Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Monroe, New York

Monroe, nestled in the scenic state of New York, is a charming town that boasts a delightful array of dining options for both the casual diner and the gourmet enthusiast. This town, renowned for its picturesque landscapes and rich historical background, is home to a vibrant culinary scene that reflects a perfect blend of traditional flavors and contemporary culinary innovation. From cozy cafes serving up hearty, homemade breakfasts to sophisticated restaurants offering exquisite interpretations of classic dishes, Monroe caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences. Whether you’re in the mood for an authentic Italian feast, a taste of American comfort food, or exotic international cuisine, Monroe’s culinary offerings are sure to impress. The town’s commitment to showcasing local produce and featuring seasonal menus further enhances the dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers.

1. Tequila Grille

Located in Monroe, Tequila Grille is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. With a warm and welcoming staff, stepping into this restaurant feels like a homecoming, where hospitality reigns supreme. The menu is a delightful fusion of flavors, from the mouthwatering Tequila Grill shrimp to the generous portions of Chicken Francais that leave diners raving. Guests can enjoy their meals on the picturesque outdoor terrace, overlooking the stunning golf course, creating a serene backdrop for a memorable dining experience. Don’t miss out on the first-round drink that’s sure to set the bar high, just like the overall experience at Tequila Grille. Whether you’re a fan of authentic German dishes or seeking a fresh and delicious culinary adventure, this restaurant is a must-visit hotspot in Monroe.

Rating:
Price:

2. Empanada Master

Nestled unassumingly along a well-traversed road, Empanada Master emerges as a culinary gem that demands a pit stop. A beacon of satisfaction for both the adventurous foodie and the famished traveler, this food truck serves up a delightful menu that shines a spotlight on empanadas, which have garnered rave reviews for their fresh, non-greasy, and flavor-packed offerings. While the tres leches cake may not have stolen everyone’s heart, the corn nuggets, chicken, beef, and pernil empanadas certainly have, with their perfectly fried, savory fillings wrapped in phenomenally doughy hugs. The friendly service only enhances the experience, making it a must-visit for anyone in search of authentic, wallet-friendly, and utterly delicious bites. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Empanada Master is a culinary pit stop that promises to turn first-time visitors into regulars.

Rating:
Price:

3. Yune’s Sushi

Nestled conveniently near the bustling Woodbury Commons Outlet Stores, Yune’s Sushi offers a culinary escape to those seeking a splendid fusion of sushi, sashimi, and Korean cuisine. From the moment I stepped into its inviting atmosphere, filled with patrons enjoying their dining experience, I knew I was in for a treat. The ‘Dinosaur Eggs’ and kimchi soup stood out for their size and flavor, respectively, leaving an impression of both surprise and delight. While the miso soup may not have been the highlight for some, the array of favorites like warm sake, ceviche, coconut shrimp, and the innovative diablo rolls more than made up for it. Despite its limited options for the younger diners, Yune’s Sushi impresses with its commitment to fresh, beautifully prepared dishes and impeccable service, firmly establishing itself as a must-visit destination for aficionados of Asian cuisine.

Rating:
Price:

4. Captain’s Table

Nestled in a spot that easily masquerades as a simple bar from the front, this long-standing surf ‘n’ turf gem reveals its true culinary canvas to those adventurous enough to explore its nautically-themed premises. With an enclosed dining room, cozy patio, and live bands setting the weekend mood, the restaurant surprises with its robust menu, where the chef’s prowess elevates every dish from mere meals to memorable dining experiences. Whether it’s the impeccably cooked salmon burger with just the right kick of Sriracha mayo, the delicate balance of flavors in the kale and calamari, or the exquisite fried calamari that calls for an encore, each bite promises a voyage of taste. The backdrop of a live band on the outdoor patio, along with the spot’s dedication to impeccable service, transforms a simple meal into an occasion, making it not just a stop but a destination for both locals and visitors alike.

Rating:
Price:

5. Plum House Japanese Restaurant

Tucked away in a cozy corner, Plum House emerges as a beacon of Japanese culinary delights, blending the traditional art of sushi with the dynamic flare of teppanyaki and teriyaki. From the first bite of their Crispy Plum House roll to the last sip of sake, my palate embarked on an exquisite journey through flavors both nuanced and bold. The ambiance of the restaurant, described as casual, belies the sophistication of the dishes served within its walls. A medley of options such as the spicy Monroe Soup and the innovative Never Know Roll ensures that each visit is a tantalizing adventure. The praise for their fresh, flavorful offerings is unanimous among patrons, and it’s clear that whether you’re a sushi aficionado or a teppanyaki enthusiast, Plum House promises an unforgettable dining experience. The attentive service and reasonable prices further elevate the overall experience, making it a must-visit for food lovers in search of authentic Japanese cuisine.

Rating:
Price:

6. Somni NY Tapas

Located in Monroe, Somni NY Tapas is a culinary gem that promises an exquisite dining experience. Embark on a tantalizing journey with their Orange/Strawberry French Toast and Short Ribs Benedict, boasting a symphony of flavors that will leave your taste buds singing with joy. The immersive atmosphere adds to the charm, as the attentive staff ensures a remarkable visit. Whether you’re drawn to their cozy fireplace or the lively outdoor patio, every corner of the restaurant exudes warmth and hospitality. Indulge in their gluten-free options like the steamed buns or savor the decadent French toast that will have you clearing your plate with delight. For a truly unforgettable brunch or special event occasion, Somni NY Tapas is a must-visit destination that promises to exceed your expectations and create lasting memories.

Rating:
Price:

7. Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar

Nestled in an upscale ambiance, Scalia & Co crafts an experience that transcends the typical Italian dining encounter, whisking its patrons away to a culinary landscape where homemade pasta and pizza reign supreme. The restaurant may not boast expansive quarters, yet its ingenious seating arrangements and an inviting bar area ensure a cozy and engaging environment. Service here is more than just a transaction; it’s a warm, personal affair, with staff like Flutur going above and beyond to accommodate every whim with a smile. While the majority of dishes receive high praise for their authenticity and flavor, mirroring a Sunday dinner at Nonna’s, even the rare constructive feedback is met with prompt and thoughtful action, underscoring the establishment’s commitment to culinary excellence. Whether you’re in for the food that tastes of tradition or the innovative wine on tap, Scalia & Co curates an unforgettable dining experience, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking the soul of Italy in every bite.

Rating:
Price:

8. Tulcingo

Tucked away in a modest strip mall lies a vibrant culinary haven that champions the rich flavors of Mexico from dawn till dusk, coupled with an enticing array of margaritas and cocktails that promise to dazzle. The restaurant, a treasure for both the gastronomically adventurous and those seeking solace in familiar comfort food, offers an array of dishes that are nothing short of outstanding. The spicy pork burrito and tacos have been lauded as a revelation, while the chimichangas and guacamole stand out for their authenticity and flavor. The ambiance, though cozy, buzzes with the excitement of diners indulging in their favorite margaritas and salsa, a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality and the sheer joy of Mexican cuisine. Attentive, polite, and helpful service adds to the allure, making every meal a memorable experience. Whether it’s the charm of a compact space filled with satisfied patrons or the delight of a seven-month-old enjoying their refried beans, this gem in the culinary landscape is a must-visit for anyone craving a genuine taste of Mexico.

Rating:
Price:

9. Jalisco

Monroe’s culinary scene just got a whole lot spicier with Jalisco, a vibrant gem serving up mouthwatering, authentic Mexican cuisine. Dive into their loaded nacho appetizers that promise a fiesta in every bite. The combos are a must-try, perfectly paired with extra guac that will have your taste buds doing the salsa. But the real star of the show? The margaritas! Fresh, zesty, and dangerously good – just like the ambiance and service here. With promo deals that make every penny count, Jalisco is a flavor fiesta waiting to be revisited time and time again. Ole!

Rating:
Price:

10. Bourbon Street Bar & Grill

Nestled in a New Orleans-inspired atmosphere, this local eatery offers a delightful surprise to those who might underestimate its charm at first glance. Despite its unassuming appearance and the occasional sketchy character in the parking lot, the restaurant shines with its culinary offerings—ranging from mouthwatering burgers accompanied by Cajun fries to the perfectly crispy fried pickles, though the unique choice of English muffins as burger buns may raise an eyebrow. The establishment’s ability to host memorable events, as evidenced by a smoothly handled surprise retirement party, speaks volumes of the attentive and amiable staff, ready to cater to both quiet family dinners and lively gatherings. With a vibe that’s both clean and bright, this spot promises an experience that goes beyond the typical bar and grill, offering a warm welcome and an even warmer farewell that assures you’ll be planning your next visit before you’ve even left.

Rating:
Price: