Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Madison, New Jersey

Located in the charming town of Madison, New Jersey, culinary enthusiasts are in for a treat with a plethora of top-notch dining establishments to explore. This lovely town boasts a vibrant culinary scene, making it a haven for foodies seeking the Best Restaurants in Madison. From cozy cafes serving artisanal coffee to upscale eateries dishing out exquisite fine dining experiences, this quaint town has something to satisfy every palate. Beyond its gastronomic delights, Madison also presents visitors with a rich tapestry of attractions, including historic sites, picturesque parks, and cultural landmarks. It’s a destination that seamlessly blends culinary excellence with cultural charm, making it a must-visit for any discerning traveler.

1. Sunday Motor Co.

In the vibrant town of Madison, the Sunday Motor Co. revs up the culinary scene with its unique charm and flavorful offerings. Housed in a converted garage, this hip eatery boasts a menu brimming with delicious and fresh options that will tantalize your taste buds. From the mouthwatering chilaquiles to the savory mushroom sandwich on a croissant, each dish is a delightful explosion of flavors. The monkeybread and lattes are additional must-tries, elevating your dining experience to new heights. With a cool, eclectic vibe and a nod to its motor-themed roots, Sunday Motor Co. is not just a restaurant but a destination where exceptional customer service and a love for all things automotive collide. Whether you’re a food enthusiast or a car aficionado, this spot is a top recommendation for a memorable culinary adventure in Madison.

Rating:
Price:

2. Shanghai Jazz Restaurant & Bar

Located in Madison, Shanghai Jazz Restaurant & Bar offers a captivating blend of upscale Asian cuisine and live jazz performances, making it a must-visit spot for food and music enthusiasts alike. With a reputation for hosting big-name artists, this institution promises an unforgettable dining experience. Reviewers have raved about the delectable coconut shrimp, craft cocktails, and standout dishes like calamari, Korean beef, noodles, and scallops. The cozy atmosphere, coupled with the exceptional music, sets the stage for a perfect evening out. Whether you’re looking for a unique date spot or a place to enjoy a meal with friends, Shanghai Jazz Restaurant & Bar is sure to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds and musical soul. Don’t miss out on the red door experience – park out back and step into a world of culinary delights and melodic harmony!

Rating:
Price:

3. Il Mondo Vecchio

Step into the world of flavor and elegance at Il Mondo Vecchio in Madison, where traditional Italian cuisine meets unparalleled sophistication. Known as a top-quality dining destination, this high-end BYOB landmark is a must-visit for those craving exquisite flavors and a charming ambiance. The penne vodka steals the show, drawing rave reviews alongside complimentary bruschetta and crispy zucchini that set the perfect tone for a memorable meal. Dive into classics like buffalo mozzarella and goat cheese beet salad or savor the earthy delights of the red snapper. Impeccable service and a menu that leaves nothing to be desired make every visit a culinary journey worth repeating. Whether it’s a special occasion or a craving for authentic Italian fare, Il Mondo Vecchio promises a dining experience that transcends expectations and ignites a love for fine dining.

Rating:
Price:

4. Grillera Mediterranean Cuisine

Grillera Mediterranean Cuisine, situated in Madison, is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. With a menu boasting succulent kebabs and perfectly grilled lamb chops, this casually elegant restaurant has garnered rave reviews. Diners praise the fresh bread served with olive oil and butter, setting the stage for a memorable meal. The baba ganoush is a standout, described as smoky, creamy, and refreshingly bright. Whether indulging in the appetizer platter or savoring the Shepherd’s salad, each dish is a harmonious blend of flavors. The cozy ambiance adds to the allure of this hidden culinary haven, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors seeking authentic Mediterranean flavors in a charming setting. Experience Grillera’s excellence for yourself and embark on a gastronomic journey that promises to delight your taste buds.

Rating:
Price:

5. Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Madison is a culinary gem that has everyone talking. With a diverse menu featuring scrumptious pizzas and delightful Italian dishes, this American BYOB joint has become a go-to spot for food enthusiasts. The rave reviews speak for themselves – from the impeccable service highlighted by friendly and attentive staff to the mouthwatering appetizers and perfectly cooked dinners that leave patrons thrilled. Whether you’re swinging by for a quick slice during your lunch break or settling in for a cozy meal with loved ones, Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria promises a memorable dining experience. Situated in the heart of Madison with convenient parking options, this restaurant is a must-visit for those craving a delicious meal in a welcoming atmosphere. Don’t just take our word for it, let your taste buds be the judge!

Rating:
Price:

6. Butter & Jam

Located in the vibrant town of Madison, Butter & Jam is a brunch haven that promises a delightful culinary escapade. With a bustling atmosphere and wide windows inviting streams of light, this spot offers a cozy yet energetic setting perfect for indulging in a scrumptious meal. The menu, although leaning towards sweet delicacies like the butter and jam board with an assortment of spreads, also presents savory options like the California breakfast sandwich and the B&J burger. While dishes like the steak and eggs and chicken and waffles shine brightly, the true star is the scratCh kitchen’s brisket skillet. Service, while sometimes needing a touch more finesse, is prompt and friendly, ensuring an overall enjoyable experience. Plan ahead and make a reservation to savor the flavors at Butter & Jam, a hidden gem waiting to be discovered in Madison for a brunch experience that’s both fun and fulfilling.

Rating:
Price:

7. Bottle Hill Tavern

Located in Madison, the Bottle Hill Tavern beckons both locals and travelers with its scrumptious offerings and laid-back ambiance. Boasting generous portions and a diverse menu, this gem stands out for its delectable dishes like the poke bowl salad, crabby waffle fries with addictive white cheddar sauce, and a tantalizing chicken caesar wrap that hits all the right notes. The attentive and friendly staff add to the welcoming atmosphere, ensuring a delightful dining experience. Whether you’re a vegetarian, a seafood aficionado, or a fan of classic tavern fare, this spot caters to all tastes. Don’t miss out on their happy hour deals, offering some of the best bang for your buck in town. Bottle Hill Tavern is a must-visit culinary destination in Madison, promising a gastronomic adventure that will have you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

8. The Prospect Tavern

Located in the charming town of Madison, The Prospect Tavern is a hidden gem not to be missed when exploring the local dining scene. Housed in a historic 19th-century building, this traditional tavern exudes warmth and coziness, offering an inviting ambiance for patrons to unwind and savor delicious American mains and sandwiches. Patrons rave about the mouthwatering chicken cordon bleu, fried dumplings, and delectable salmon dish that are described as top-notch. With a focus on providing a comfortable and relaxing environment, The Prospect Tavern stands out for its friendly staff, affordable happy hour prices, and impeccable service. Whether you’re seeking a perfect date spot or a casual hangout with friends, this tavern is the ideal destination to enjoy great food in a peaceful setting, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike.

Rating:
Price:

9. Palm Thai Restaurant

Situated in Madison, Palm Thai Restaurant offers a modern twist on classic Thai dishes, creating a culinary experience that’s truly unforgettable. With a BYOB policy to top it off, guests can savor the mouthwatering flavors while enjoying their favorite beverages. The Sweet Chili Red Snapper steals the show with its crispy yet tender fish pieces immersed in a delightful sweet and spicy sauce, perfect for those wary of whole fish dishes. For a fiery kick, the Volcano Pork Shank, falling-off-the-bone tender, packs a punch of spice that’s not for the faint-hearted but definitely for the flavor enthusiasts. Sip on their Thai Iced Tea or opt for the Lychee Iced Tea for a dairy-free yet equally delicious alternative. And don’t miss out on the Shrimp Pad See Ew, where every bite of the perfectly cooked noodles is a delight, albeit with a wish for more shrimp per forkful. With excellent service and dishes executed with precision, Palm Thai Restaurant is a gem waiting to be discovered by all Thai cuisine aficionados in Madison.

Rating:
Price:

10. Nautilus Diner

Located in the vibrant town of Madison, Nautilus Diner is a culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. This easygoing diner, renowned for its all-day fare, serves up a variety of delectable dishes that leave patrons coming back for more. One standout dish that has garnered praise is the mouthwatering Reuben sandwich, a true crowd-pleaser. With its convenient location just a short stroll from Madison’s NJTransit train station, Nautilus Diner combines convenience with culinary excellence, making it a must-visit destination for locals and visitors alike.

Rating:
Price: