Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Milton, Ohio

Situated in the heart of Ohio, Milton beckons with a culinary scene that’s sure to tantalize the taste buds of even the most discerning food enthusiasts. This lovely town boasts a diverse array of eateries, making it a haven for foodies seeking the Best Restaurants in Milton. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal coffee to upscale dining establishments showcasing farm-to-table fare, this quaint town has something for every palate. Beyond its gastronomic delights, Milton also offers a myriad of attractions, including historic landmarks, picturesque parks, and vibrant cultural events. Get ready to embark on a gastronomic journey through one of Ohio’s most charming destinations.

1. The Prop House

Located in Milton, The Prop House is a culinary hotspot that has locals raving about its delicious offerings. With an array of seating options, including cozy booths and high-top tables, this restaurant effortlessly caters to every diner’s preference. The diverse menu boasts mouthwatering sandwiches, burgers, steaks, and enticing entrees that are perfectly prepared to tantalize your taste buds. Don’t miss out on their unique Cherry Pop drink, a definite crowd-pleaser. Friendly staff, a clean and inviting atmosphere, and standout dishes like the peanut butter and jelly hamburger and pineapple pork chop make dining at The Prop House an unforgettable experience. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, this gem is sure to leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price:

2. Halliday’s Winery

Halliday’s Winery in Milton is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. With a breathtaking view of Lake Milton, this spot offers an unforgettable dining experience. The fig pizza, cooked to perfection, is a standout on their menu, alongside the cherry tomato bruschetta. The laid-back atmosphere is perfect for enjoying their impressive drink selection, including the Concord grape wine that’s like “adult grape juice.” Whether you choose to dine indoors or outdoors, you’re in for a treat. Plus, events like trivia nights and trunk or treat make this winery a must-visit destination for families and friends alike. Get ready to be wowed by the great food, friendly staff, and overall outdoor experience at Halliday’s Winery.

Rating:
Price:

3. Stone Age Pizza

Located in the vibrant town of Milton, Stone Age Pizza is a culinary gem that has been turning heads for all the right reasons. Nestled on the shores of Lake Milton, this pizza haven has quickly become a favorite among locals and travelers alike. Their menu is a symphony of flavors, with standout dishes like loaded wings, mouthwatering calzones, and a colossal sandwich that is sure to leave you speechless. The attention to detail shines through in every bite, from the generously topped pizzas to the hearty pepperoni rolls. With prices that won’t break the bank, Stone Age Pizza offers a dining experience that is not only delicious but also budget-friendly. The friendly staff adds an extra layer of warmth to this already inviting atmosphere, making every visit a memorable one. Don’t miss out on the chance to indulge in their cheesy goodness – your taste buds will thank you!

Rating:
Price:

4. Kyps Restaurant

Located in the charming town of Milton, Kyps Restaurant is a delightful gem that exudes nostalgia and simplicity. Patrons rave about their double burger with fries, chocolate malt, and delectable sandwiches, all at unbeatable prices. The classic beach and fish decor, complete with a retro jukebox and arcade machine, transport diners back to the carefree days of the 70s and 80s. With fresh-tasting fries, perfect burgers, and delicious milkshakes, this mom and pop shop is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of small-town hospitality and affordable, high-quality comfort food. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Kyps Restaurant promises a dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

5. Castaway Craig’s Pub & Grub

Located in Milton, Castaway Craig’s Pub & Grub is a culinary treasure that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. The tantalizing menu boasts crowd-pleasers like the Reuben sandwich and the Philly sub, which have left diners raving about their flavorful perfection. From hot and crispy tots baskets to mouthwatering Mojo Chicken, every dish is a symphony of taste that keeps patrons coming back for more. With a welcoming atmosphere, live music, and friendly staff like bartender Amanda who make you feel right at home, this restaurant is not just a dining experience but a community gathering spot. Whether you’re a food enthusiast or a karaoke lover, Castaway Craig’s Pub & Grub promises a memorable dining escapade that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price:

6. Westfall’s Family Restaurant

Located in the bustling town of Milton, Westfall’s Family Restaurant has quickly become a must-visit gem for food enthusiasts craving a memorable dining experience. As one reviewer raves about the pressure fried chicken and Jo Jo’s, it’s evident that this eatery takes comfort food to new heights, ensuring each bite is packed with flavor and care. With a recent change in ownership, the attention to detail shines through, as highlighted by another patron who praised the thin-sliced bacon as the best they’ve ever had. From the warm hospitality of the owner to the impeccable service of servers like Karen, Westfall’s exudes a charm that extends beyond just a meal, making it a destination where culinary delights and genuine care converge seamlessly. For those seeking a delectable escape in Milton, Westfall’s Family Restaurant promises a savory journey worth savoring.

Rating:
Price:

7. Olde Dutch Mill Golf Course & Sports Facility

Located in Milton, Olde Dutch Mill Golf Course & Sports Facility is more than just a place to tee off; it’s a hidden culinary gem waiting to be discovered. With rave reviews praising the challenging yet well-maintained course, it’s evident that this spot is a golfer’s paradise. And the real hole-in-one? The food! From mouthwatering Rubin sandwiches that outshine competitors to delectable bacon chicken wraps and perfectly crispy fries, every dish seems to hit the mark with diners. With a staff that goes above and beyond to make your experience memorable, this spot is not just about birdies and bogeys, but also about savoring delightful bites in between swings. So, whether you’re perfecting your golf game or simply craving a delicious meal, Olde Dutch Mill is a must-visit for a truly satisfying experience in Milton.

Rating:
Price:

8. Ai Kah Garden

Located in the vibrant town of Milton, Ai Kah Garden is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With rave reviews highlighting the exceptional flavors and fast service, this restaurant has solidified its reputation as a must-visit destination for foreign cuisine enthusiasts. Diving into their menu promises a delightful journey through a world of delectable dishes, making it a top contender for the title of the best restaurant in Milton. Unleash your taste buds and experience the magic of Ai Kah Garden for yourself!

Rating:
Price:

9. Gionino’s Pizzeria

Tucked in Milton, Gionino’s Pizzeria presents a slice of heaven for pizza enthusiasts. Unveiling a delectable array of pies, pastas, and subs, this down-to-earth establishment has locals hooked, with one rave review suggesting ordering the pizza “well done” for optimal flavor. From the tempting Caprese pizza to mouthwatering honey mustard wings, each bite paints a picture of culinary craftsmanship. Not to be missed is the Deluxe sub, brimming with a generous bounty of cold cuts and veggies, offering a quick and affordable savory delight. Delighting patrons with the “BEST garlic bread” around, Gionino’s proves to be a gastronomic haven where flavors dance harmoniously on every plate. A must-visit spot for pizza aficionados seeking a taste sensation that lingers long after the meal is over.

Rating:
Price: