attentive staff, notably Abby, exudes small-town charm while concocting delectable drinks tailored to perfection. The loaded potato skins and pepper jack cheese balls steal the show, earning rave reviews and leaving taste buds in a state of euphoria. For a main course, the pork chop dish shines brightly, complemented by velvety mashed potatoes and crisp green beans. As you savor the flavors at Sherwood Inn, you’ll find yourself immersed in a culinary journey that is as rich in history as it is in taste. An absolute must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking a unique dining experience in New Haven. 🍽️🌟