Best Restaurants in Middlebury, Connecticut

Located in the vibrant town of Middlebury, Center St Kitchen is a culinary gem that has foodies buzzing. With a great selection ranging from breakfast sandwiches to mouthwatering pizza, this spot has something for everyone. The professional and helpful staff ensure a top-notch dining experience, while the outstanding coffee keeps patrons coming back for more. Situated inside a gas station convenience store, this hidden culinary treasure is a must-visit for those seeking fresh and delicious fare in Middlebury.

In the charming town of Middlebury, Kitchen 64 stands out as a hidden gem for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful dining experience. Nestled in a cozy setting, this restaurant offers a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, from the indulgent special eggs Benedict featuring poached eggs over lox with arugula and capers to the mouthwatering pecan pancakes that have guests raving. The friendly staff adds to the inviting atmosphere, making every visit a memorable one. Whether you’re a fan of classic French toast or feeling adventurous with the Grinch pancakes, Kitchen 64 consistently delivers on both taste and value, making it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. With top-notch service, reasonable prices, and an array of delectable dishes, this spot is sure to earn a well-deserved spot on your list of must-visit restaurants in Middlebury.

Located in Middlebury, Vyne Restaurant & Bar exudes an inviting atmosphere that seamlessly blends indoor charm with outdoor allure, making it an ideal setting for gatherings big and small. A haven for culinary enthusiasts, this gem offers a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, ensuring a delightful dining experience for every patron. With glowing reviews highlighting the seamless execution of events like bridal showers in the enchanting garden room, where delectable dishes and impeccable service abound, Vyne promises to turn any occasion into a memorable affair. Whether relishing a meal indoors or savoring the warmer months on the outdoor terrace, Vyne’s commitment to excellence shines through, promising a culinary journey that delights the senses.

Located in Middlebury, Meet Me Here Restaurant and Bar is a gem waiting to be discovered by food enthusiasts. The menu boasts crowd-pleasers like the perfectly grilled salmon and the mouthwatering Meet Me Here Burger, which has left diners raving. Regulars love the personalized service, with shoutouts to attentive staff members like Gary and the delightful waitress, Sherry. The cozy atmosphere exudes a sense of familiarity, making it a go-to spot for locals who appreciate a culinary experience that goes above and beyond. Whether you’re craving the sumptuous Braised Short Ribs or the classic calamari, a visit to Meet Me Here promises a memorable dining adventure that will keep you coming back for more. Make sure to secure a reservation for a truly unforgettable culinary journey.

Located in Middlebury, Brewbury is a vibrant hub for food and fun, offering an expansive space perfect for gatherings of all sizes. The diverse menu boasts must-try items like their irresistible pizza with a whipped ricotta base and unique toppings like eggplant parm, creating a pizza lover’s paradise. Pair these delights with the Neon Moon beer, a praised wheat blend, and you’re in for a treat. With a full bar offering more than just beer, friendly and attentive servers like Maisey, and an outdoor bar where you can enjoy great drinks and engaging conversations, Brewbury stands out as a gem in the Connecticut pizza scene. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual afternoon bite or hosting a special event, Brewbury promises an unforgettable experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Located in Middlebury, Middlebury Pizza is a true gem in the local culinary scene. The raving reviews speak for themselves, with patrons praising the delectable meatball and onion pizza, a true treat after a long week. Regulars spanning over 15 years commend the consistently great pizzas and grinders, served by a friendly staff that adds a welcoming touch to every visit. The Italiano pizza, boasting roasted red peppers, sausage, pepperoni, and basil, is a must-try, alongside the flavorful tortellini soup. Middlebury Pizza is a must-visit for those craving a delightful and longstanding dining experience in Middlebury.

In the vibrant town of Middlebury, sits Señor Pancho’s, a Mexican gem that promises to tantalize your taste buds and transport you to flavor heaven. With a stellar reputation for its delectable margaritas that have been hailed as “the best in the world,” this lively spot is a must-visit for cocktail aficionados. The menu boasts an array of mouthwatering dishes, from honey chipotle wings that are “AMAZING” to a variety of tacos that will have you coming back for more. And let’s not forget the daily early bird happy hour specials that are sure to make your wallet and your taste buds equally happy. The staff here are not just friendly but go above and beyond, ensuring a memorable dining experience. If you’re seeking a fiesta for your senses, Señor Pancho’s is the place to be in Middlebury.

Located in Middlebury, Dunkin’ is not just your average chain – it’s a beacon of exceptional breakfast delights and a haven for coffee aficionados. With a reputation for top-notch service and a welcoming atmosphere, this Dunkin’ outpost has patrons raving about the friendly staff who always go the extra mile. Cleanliness is clearly a top priority here, with customers noticing the meticulous care taken even during busy periods. And let’s not overlook the quirky touch of restroom tunes adding a unique charm to the experience. So, whether you’re a regular greeted by name or a newcomer seeking a comforting cup of joe, Dunkin’ in Middlebury promises a delightful escape into the world of delectable breakfast treats and sip-worthy coffees.

Pies & Pub in Middlebury is a must-visit gem for those craving a cozy neighborhood pub experience with a twist. Picture this: a laid-back setting where every visit feels like a warm welcome, complemented by a delightful back patio that recently got a chic expansion. This spot isn’t just about the ambiance; it’s about mouthwatering specials like 50 cent wing nights on Mondays and $3 craft beers on Tuesdays that keep regulars coming back for more. And let’s talk about their pizza – a solid choice paired with a rotating array of beers that’ll make your taste buds sing. The buzz around their Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese pizza is real, along with rave reviews about the meat lovers pizza and the twist on French fries known as sidewinders. With a menu that boasts delights like a Philly cheesesteak grinder, Pies & Pub is a culinary adventure waiting to be explored with friends. Trust the locals; this spot is a hit for good reason!

Located in the charming town of Middlebury, 8 Fifty Wood Fired Pizza is a gem not to be missed. The Festive Salad seems to be a crowd favorite, described as fresh, beautifully presented, and a must-try by enthusiasts. From the attentive and knowledgeable staff to the beautiful dining room ambiance, every visit promises a delightful experience. With raving reviews about the consistency, great wine selection, and overall awesome atmosphere, 8 Fifty Wood Fired Pizza is clearly a standout destination for foodies seeking a memorable dining adventure in Middlebury.