Best Restaurants in New Buffalo, Michigan

In the bustling town of New Buffalo lies David’s Delicatessen & Coffee, a hidden gem for breakfast enthusiasts. Nestled among the vibrant streets, this cozy spot offers a delightful array of customizable egg sandwiches that have become the talk of the town. Patrons rave about the charming ambience, with the bright window seating providing a scenic view to savor while indulging in mouthwatering baked goods. The friendly staff adds to the inviting atmosphere, ensuring a pleasant start to the day. Whether you opt for a vanilla latte or a cinnamon roll, each visit promises a quick and satisfying breakfast experience that leaves you craving more. David’s is a must-visit for those seeking a quaint breakfast spot with a modern twist in New Buffalo.

Located in New Buffalo, the Hummingbird Lounge is a must-visit gem for those seeking a unique dining experience. With a menu boasting standout dishes like the delectable short rib and perfectly seasoned roast chicken, this restaurant leaves a lasting impression on every diner. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere, where you can enjoy hand-battered fish and chips or sip on expertly crafted cocktails like the Negroni and espresso martini. Whether you’re looking for a special occasion spot or a casual hangout, the Hummingbird Lounge’s upscale feel without the stuffiness makes it a top choice in town. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their delightful offerings and soak in the vibrant atmosphere.

Brewster’s New Buffalo is a hidden gem in the lively town of New Buffalo, boasting a cozy cafe setting with an impressive atrium bar that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Diving into the reviews, it’s clear that their handcrafted regional Italian cuisine is a real crowd-pleaser. Guests rave about the Large Triple Crown pizza with its unique twist of pepperonis on the side of the crust and a drizzle of hot honey, elevating the flavors to new heights. The Chopped Margarita Salad also garners praise for its freshness and creativity. From delightful soups to mouthwatering lasagna, every dish seems to hit the mark, leaving diners beyond satisfied. With a friendly staff, prompt service, and a diverse selection of beverages, Brewster’s is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience that promises to exceed expectations. Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast or dinner, this spot is a must-visit for anyone craving top-notch Italian fare in New Buffalo, Michigan.

Located in the charming town of New Buffalo, Terrace Room is a culinary gem offering rustic Italian fare with a creative twist. From homemade pasta to delectable seafood dishes, every bite here is a delightful journey through Italian flavors. Guests rave about the bruschetta with apple pairing, a surprising yet satisfying combination, and the tender lamb shank that practically melts in your mouth. The commitment to using locally and ethically sourced ingredients shines through in every dish, reflecting their dedication to sustainability. With impeccable service and a picturesque waterfront patio, Terrace Room promises an enchanting dining experience that will leave you eagerly planning your next visit to explore more of their exceptional menu.

Located in New Buffalo, RIOS MEXICAN GRILL #1 is a gem for those craving authentic Mexican flavors. Boasting quality meats and a guacamole with a nice kick, this casual spot has won over locals and visitors alike. Offering dedicated fryers for corn chips and gluten-free options, the friendly and fast service here ensures a delightful experience. With outdoor seating available, the atmosphere is perfect for enjoying outstanding Mexican cuisine at non-tourist prices. Don’t miss the hot sauce with a fiery kick that keeps patrons coming back for more at this beloved restaurant.

Situated in the vibrant town of New Buffalo, The Stray Dog Bar & Grill is a must-visit gem for both food enthusiasts and dog lovers alike. With a lively ambiance adorned with charming dog pictures, this spot stands out as a top dining destination. Indulge in their Mahi Tostada for a burst of flavors, savor the fantastic Short Rib Mac n Cheese, or opt for the unique Yum Yum burger for a delightful culinary experience. The menu’s diversity is a standout feature, offering mouthwatering dishes like the Fish n Chips and the Chicken Salad with garlic fries. With attentive and friendly service, alongside a clean atmosphere, The Stray Dog Bar & Grill promises a memorable dining experience that will have you coming back for more. Don’t miss the chance to sample their signature dishes and soak in the welcoming rooftop patio vibes, making it a perfect spot for a delectable meal any time you’re in town.

Located in the vibrant town of New Buffalo, Song Asian Cuisine delivers a dining experience that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more. This gem offers a delightful fusion of sushi and Chinese classics in a charming setting adorned with cute Asian decor. The reviews rave about the impeccable cleanliness, attentive service, and, most importantly, the mouthwatering dishes. From the perfectly crispy tempura to the flavorful General Tso chicken, every bite is a culinary delight. Don’t miss the opportunity to savor their fresh seaweed salad and top-notch pho. With such glowing recommendations, Song Asian Cuisine is a must-visit for anyone searching for the best restaurants in New Buffalo.

Located in the vibrant town of New Buffalo, Al Fuego Grill & Bar is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Boasting an extensive and impressive menu, this eatery is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking exceptional breakfast and lunch options. The breakfast crepes are a standout, described as nothing short of amazing by patrons who can’t get enough of the generous portions and affordable prices. The hearty chorizo scramble and flavorful chilaquiles are must-tries, showcasing the chef’s dedication to quality and taste. With friendly staff and a lively atmosphere, Al Fuego Grill & Bar promises a dining experience that’s as delightful as it is delicious. Don’t miss out on this Mexican-infused culinary adventure, where every bite is a celebration of flavor and satisfaction.

Located at the Marina Grand Resort in New Buffalo, Bentwood Tavern offers a chic dining experience that has captured the hearts and taste buds of its patrons. Globally inspired comfort food made from local ingredients takes center stage at this must-visit spot. Diners rave about the delectable dishes like crispy chicken thighs with a yogurt sauce, grouper with cilantro rice and burst tomatoes, spare rib ragù, and the mouthwatering white fish with capers and tomatoes. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff add a special touch to the overall dining experience, making it the perfect destination for a romantic date night or a family outing. With a menu that promises culinary delights and a setting that exudes sophistication and warmth, Bentwood Tavern is a top contender for the best restaurants in New Buffalo.

Located in New Buffalo, the Woodlands Course at Whittaker is a hidden gem that offers so much more than just a round of golf. The glowing reviews speak volumes about the impeccable service provided by Rik Durkin, who goes above and beyond to ensure every detail is perfect. The venue’s elegant setting, surrounded by lush natural beauty, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. Guests rave about the mouthwatering Italian buffet that leaves taste buds tingling. The staff’s friendliness and the challenging yet enjoyable course make this spot a must-visit when in the area. Whether you’re a seasoned golfer or just getting into the swing of things, a day at Whittaker Woods promises to be an unforgettable experience that strikes the perfect balance between luxury and adventure.