Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Hartford, New York

Discover the culinary delights of New Hartford, New York, a picturesque town brimming with gastronomic treasures waiting to be savored. Situated in the heart of charming upstate New York, this lovely town offers a diverse array of dining options that cater to every palate. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, New Hartford boasts some of the Best Restaurants in the region, promising a gastronomic journey like no other. Immerse yourself in the town’s rich culinary scene while exploring its vibrant local attractions, creating unforgettable memories with each bite. Plan your next epicurean adventure in New Hartford and indulge in a feast for the senses like never before.

1. SLOPPY JOE’S PIZZA

Situated in the vibrant town of New Hartford, Sloppy Joe’s Pizza is a hidden gem that promises a delightful culinary experience. With a stellar reputation for serving up mouthwatering New York-style pizzas reminiscent of Big Apple flavors, this restaurant has garnered a loyal following among locals and tourists alike. Diving into the menu reveals a standout dish, the Sloppy Joe’s combo, lovingly described as a nostalgic throwback to comforting homemade meals. Beyond the delectable pizzas, patrons rave about the warm and inviting atmosphere, where friendly service and attention to detail elevate the dining experience. Regulars can’t get enough of the homemade bread and buns, with standout items like grilled cheese and burgers stealing the show. As this restaurant continues to innovate with new specials and menu additions, it’s clear that Sloppy Joe’s Pizza is not just a pizza joint but a culinary destination that caters to all tastes and preferences, making it a top contender among New Hartford’s dining scene.

Rating:
Price:

2. Space NexDoor GastroLounge

Step into the culinary cosmos of Space NexDoor GastroLounge, a celestial eatery in New Hartford that is more than just a bar – it’s a stellar experience. The glowing reviews all resonate with praise for the exceptional staff, particularly Heather, who crafts liquid masterpieces that tantalize the taste buds and create a warm, welcoming ambience that feels like a home away from home. Whether you’re in the mood for a sophisticated cocktail or simply seeking a laid-back spot to unwind with friends, Space NexDoor delivers on all fronts. Pair the phenomenal drinks with finger-licking good food in a chic, modern setting that exudes relaxation and good vibes – a combination that’s bound to elevate your dining experience to new heights. Don’t just take my word for it, take a quantum leap into Space NexDoor GastroLounge and treat yourself to an out-of-this-world dining adventure that’s sure to leave you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

3. The Beer Hub

In the vibrant town of New Hartford, The Beer Hub is a must-visit gem for craft beer aficionados and foodies alike. Nestled in an old train station, this brewpub exudes a mellow and friendly vibe that sets the perfect backdrop for sampling their unparalleled selection of specialty craft beers. Not only will you be impressed by the inviting main tap room, but you’ll also be treated to an educational and personalized beer experience by the knowledgeable staff, especially the standout bartender, Chimere. With a menu featuring delicious soft pretzels and flatbread pizzas, The Beer Hub may be small in offerings but definitely big on flavor. Whether you’re a seasoned craft beer enthusiast or just dipping your toes into the scene, this spot promises a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere that will keep you coming back for more. Unleash your inner beer connoisseur at The Beer Hub – your taste buds will thank you!

Rating:
Price:

4. Prop’s Inn

Located in the vibrant town of New Hartford, Prop’s Inn boasts a rich history and a delectable menu that will leave your taste buds tingling with excitement. Step into this charming spot adorned with captivating pictures that narrate the restaurant’s fascinating past. The Prop Burger is a must-try – a behemoth of a burger that will satisfy even the heartiest of appetites! Pair it with some crispy tater tots or indulge in the flavorful pulled pork, a true standout alongside the delightful coleslaw. The attentive and friendly service adds to the overall experience, making each visit feel like a warm welcome back in time. Prop’s Inn is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination for culinary bliss and nostalgia. Plan your visit soon to savor a memorable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

5. Georgio’s Village Cafe

In the bustling town of New Hartford, Georgio’s Village Cafe beckons to all Italian cuisine aficionados. A cozy brick-walled haven that pulses with the aromas of homestyle cooking and the clinks of glasses filled with fine wine, this gem is where culinary dreams come true. Enthusiastic reviewers couldn’t contain their excitement, raving about the unforgettable greens that seem to be the talk of the town. From the delectable Risotto to the mouthwatering Utica greens, every dish seems to sing with flavor. Guests reveled in the convivial atmosphere, where reservations are forsaken for the pleasure of mingling at the vibrant bar before indulging in the delightful fare. Georgio’s seems to have mastered the art of impeccable service, leaving patrons in awe of the food and the seamless operations that make dining here an absolute joy. So, if you’re craving a taste of Italy in the heart of New Hartford, set your sights on Georgio’s Village Cafe for a dining experience that promises to be nothing short of extraordinary.

Rating:
Price:

6. Pizzeria Italia

In the vibrant town of New Hartford, Pizzeria Italia stands out as a beacon of culinary excellence, particularly for those seeking gluten-free delights. With rave reviews highlighting their mouthwatering gluten-free pizza with a “thick & flavorful” crust and the utmost care taken to prevent cross-contamination, this gem caters not only to pizza enthusiasts but also to those with dietary restrictions. The extensive menu, boasting options like Eggplant Parm and Chicken/Shrimp Riggies, ensures there’s something for everyone to relish. And let’s not forget the wings – crispy, saucy, and simply irresistible. Whether you’re a gluten-free guru or a traditional pizza aficionado, Pizzeria Italia promises a delectable experience that transcends expectations. A must-visit for those in search of the perfect pie and a true taste of Italian goodness in New Hartford!

Rating:
Price:

7. Pumpernickel’s Deli, Restaurant and Catering

Located in New Hartford, Pumpernickel’s Deli, Restaurant, and Catering is a gem that keeps patrons coming back for more. With rave reviews highlighting their generous portions and friendly staff, this spot offers a delightful dining experience. The menu boasts mouthwatering classics like pastrami on marble rye and a stellar turkey wrap, perfect for those looking to indulge in flavorful comfort food. The cozy decor, adorned with playbills and posters, sets the stage for a memorable meal. Whether you’re a fan of IPA beer or crave a top-notch Reuben paired with a local favorite like Saranac Pumpkin Ale, Pumpernickel’s is a must-visit for those seeking a true taste of New Hartford’s culinary scene. Don’t miss out on this family-run restaurant that promises exceptional service and delicious eats every time!

Rating:
Price:

8. Taj Mahal Indian Restaurant

Located in the charming town of New Hartford, Taj Mahal Indian Restaurant is a culinary gem that offers a delightful array of traditional Indian dishes. With a menu boasting lunch specials, vegetarian options, and a buffet that never fails to impress, this eatery truly encapsulates the authentic flavors of India. Diners rave about the colorful and delicious buffet spread, with standout dishes like Samosas, garlic and cheese naan bread, and Lamb Biryani stealing the show. The attentive staff, including Kiran who recommended the must-try coconut naan, ensure a warm welcome and impeccable service. Despite a recent quality hiccup mentioned by a loyal patron, Taj Mahal’s commitment to excellence shines through in every flavorful bite, making it a must-visit for those craving a taste of India in New Hartford.

Rating:
Price:

9. Cafe CaNole Bakery & Restaurant

Located in the charming town of New Hartford, Cafe CaNole Bakery & Restaurant is a delightful family-run establishment that serves up mouthwatering modern Italian cuisine and classic pastries. Patrons rave about the exceptional service and the homemade, fresh dishes that come at a reasonable price, making it a gem worth discovering. From the Tuscan Chicken Sandwich to the Haddock Francaise with Risotto and Spinach, every bite at Cafe CaNole is a culinary masterpiece. With attentive wait staff and a cozy ambiance, this restaurant stands out as a must-visit spot for those craving authentic Italian flavors in the Utica area. Don’t miss the chance to savor a memorable dining experience here!

Rating:
Price:

10. The Grapevine

Located in the vibrant town of New Hartford, The Grapevine is a true culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. With a diverse and flavorful menu that caters to both seasoned Mediterranean food enthusiasts and newcomers, this restaurant offers a feast for the senses. The standout blackened salmon, described as “AMAZING” by one reviewer, is a must-try, showcasing impeccable flavor and texture that will leave you craving more. The accommodating and down-to-earth staff create a warm and friendly atmosphere, ensuring every visitor feels right at home. Whether you’re enjoying a refreshing salad, a delectable gyro bowl, or a savory kebab with lamb and veggies, each dish is crafted with care and bursting with delicious flavors. The Grapevine is not just a restaurant; it’s a culinary journey that promises to delight and satisfy your cravings. For an exceptional dining experience in New Hartford, look no further than The Grapevine.

Rating:
Price: