Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Lewiston, New York

Situated in the picturesque town of Lewiston, New York, culinary enthusiasts are in for a treat with a vibrant array of dining experiences to explore. This lovely town boasts a diverse culinary scene, making it a hotspot for food lovers seeking the best restaurants in Lewiston. From cozy cafes serving up artisanal coffee to upscale eateries dishing out gourmet cuisine, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Beyond its gastronomic delights, Lewiston also offers charming attractions such as historic sites, art galleries, and breathtaking views of the Niagara River. Join me on a virtual tour of the top dining spots in this culinary haven.

1. Brewed And Bottled Craft Beer Shop

Brewed And Bottled Craft Beer Shop in Lewiston is a beer lover’s paradise, boasting an array of craft brews that will tantalize your taste buds. With a reputation as one of the best breweries in the US, this spot is a gem for beer enthusiasts near and far. The staff, described as helpful, knowledgeable, and even a tad dramatic and silly, adds a fun flair to your beer-picking experience. Whether you’re into macro lagers or pastry stouts, their diverse selection ensures there’s something for every palate. The cozy ambiance, both indoors and outdoors, exudes a welcoming coffee shop vibe, making it the perfect setting to savor your chosen brew. So, if you’re in the mood for a top-notch craft beer experience in WNY, look no further than Brewed And Bottled Craft Beer Shop!

Rating:
Price:

2. Hustler’s Tavern

In the vibrant town of Lewiston, Hustler’s Tavern stands out as a gem for both locals and visitors alike. The raving reviews speak for themselves – with massive portions that could easily feed a crowd, the truffle fries are an absolute must-try, setting the bar high right from the start. The diverse pizza styles, from Detroit to New York, offer a tantalizing journey for your taste buds, with standout options like the mushroom-packed pie stealing the show. Amidst the historical references and cool vibes, Hustler’s Tavern exudes a welcoming atmosphere where every detail, from the perfectly cooked brussel sprouts to the artisanal cocktails, is meticulously crafted to elevate your dining experience. Whether you’re a pizza enthusiast or cocktail connoisseur, this top-notch pizzeria is a definite must-visit in the quest for the best restaurants in Lewiston.

Rating:
Price:

3. The Spicey Pickle

In the vibrant town of Lewiston, The Spicey Pickle beckons with its enticing array of flavors and inviting ambiance. As online food explorers sing praises of the restaurant’s fresh and crisp hard shell tacos, it’s clear that this place is a taco-lover’s paradise. Patrons rave about the reminiscent taste of the dishes, drawing playful parallels to a beloved fast-food chain. With a cozy setting and amiable staff to enhance your dining experience, The Spicey Pickle is sure to spice up your culinary journey in Lewiston. Indulge in their tantalizing taco creations and savor the delightful fusion of flavors that await at this hidden gem.

Rating:
Price:

4. Queenston Heights Restaurant

Embark on a culinary journey at Queenston Heights Restaurant, a seasonal gem in Lewiston that encapsulates upscale-casual dining at its finest. Amidst the regional wines and Sunday brunch delights, patrons rave about not just the food, but the exceptional service led by the remarkable Jackie. From wedding extravaganzas to leisurely brunches, the menu boasts a tantalizing array of dishes – imagine savoring chicken, short rib, and prime rib masterpieces amidst a backdrop of the Niagara River. With a panoramic view that steals the spotlight and a weekend buffet that promises a gastronomic adventure, Queenston Heights Restaurant beckons food enthusiasts to revel in a top-notch dining experience. Don’t miss out on this culinary haven; make your reservations early for a taste of excellence!

Rating:
Price:

5. Griffon Brewery and Gastropub

Located in the charming town of Lewiston, Griffon Brewery and Gastropub is a hidden gem that promises a delightful dining experience. Guests rave about the scenic balcony overlooking the river, providing a picturesque backdrop for your meal. The attentive staff, like Trish, go above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit, catering to all needs with a smile. Don’t miss out on the Maryland Crab Pretzel Bombs, a highly recommended dish that is perfect for sharing with friends or family. Griffon Brewery and Gastropub is not just a place to eat; it’s an experience that will have you planning your next visit before you even leave.

Rating:
Price:

6. The Village Bake Shoppe

Located in Lewiston, The Village Bake Shoppe is a must-visit gem for any dessert enthusiast. With a stellar reputation for crafting show-stopping cakes, the red velvet with amaretto mousse filling seems to be a fan favorite, eliciting rave reviews for both its visual appeal and delectable taste. Offering an array of pastries and cakes, this charming spot exudes a welcoming ambiance and boasts friendly service that leaves patrons like the reviewer planning return visits. Noteworthy mentions go to the Pumpkin Spice cookies, biscottis, and Mini Mile High Apple Pie that pair perfectly with their excellent coffee and cappuccinos. The staff’s expertise in guiding customers to the perfect treat, including accommodating gluten-free options, adds an extra layer of charm to this delightful bakery. Whether you’re in the mood for a special occasion cake or simply craving a scrumptious dessert, The Village Bake Shoppe is a top choice for an indulgent sweet treat experience in Lewiston.

Rating:
Price:

7. Villa Coffee House

Situated in the charming town of Lewiston, Villa Coffee House is an absolute gem for breakfast enthusiasts. With a seasoned cook/server/cleaner named Debbie at the helm for an impressive 40 years, the warmth and flavor of this place shine through in every bite. The corned beef dishes, whether paired with over easy eggs or poached, are described as nothing short of perfection by patrons. The mention of DiCamillo toast, with its legendary reputation from a local bakery, adds an extra touch of culinary delight. The cozy atmosphere, generous portions, and attentive service make Villa Coffee House a must-visit spot for a delightful morning meal experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

8. Syros Restaurant

Located in Lewiston, Syros Restaurant offers a delightful fusion of Greek and American cuisine that is sure to tantalize your taste buds. With a cozy ambiance and a menu packed with both familiar favorites and breakfast delights, this spot is a definite must-visit. Guests rave about the friendly staff and impeccable service, with special mentions of attentive waitstaff like Anna and the young waiter. The food steals the show here, with standout dishes like the chopper sirloin with veggies and the mouthwatering “Popeye” wrap with spinach, feta, and chicken. Don’t forget to try their famous fries and homemade dressings. Syros Restaurant promises a pleasant dining experience filled with generous portions and fresh, delicious food that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Rating:
Price:

9. Favorites Pizza & Wings Lewiston

Located in Lewiston, Favorites Pizza & Wings is a gem worth discovering for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful culinary adventure. With a diverse menu offering a plethora of options like mouthwatering pizza with generous toppings, tantalizing wings in a myriad of flavors, and delectable sides, this cozy spot is a haven for foodies on the hunt for a steal. The friendly staff at Favorites Pizza & Wings pride themselves on exceptional customer service, ensuring that even large orders are prepared with precision and ready at the perfect time. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza or feeling adventurous with a steak and cheese or chicken cordon bleu, this hidden culinary treasure promises a flavor-packed experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

10. Cask + Cow

If you find yourself in Lewiston craving a memorable culinary experience, look no further than Cask + Cow. Boasting a delightful ambiance with background music setting the perfect tone, this gem has garnered rave reviews for its top-notch fare. From the delectable pub pretzels that leave taste buds dancing to the flavorful chicken Adriana that’s a genuine showstopper, every dish is a testament to their commitment to excellence. Whether you’re savoring the perfection of their burgers or indulging in the unique Elvis-inspired Hot Tempered Elvis burger, each bite is a symphony of flavors that’ll have you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your meal. The staff, especially Lydia, ensures that you feel like a VIP, making this spot a must-visit for those seeking an unforgettable dining experience in the Lewiston area.

Rating:
Price: