Best Restaurants in Middlefield, Ohio

Located in the charming town of Middlefield, Cinda’s Restaurant is a true gem in the heart of Amish country. This bustling Mom & Pop spot has garnered a loyal following for its generous homemade dishes and incredibly friendly service. Patrons rave about the attentive waitstaff who ensure a delightful dining experience. Don’t miss out on their transcendent menu offerings and reasonable prices that have diners proclaiming it as a “must-try” staple. With all-you-can-eat fish specials on Fridays, Cinda’s offers a variety that keeps customers coming back for more. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty meal or a memorable dining experience, Cinda’s Restaurant is definitely a standout in Middlefield’s culinary scene.

Located in Middlefield, The Amish Country Market is a true hidden gem brimming with culinary delights that will tantalize your taste buds. Step into this food haven and be prepared to be blown away by their legendary Pretzel Bar, where the Pretzel rolls steal the show with their hot, buttery deliciousness. Whether you’re savoring the Steak and Cheese or indulging in the Sausage Egg and Cheese pretzel, each bite is a flavor explosion. The atmosphere might be under construction, but the rave reviews promise an exciting transformation. From heavenly soft pretzels to mouthwatering homemade donuts, this place is a must-visit for those seeking a culinary adventure in Middlefield.

Located in Middlefield, Tai-Pan is a gem that Ohio locals swear by for an unforgettable dining experience. With a stellar reputation for its impeccable service and delectable dishes, this family-owned establishment has truly won the hearts of its patrons. The hot and sour soup and vegetable tempura have been highlighted as must-try items, showcasing the chef’s mastery in creating flavors that keep customers coming back for more. Tai-Pan’s generous portions and top-notch quality set it apart from the rest, making it a pricier but undoubtedly worthwhile choice for those craving authentic Chinese cuisine in a cozy and inviting setting. If you’re in Middlefield and craving a taste of excellence, Tai-Pan is a definite must-visit on your culinary journey.

Located in the charming town of Middlefield, Middlefield Cafe & Diner promises a delightful dining experience that encompasses warmth and flavor. With a menu boasting savory Chili and delectable sweet potato fries, it’s no wonder patrons rave about the yummy offerings. The exceptional service and friendly atmosphere add an extra dash of charm to this bustling eatery. Don’t miss out on their perfectly cooked breakfast delights mentioned by loyal customers, ensuring a satisfying start to your day. Situated in a quaint shopping center, this gem of a diner, staffed by Amish cooks and frequented by a diverse clientele, is a true culinary treasure waiting to be explored.

Situated in Middlefield, the FROST BAR N Grille is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Picture this: live blues music setting the tone for a vibrant atmosphere as you indulge in a sample platter of mouthwatering appetizers like Fresh Cut French Fries, Mozzarella Sticks, and Potato Skins. The burgers here are hailed as culinary masterpieces – juicy, robust, and cooked to perfection, catering to all burger aficionados. With rave reviews highlighting the friendly service and the rave-worthy dishes like chicken tenders, quesadillas, and onion rings, FROST BAR N Grille is not just a 5-star eatery; it’s a stellar 10-star destination that will leave you craving more. Don’t miss out on their burger special – it’s an absolute game-changer!

Located in Middlefield, Vinny’s Italian Kitchen is a culinary gem that guarantees a satisfying dining experience. With portion sizes that border on the absurdly generous, leaving with leftovers is a foregone conclusion. From appetizers to desserts, the commitment to quality and abundance is unwavering. A standout favorite is the pumpkin Russian drink, a seasonal delight that pairs perfectly with their flavorful dishes. The menu boasts exquisite Italian creations with fresh herb-infused sauces that elevate each bite. The warm ambiance, attentive service, and beautiful craftsmanship further enhance the overall dining experience. Vinny’s is a must-visit spot for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine that doesn’t disappoint.

Situated in the charming town of Middlefield, Maggie’s Donuts is a hidden gem for all dessert aficionados. With a reputation for crafting the freshest donuts in town, this spot is a must-visit for any sweet tooth. Indulge in their mouthwatering Apple Fritter and cream sticks that have garnered rave reviews. Make sure to arrive early to snag one of their beloved glazed croissants before they fly off the shelves! The maple bacon donut seems to be a fan favorite, winning over the hearts of both kids and adults alike. The warm and welcoming atmosphere paired with top-notch service make Maggie’s Donuts a delightful destination for a treat that’s sure to satisfy your cravings.

Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen in Middlefield is a culinary gem that has been a favorite dining destination for many loyal customers. Renowned for its hearty American comfort food, this restaurant offers a delightful experience that leaves taste buds tingling with joy. The portions are generous, ensuring that every visit is a feast for both the stomach and the soul. Guests rave about the freshness and deliciousness of every dish, with the buffet being a standout, boasting a wide array of delectable items. From mouth-watering meatloaf to irresistible pies and cakes, Mary Yoder’s truly embodies the essence of good old Amish-style home cooking. With attentive service and a cozy ambiance, this restaurant is a must-visit for anyone in search of a wholesome and satisfying meal. Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast or dinner, one thing is for sure – a trip to Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen is an experience not to be missed.

Located in Middlefield, Kaballos Mexican Kitchen & Bar is a vibrant gem that has been garnering rave reviews from satisfied patrons. Boasting an impressive menu filled with tantalizing dishes, this establishment has left diners in awe with its impeccable presentation and flavors that exceed all expectations. With prices that won’t break the bank, Kaballos offers a culinary experience that is as affordable as it is delightful. From the colorful and piping hot dishes to the warm and professional staff, this restaurant creates a welcoming family atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Don’t miss out on their must-try seafood soup and black bean soup, or indulge in the flavorful Kaballos sampler for a truly satisfying meal. With a recent renovation that has breathed new life into the place, including a charming horse theme, Kaballos Mexican Kitchen & Bar is the ideal spot for a memorable dining experience in Middlefield.

In the heart of Middlefield sits The Cutting Board, a vibrant spot where flavorsome dishes and top-notch service take center stage. Diners rave about the pulled pork sandwich, boasting about its juicy meat and perfectly toasted brioche bun. The variety on the menu is a big hit, with options like the smash burger and house chips winning over patrons. The welcoming atmosphere, complete with attentive Amish staff, adds to the charm of this Dutch Country makeover eatery. Whether you’re in for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, The Cutting Board promises a delightful culinary experience that’s bound to leave you planning your next visit. Be sure to indulge in their enticing coffee drinks for the perfect ending to your dining affair!