Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Middletown, New York

Unveil the culinary treasures of Middletown, New York, a vibrant hub for food aficionados and avid travelers alike. This charming town boasts a dynamic culinary scene, offering a plethora of gastronomic delights sure to tantalize your taste buds. From fusion eateries to cozy cafes and upscale fine dining establishments, Middletown is a haven for foodies seeking an unforgettable dining experience. Amidst its inviting streets, you’ll discover an array of diverse flavors and dishes, making it a must-visit for those in search of the Best Restaurants in Middletown, New York. Beyond the culinary realm, Middletown also offers a rich tapestry of attractions, blending historical sites, outdoor adventures, and cultural experiences for a truly immersive journey.

1. Arkville Bread & Breakfast

Located in the charming town of Middletown, Arkville Bread & Breakfast is a culinary gem not to be missed. Step into this cozy establishment and be greeted by a unique setting – dining by a little window inside a train car, adding a touch of whimsy to your meal. Diving into their menu, you’ll find rave reviews about their breakfast dishes, with highlights like the delish breakfast sandwich and the massive florentine omelette with avocado. The sense of community is palpable as locals mingle with out-of-towners, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Don’t miss out on the apple jacks or the blueberry pancakes for a taste of nostalgia paired with exceptional flavors. Arkville Bread & Breakfast is a must-visit for anyone seeking delicious, comforting food in a delightful setting in Middletown.

Rating:
Price:

2. The Meadows Golf Center and All American BBQ

Calling all foodies in Middletown! The Meadows Golf Center and All American BBQ is not your average dining spot. Situated in the picturesque Catskills, this hidden gem is garnering rave reviews for its mouthwatering barbecue and warm hospitality. From homemade BBQ ribs to delectable pulled pork sandwiches, Russ and Julie sure know how to satisfy your taste buds. But it’s not just about the food here – patrons commend the welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service provided by the owners. Whether you’re a golf enthusiast looking to perfect your swing or a newbie eager to learn, The Meadows offers a delightful 9-hole course with stunning river views that will leave you in awe. Don’t miss out on this unique dining experience that promises a blend of great food, fun golf, and memorable moments. Make The Meadows Golf Center and All American BBQ your next culinary adventure in the Catskills!

Rating:
Price:

3. Brothers pizzeria Inc

Located in Middletown, Brothers Pizzeria Inc is a hidden gem that has been winning hearts and taste buds alike with its delectable offerings. The rave reviews speak volumes about their mouthwatering pizzas and wings that have patrons coming back for more. Customers can’t get enough of the airy and flavorful crust that serves as the perfect canvas for their specialty pies. The wings have been hailed as the best around, adding an extra flavor punch to your visit. Whether you’re a fan of classic cheese pizza or adventurous with mushroom toppings, this place promises a crispy bottom and a burst of handmade goodness in every bite. Brothers Pizzeria Inc is a must-visit for pizza aficionados looking to elevate their dining experience in Middletown.

Rating:
Price:

4. Trattoria Locale

In the vibrant town of Middletown lies Trattoria Locale, a culinary treasure trove that has garnered raving reviews from food enthusiasts. Delight your taste buds with their delectable pasta dishes, hailed as nothing short of ambrosial by diners who have sampled their menu. The paninis, a delightful deviation from the usual, have won hearts with their exquisite flavors – especially the balsamic-infused creations that leave a lasting impression. Visitors are not just treated to a gastronomic feast but also to an ambiance dripping with charm, making every visit a memorable experience. Embodying a slice of Italy in the Catskills, Trattoria Locale beckons all to savor its fresh and flavorful offerings, whether dining in or opting for a tantalizing takeout experience. Prepare to be enchanted by this quaint gem that promises a culinary journey worth revisiting time and time again.

Rating:
Price:

5. Oakley’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, Oakley’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill is a culinary gem that draws food enthusiasts from near and far. Delighting patrons with their wood-fired creations, Oakley’s is a haven for flavor seekers. Raving reviews echo the sentiments of patrons who have embarked on a culinary journey filled with delights like wings, calamari, and a variety of pizzas that are simply outstanding. The mild chicken wings with garlic, sweet potato fries, and the signature “garbage” wings are highlighted as must-try items that tantalize the taste buds. Pair these delectable dishes with a cold beer and revel in the friendly and attentive service that sets Oakley’s apart. While some diners noted a slight delay in service, the overall consensus remains unwaveringly positive – Oakley’s Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill is a must-visit destination for an unforgettable dining experience in Middletown.

Rating:
Price:

6. The Ark Bowl & BBQ

With its vintage charm and mouthwatering BBQ delights, The Ark Bowl & BBQ in Middletown is a true hidden gem waiting to be discovered. Step back in time as you indulge in their delectable pulled pork, hailed as the best around by avid foodies. The classic lanes and manual scorecards evoke nostalgia, while the friendly staff and live music create a vibrant atmosphere you won’t find elsewhere. Make sure to try their flavorful wings, chicken fingers, and mozzarella sticks – each bite is a savory journey worth savoring. Whether you’re a bowling enthusiast or a BBQ lover, this spot promises a unique dining experience that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left. Experience the best of the past and present at The Ark Bowl & BBQ – a culinary adventure you won’t soon forget.

Rating:
Price:

7. Inn Between

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, Inn Between is a hidden gem that boasts a cozy interior and a welcoming atmosphere. The owners, Tina and her husband, are lauded for their warm hospitality, making every diner feel like a regular. The menu features delectable dinner specials like mouthwatering prime rib and decadent desserts, ensuring a memorable dining experience. With a small bar and a full restaurant, this place exudes charm and comfort. The attentive staff and excellent service add to the overall appeal, making it a must-visit spot for food enthusiasts exploring the Catskills region. Be sure to check out this delightful eatery for a culinary journey that promises to leave you wanting more.

Rating:
Price: