Best Restaurants in Mantua, New Jersey

Located in Mantua, Jim’s Family Style Pizza is a hidden gem that has been serving up delicious food for over 30 years. Customers rave about their mouthwatering wings, full sandwiches, and unbeatable pizza. The friendly staff adds a personal touch, making you feel right at home with photos of their own families adorning the walls. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Jim’s will impress you with their quick service, top-notch food quality, and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Don’t miss out on their famous Johnny boy sandwich or the highly recommended Jimmy’s Special Stromboli – you won’t be disappointed! For a taste of true family-style hospitality and delectable Italian-American cuisine, Jim’s is the place to be in Mantua.

Sal’s Pizza & Restaurant in Mantua is a culinary gem offering a delightful array of Sicilian-style pies, pasta creations, and hearty sub sandwiches. Patrons rave about the tantalizing gluten-free pizza options, ensuring everyone gets a slice of the deliciousness. The menu also boasts mouthwatering chicken cheesesteak hoagies with fried onions that seem to vanish faster than you can say “buon appetito.” With a friendly and welcoming staff, coupled with reasonable prices, it’s no wonder locals keep coming back for more of Sal’s savory delights. Don’t miss out on this hometown favorite that guarantees a flavorful experience worth savoring time and time again.

Located in the charming town of Mantua, La Sicilia is a must-visit gem for pizza enthusiasts. With a perfect blend of crispy yet chewy crust, savory pepperoni, and just the right amount of cheese, their pies have been hailed as “damn good” and “the best tasting pizza around.” Beyond their classic offerings, the vegan pizza has also garnered high praise for its deliciousness, catering to various dietary needs without compromising on flavor. The New York type atmosphere and friendly staff add to the overall experience, making La Sicilia a top contender for the best restaurants in Mantua. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a stop at La Sicilia for a slice of heaven is definitely in order.

In the vibrant town of Mantua lies Mi Familia, an Italian-American gem that has captured the hearts of locals and newcomers alike. This cozy establishment boasts a menu brimming with classic favorites like pizza, pasta, subs, and wings, all served with a touch of homemade perfection. Rave reviews echo the sentiments of patrons who swear by the freshness of the salads and the savory allure of the chicken parm, a dish that has become a household favorite. The dedication to quality shines through in every bite, with mentions of impeccable service and speedy delivery adding to the allure of Mi Familia. Whether you’re in the mood for a comforting slice of white pizza or craving the satisfying crunch of breaded wings, this family-owned eatery promises a delightful dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more. Embrace the flavors of Italy with a touch of American charm at Mi Familia, a must-visit spot in Mantua for those seeking a taste of home-cooked goodness.

Situated in Mantua, the Barnsboro Inn is a gem that exudes history and charm. Boasting a menu brimming with delectable pub grub, juicy steaks, and fresh seafood, this circa-1776 tavern offers a culinary experience like no other. Rave reviews mention the exceptional bacon cheeseburger that transports diners back to the cozy vibes of old Philadelphia bars. With friendly staff like Mia and Debbie, known for their top-notch service and delightful concoctions, including an array of specialty drinks and mouth-watering crab cakes, it’s no wonder patrons are lured back time and time again. Dive into this historic haven for a taste of the best that New Jersey has to offer – it’s a true slice of American culinary tradition!

Located in Mantua, The Telford Inn is a hidden gem for those in search of a delightful dining experience. Step into this former 18th-century inn, now transformed into a cozy spot offering a delectable array of surf ‘n’ turf dishes and American classics, alongside a tempting selection of beers that will surely tantalize your taste buds. As one enthusiastic reviewer raved about their prime rib specialty, another savored a delectable prime double cut paired perfectly with a nice glass of wine. The menu boasts an impressive lineup, including the must-try prime rib sandwich, chicken strips, and the crowd-pleasing brisket nachos. With entertaining magicians adding a touch of magic on Saturdays, The Telford Inn promises not just a meal, but a memorable experience worth revisiting time and time again. Indulge in their offerings and discover the flavors that make this local spot a true culinary gem in Mantua.

Located in Mantua, Amigos is a culinary gem that seems to have won the hearts and taste buds of many diners. Raving about the impeccable service and scrumptious food, patrons have highlighted the standout empanadas, with some even planning to throw a second party just to indulge in these delights once more. The fajita bar has also garnered well-deserved praise for its incredible flavors and generous portions, making it an absolute hit. Regulars keep coming back for more, drawn in by the unbeatable prices and the mouthwatering array of dishes, especially the spicy beef and jerk chicken empanadas that seem to have left a lasting impression. With such high praises and repeat visits, Amigos in Mantua is clearly a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience that tantalizes the taste buds and leaves you craving more.

Located in Mantua, Vito’s Pizza is making waves with its mouthwatering offerings that have garnered rave reviews. Patrons can’t stop praising the delectable pizzas, with one reviewer dubbing it the best they’ve ever had. The love doesn’t stop there – the chicken quesadilla, pasta, and ribeye cheesesteak have also captured the hearts (and taste buds) of visitors. It’s evident that passion and care go into every dish, from the delicious Chicken Caesar Panini to the generously loaded cheese steaks that keep customers coming back for more. Whether you’re in the mood for a savory slice or craving some BBQ chicken boneless wings that are described as “everything,” Vito’s Pizza seems to have all the right ingredients for a memorable dining experience in Mantua. Don’t miss out on the chance to savor a slice of perfection at this local gem!

Situated in Mantua, Coffee & Creams SW Grill is a culinary gem that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many food enthusiasts. With glowing reviews praising the owner’s warm hospitality and the mouthwatering dishes, it’s no surprise this spot is a must-visit for both locals and those willing to make the drive. From the addictive Chai tea lattes that vanish in seconds to the fresh and flavorful meals made with love, patrons rave about the consistent quality and the irresistible urge to return for more. Whether you’re indulging in the shrimp tacos or savoring a burrito with a side of delectable blueberry scones, each bite at Coffee & Creams SW Grill is a delightful journey worth embarking on time and time again.

Located in Mantua, Rocco’s Pizza is making waves with its mouthwatering slices that have customers raving. The by-the-slice pizza is lauded for its fresh and hot quality, with a perfect balance of sauce and crust that keeps patrons coming back for more. Not only are the slices huge, but they come at a crazy affordable price point, making it a steal for families. With a friendly service that exudes southern hospitality, Rocco’s Pizza creates an atmosphere that feels like a slice of home. For those craving a taste of South Jersey, this gem is a must-visit spot that promises a flavorful experience worth revisiting.