Best Restaurants in New Glarus, Wisconsin

Step into the charming world of Glarner Stube, a culinary gem located in the heart of New Glarus. Since 1991, this wood-paneled nook has been delighting patrons with its old-world vibe and Swiss delicacies. Dive into massive portions of German delights and savor the best steak dinner in years, where even the kitchen staff bask in deserved praise. Be sure to try the red cabbage, schnitzel, and the Ruben sandwich – all hailed as perfection by delighted diners. With a friendly team, a great selection of local craft beer on tap, and a cozy atmosphere, Glarner Stube is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience worth every moment and every cent. Don’t miss this must-stop spot in New Glarus for an unforgettable culinary journey.

If you’re looking for a culinary adventure in New Glarus, look no further than Cow & Quince Presents Blackbird Pie Bar. This warm and welcoming restaurant prides itself on offering local fare with an organic twist, creating a dining experience that’s truly a gem in the community. From the perfectly seasoned Bisquits and Gravy to the mouthwatering Duck Confit and savory french toast, each dish is a culinary masterpiece that will leave your taste buds singing. The quirky yet charming ambiance adds to the overall appeal, making you feel right at home in this historic downtown setting. Whether you’re a fan of Farm to Table cuisine or simply looking for a delicious meal at an affordable price, Cow & Quince is sure to become your new favorite spot in town. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to indulge in the delectable offerings and friendly service that this restaurant has to offer!

Kennedy’s Ice Cream And Grill in New Glarus is a delightful culinary gem that promises a flavorful experience worth savoring. Nestled in the heart of this charming town, Kennedy’s boasts a wide array of delectable ice cream flavors that are not only delicious but also perfectly balanced in sweetness, ensuring a delightful treat for your taste buds. The menu is a treasure trove of scrumptious delights, from generously stacked BLTs to mouthwatering cheeseburgers with a soft bun and fresh toppings, offering the ideal summertime meal. The warm and friendly staff, coupled with cozy outdoor seating, create a welcoming ambiance that complements the scrumptious offerings. Kennedy’s Ice Cream And Grill is a must-visit destination for both food enthusiasts and those seeking a memorable dining experience in New Glarus.

Located in the charming town of New Glarus, Fat Cat Coffee Works is a haven for coffee aficionados and food enthusiasts alike. With ample seating, including a cozy upstairs area perfect for leisurely moments, this coffee spot exudes an inviting ambiance. Known for their excellent cappuccinos, Fat Cat is a go-to spot for a delightful breakfast or lunch experience. The attentive service and friendly atmosphere make it a top choice for locals and visitors alike. Whether you prefer a table inside the cafe or a more secluded spot behind the building, this hotspot promises a memorable and comfortable coffee bar experience.

Located in the charming town of New Glarus, Kristi’s Restaurant beckons with a unique blend of surf ‘n’ turf dishes infused with a Mexican twist, all housed within a cozy Victorian-era structure. Drawing rave reviews from patrons, this gem boasts a delightful atmosphere complemented by an attentive staff. From apps to entrées, highlights include the delectable Salmon, Wiener Schnitzel, Lobster Bisque, and Lemon Ginger Cheesecake. With a focus on exceptional cocktails and quality service, this spot promises a dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Whether it’s a romantic evening or a casual gathering, Kristi’s Restaurant in New Glarus is a culinary haven worth exploring for a truly memorable meal.

Situated in the picturesque town of New Glarus, Sugar River Pizza Co. is a culinary gem that boasts not only delectable dishes but also top-tier service. Amidst the cozy ambiance, guests rave about the attentive servers like Rita and Sierra, ensuring a delightful dining experience from start to finish. The Garden Belle pizza steals the spotlight for its flavorful toppings, while the Greek Salad and an amazing beer selection add to the diverse menu offerings. Nestled along the scenic Sugar River State Trail, this restaurant is a must-visit for both locals and travelers seeking a memorable meal in the heart of downtown New Glarus.

Located in New Glarus, Sportsman’s Bar & Grill is not your average dining spot. The owner doubling as a friendly bartender adds a personal touch to your experience, ensuring top-notch service. The menu boasts must-try dishes like cheese curds, fried pickles, and a fantastic pizza. One reviewer raved about the homemade ranch dressing, showcasing the attention to detail in every bite. Whether you’re in for a family dinner, casual drinks, or live music nights, Scott, the owner, is sure to make your visit memorable with delicious food and great specials. Dive into a world of great food and service at Sportsman’s Bar & Grill – a gem waiting to be discovered in New Glarus!

Located in New Glarus, Puempel’s Olde Tavern offers a charming experience that blends mouthwatering dishes with a touch of local flair. The atmosphere seems to buzz with excitement, especially during events like polka fest, as mentioned by enthusiastic patrons. The soft and chewy pretzel, a star of the menu, pairs perfectly with the Bloody Mary bar, setting the stage for a delightful culinary adventure. Don’t miss out on the naked cheese curds, a unique twist on a classic favorite. With a simple yet satisfying food selection, friendly service, and a cool backstory about the tavern’s artwork, Puempel’s Olde Tavern is a must-visit gem in New Glarus for a taste of local comfort and flavor.

Nestled in the charming town of New Glarus, Ott Haus Pub & Grill is a hidden gem for burger aficionados and foodies alike. Boasting rave reviews for its mouthwatering offerings, this spot is a must-visit for anyone craving a culinary adventure. Dive into their signature Works Burger, a true masterpiece that has left diners raving about its tantalizing flavors. Don’t miss out on the Fried Portabella Mushrooms, a unique dish that promises to tantalize your taste buds. With a friendly staff and quick service, Ott Haus Pub & Grill is the perfect place to unwind and indulge in a delectable meal. Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or just passing through town, this is one dining experience you won’t want to miss!

Located in the vibrant town of New Glarus, Tofflers Pub & Grill is a hidden gem for foodies seeking a casual dining experience with a touch of local charm. Boasting a menu filled with mouthwatering burgers and a selection of regional brews, this establishment has become a beloved fixture for both visitors and locals alike. The buzz around their famous fish fry is undeniable, drawing in crowds eager to savor this classic dish served with a side of small-town hospitality. Amidst the lively atmosphere, patrons have praised the attentive staff who ensure a seamless dining experience, even during peak hours. With a diverse menu to cater to every palate, Tofflers Pub & Grill promises a culinary adventure that will keep you coming back for more.