Best Restaurants in Middletown, New Jersey

Located in Middletown, Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet is a true gem for food enthusiasts seeking an unparalleled dining experience. The stellar reviews speak for themselves – diners are raving about the mouthwatering Italian subs and the generously portioned eggplant parm. With an array of tempting sandwich options to choose from, it’s no wonder patrons find themselves coming back for more. Not to be missed are the delightful fried ravioli, a definite crowd-pleaser. The staff, hailed as both funny and kind, adds an extra layer of charm to this culinary hotspot. Taliercio’s Ultimate Gourmet is a must-visit for those looking to indulge in top-notch deli delights in Middletown.

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, Belford Brewing Company is making waves as a top contender in Monmouth County’s brewery scene. Boasting a plethora of flavorful craft beers, this spot is a must-visit for beer enthusiasts looking to savor unique brews like the Pro Multis and Waackaack IPA. The inviting atmosphere, complete with live music and a charming outdoor patio, sets the stage for memorable visits. Not only does Belford Brewing Company offer a diverse selection of beers, including crowd favorites like the P(b)each and Flannel brews, but the friendly and knowledgeable staff, including owners Mike and Mary, elevate the experience to new heights. With reasonable prices and a warm, welcoming vibe, Belford Brewing Company promises a delightful escape for both locals and visitors alike. A visit to this gem will undoubtedly leave you planning your next return trip for another round of exceptional beers and good times. Cheers to unforgettable brewery adventures!

In the vibrant town of Middletown, Il Colosseo Ristorante stands out as a culinary gem that transports diners straight to Italy. The enchanting melodies of Italian classics serenade the air, setting the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Guests are welcomed by a team that embodies hospitality at its finest, ensuring every visit is nothing short of exceptional. From the tantalizing Chicken Parmesan drenched in velvety vodka sauce to the impeccable service overseen by the attentive manager Pasquale, every dish at Il Colosseo embodies the pinnacle of Italian culinary artistry. With each bite, patrons are whisked away on a delectable journey, leaving them eagerly anticipating their next rendezvous with this gastronomic haven in Middletown. Let Il Colosseo Ristorante be your ticket to a culinary escape like no other.

Located in Middletown, Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine stands out as a hidden gem that deserves more recognition. Boasting a serene ambiance, this North Indian culinary gem offers a delightful array of traditional dishes that are a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds. Patrons rave about the Channe Ki Chaat, a flavorful appetizer that sets the stage for a culinary journey filled with delights like the shrimp Tikka marsala and the aromatic garlic naan. With reasonable prices that make every dish feel like a steal, Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine is a must-visit spot for those craving an authentic Indian culinary experience. Whether you opt for the buffet or a la carte, every bite here is a harmonious blend of spices and flavors that will leave you eagerly planning your next visit to savor more of their outstanding offerings.

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, Haldi Chowk 35 Authentic Indian Cuisine is a true gem for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful culinary adventure. The array of dishes at this casual eatery promises a feast for the senses, as highlighted by rave reviews from patrons. From the explosive spiciness of Chicken 65 to the creamy perfection of Butter Chicken, each dish bears testimony to the culinary mastery of the talented chefs at Haldi Chowk. The fusion of traditional and innovative flavors, such as the Naan pot pie and Indian Cheesecake, showcase a harmonious blend that is both unique and utterly delicious. With a warm and personable new owner and executive chef, Salil Bhandari, the restaurant brings a fresh perspective to Indian cuisine, promising a memorable dining experience that caters to diverse palates. For a taste of authentic Indian cuisine with a creative flair, Haldi Chowk is a must-visit destination for those craving a culinary journey unlike any other in Middletown.

Situated in the vibrant town of Middletown, Olde Village Pub is a gem worth discovering for both locals and visitors seeking a top-notch dining experience. Boasting a stellar 4.5 overall rating, this cozy establishment exudes a welcoming atmosphere that beckons you to unwind and indulge in their delectable offerings. Patrons rave about the friendly staff, with comments highlighting the exceptional service provided by individuals like Sam & Gary, adding a personal touch to your dining escapade. Known for their reasonably priced yet scrumptious fare, this pub prides itself on offering a diverse menu featuring fresh daily specials that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With live music adding a vibrant soundtrack to your meal, the efficient and spirited staff ensure that every visit is a memorable one. Don’t miss the chance to savor a delightful culinary journey at Olde Village Pub – a true culinary oasis in Middletown.

In the heart of Middletown, Honey Baked Ham is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Boasting a charming indoor setting and top-notch customer service, this family-owned establishment serves up an array of smoked hams, turkeys, and roasts that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Repeatedly praised for their mouthwatering ham and delectable roasted turkey breast, Honey Baked Ham has become a go-to spot for holiday feasts and weekend indulgences. With a stellar reputation for consistency and flavor, this beloved eatery is a must-visit for those seeking a savory, homestyle meal in Middletown.

Located in the vibrant town of Middletown, Matata Asian Cuisine is a culinary gem that has foodies buzzing with excitement. Dishing out delectable Asian delights, this restaurant has garnered rave reviews for its flavorful dishes and generous portions. From the savory beef lo mein to the mouthwatering chicken curry and the crowd favorite sushi, each bite is a symphony of flavors that will leave your taste buds dancing. The friendly staff adds an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience, making every visit a memorable one. Whether you’re a sushi aficionado or a fan of hot and sour soup, Matata Asian Cuisine is a must-visit hotspot for those seeking a delightful culinary adventure in Middletown. Don’t miss out on the chance to savor the yummalicious offerings that this restaurant has to offer—it’s a dining experience that will surely win over your palate!

MeeMom’s in Middletown is a gem of a find for breakfast enthusiasts in search of a cozy spot to indulge in hearty morning delights. Boasting a menu teeming with mouthwatering options, this establishment has garnered praise for its friendly and attentive staff, creating an inviting atmosphere that beckons patrons to return time and time again. The lure of monthly drink specials adds an element of surprise to each visit, while standout dishes like the gluten-free French toast leave a lasting impression on diners of all ages. Whether you’re craving a leisurely brunch or a satisfying lunch, MeeMom’s promises a delightful culinary experience that’s sure to please even the most discerning palates. Uncover the culinary treasures of Middletown at this beloved breakfast haven.

Step into the luxurious culinary world of Gabriella’s Italian Steakhouse, located in the vibrant town of Middletown. As you delve into the reviews, a symphony of praise unfolds, painting a picture of an exquisite dining experience. Guests revel in the impeccable service, with mentions of friendly staff and a buzzing atmosphere reminiscent of upscale Miami eateries. The menu’s highlights include the famed meatballs that even non-meatball enthusiasts find irresistible, a decadent cowboy steak that melts like butter, and truffle fries that elevate the dining experience. Pair these delectable dishes with signature cocktails and live DJ entertainment, and you have a recipe for an unforgettable evening. Indulge in the best garlic bread of your life, savor the truffle and fennel sausage pasta transporting you to Sorrento, and relish the Bistec alla Florentina with bone marrow and steak fries that beckon you back for more. Gabriella’s Italian Steakhouse is not just a restaurant; it’s an ode to culinary excellence that demands a visit. Bon appétit!