Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in New Albany, Indiana

Located in the charming town of New Albany, Indiana, discerning foodies and avid travelers alike will discover a culinary haven waiting to be explored. This lovely town boasts a vibrant dining scene, making it a hotspot for gastronomical delights. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, New Albany is a paradise for food enthusiasts eager to indulge in a myriad of flavors. In addition to its gastronomic offerings, this quaint town also features an array of attractions, promising visitors a memorable experience beyond just dining. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor passing through, immerse yourself in the best restaurants in New Albany for an unforgettable culinary journey.

1. Board and You Bistro & Wine Bar

Located in New Albany, Board and You Bistro & Wine Bar is a hidden gem that promises a culinary journey like no other. With a warm and cozy ambiance that feels like a home away from home, this bistro exudes charm and sophistication. The menu, curated with creativity and passion, boasts dishes that are both visually stunning and bursting with flavor. From the delightful charcuterie board to the mouthwatering short ribs on risotto, each bite tells a story of culinary excellence. The attentive staff, led by the dedicated owner Zack, ensures a personalized experience that elevates every sip of wine and every bite of food. Whether you’re popping in for snacks and a glass of wine or treating yourself to a full dining experience, Board and You promises to exceed your expectations with its impeccable service and unwavering commitment to hospitality. Indulge in the Shrimp Cocktail or savor the fresh greens, but whatever you do, make a reservation and treat yourself to an unforgettable evening at this top-tier establishment.

Rating:
Price:

2. Agave & Rye New Albany

Agave & Rye in New Albany is a haven for foodies looking to embark on a culinary adventure in this vibrant town. The buzz around their Birria tacos is undeniable, drawing in patrons seeking a flavor-packed experience like no other. From the rave reviews praising the polite service and timely orders to the creative dishes like the brussels appi and sugar daddy taco that are simply unforgettable, this spot exudes a trendy, artsy charm that sets it apart. With a mix of strong and delicious drinks, along with a welcoming atmosphere whether you choose to dine inside or outside, Agave & Rye promises a memorable gastronomic journey worth braving any nearby construction woes. Indulge in their must-try items and savor the essence of this culinary gem that beckons you to taste perfection in every bite.

Rating:
Price:

3. The Exchange Pub + Kitchen

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen in New Albany is a culinary treasure trove that promises a delightful dining experience. With a commitment to using locally sourced ingredients, this rustic-chic gastropub offers a menu that continuously surprises and delights its patrons. From the delectable fish and chips to the mouth-watering goat cheese balls, each dish is crafted with precision and flair, ensuring a memorable meal every visit. The cozy ambiance sets the stage for a perfect date night, complete with live music and a diverse selection of drinks, including local whiskey and a variety of beers. The attentive staff, like the charming Anastasia, goes above and beyond to make your dining experience top-notch. Whether you’re craving a juicy burger or a comforting bowl of squash soup, The Exchange Pub + Kitchen is a must-visit destination for anyone looking to savor the best of New American cuisine.

Rating:
Price:

4. Dragon King’s Daughter

Located in the vibrant town of New Albany, Dragon King’s Daughter is a culinary gem not to be missed. With rave reviews praising their delicious specialty rolls and sashimi, it’s no surprise that diners are flocking to this hotspot. Guests have marveled at the overflowing and fresh small salads, alongside standout dishes like the Mama Ain’t Right Sushi Roll and the fan-favorite Chupacabra Roll. The fusion of Oriental and Mexican flavors in their Spicy Miso Ramen has left taste buds tingling in delight. Add in exceptional service and even unique restroom facilities with a surprise bidet, and you have a dining experience that truly stands out from the crowd. Whether you’re a sushi enthusiast or ramen aficionado, Dragon King’s Daughter promises a fantastic meal from start to finish.

Rating:
Price:

5. Wild Eggs New Albany

Located in the vibrant town of New Albany, Wild Eggs is a breakfast haven that promises a warm and welcoming dining experience. With rave reviews highlighting their attentive service and flavorful dishes, this spot is a gem for both locals and visitors. Indulge in the decadent Pumpkin Pie Pancakes or savor the Wild Mushroom & Roasted Garlic Scramble, where freshness and quality shine through. The Mad Platter breakfast is a definite must-try, showcasing a symphony of flavors that will leave your taste buds singing. And don’t miss out on their creative omelettes, like the Wild Mushroom and Goat Cheese option that has diners raving. Wild Eggs is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience that promises a delightful meal and a memorable time. Join the locals in supporting this culinary gem and treat yourself to a breakfast adventure worth savoring in New Albany.

Rating:
Price:

6. La Catrina Mexican Kitchen

With colorful decor and a lively ambiance, La Catrina Mexican Kitchen in New Albany promises an unforgettable dining experience. Guests rave about the lightning-fast service and potent margaritas that pack a flavorful punch without overwhelming the palate. The menu, filled with diverse taco options to cater to every taste bud, showcases the authenticity and love put into each dish by the dedicated family-run establishment. Sip on a refreshing sangria-rita or the intriguing Azul margarita while savoring loaded tacos and exploring the toppings bar for a customized culinary adventure. Whether you’re a margarita aficionado or a taco enthusiast, La Catrina is a must-visit spot for a fun and delicious Mexican feast in the heart of New Albany.

Rating:
Price:

7. Brooklyn and The Butcher

In the heart of New Albany, Brooklyn and The Butcher stands out as a gem among the city’s culinary offerings. This stylish contemporary space offers an impressive array of steaks, small plates, and a delightful selection from the raw bar. The reviews sing praises of the delectable dishes, with highlights including the mouthwatering Au Pivore, succulent NY strip steaks cooked to perfection, and the irresistible twice-baked loaded potato. Guests rave about the charming Victorian home ambiance, giving off an air of high-class sophistication paired with a laid-back atmosphere. From the delectable house-made lemonade to the smooth sips of Moscato, every detail at Brooklyn and The Butcher seems to be carefully curated for a top-notch dining experience. Whether you’re in for a casual brunch with a savory Smash burger or an elegant customer appreciation dinner, this restaurant promises to deliver unforgettable flavors and impeccable service that will keep you coming back for more. It’s a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a culinary adventure in New Albany!

Rating:
Price:

8. Toast On Market

Situated in the vibrant town of New Albany, Toast On Market is a must-visit gem for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful culinary experience. This cozy daytime cafe has garnered a loyal following for its all-day breakfast offerings that go above and beyond. Patrons rave about the exceptional service, with Andrew being hailed as a standout server for his timely, friendly, and knowledgeable approach. The menu boasts standout dishes like the western scrambler special with homemade pico cream sauce and the indulgent cinnamon roll that has diners coming back for more. From the warm and yummy biscuits to the perfectly prepared entrees, each bite at Toast On Market is a flavorful journey worth savoring. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or a leisurely brunch, this spot promises a delicious meal and top-notch service that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your last bite.

Rating:
Price:

9. Recbar 812

Situated in the lively town of New Albany is Recbar 812, a vibrant hangout pulsating with the nostalgia of old-school pinball machines and vintage arcade games. Boasting a wide array of pub grub and craft beers on tap, this establishment is a haven for both the young and the young at heart. One enthusiastic reviewer commended the venue for its ideal space for kids’ birthday parties, complete with delicious fare and a plethora of gaming options. Despite some accessibility challenges for differently-abled patrons, the prompt and attentive staff swiftly rectified any hiccups, ensuring a memorable experience for all. Whether seeking a nostalgic trip down memory lane or a fun night out with loved ones, Recbar 812 promises a lively atmosphere and delectable treats that will leave you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

10. PARLOUR

In the vibrant town of New Albany, situated off State Rd 11, PARLOUR emerges as a gem for food enthusiasts seeking a flavorful experience. Boasting a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, this establishment has garnered a loyal following for its hearty portions and impeccable service. Whether you’re craving the zesty wings that are hailed as legendary or indulging in the tantalizing hot honey pepperoni pizza, each bite at PARLOUR is a culinary adventure waiting to be savored. The inviting atmosphere coupled with the attentive staff, like the renowned server Jay, elevates the dining experience to new heights. Embrace the opportunity to explore the eclectic offerings at PARLOUR and unlock a gastronomic journey that promises to delight your taste buds with each visit.

Rating:
Price: