Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Lemay, Missouri

Situated in the heart of Missouri, Lemay boasts a vibrant culinary scene that will tantalize any food enthusiast’s taste buds. This lovely town is a treasure trove of gastronomic delights, offering an eclectic mix of flavors and cuisines. From cozy cafes to upscale eateries, Lemay is a haven for foodies looking to explore the Best Restaurants in town. Beyond its dining options, Lemay also entices visitors with its rich history, scenic parks, and charming local shops. Join me on a culinary journey through Lemay, where every meal is a delectable adventure waiting to be savored.

1. Affton Pizza Company

Affton Pizza Company, located in Lemay, is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered by pizza aficionados searching for a unique slice of St. Louis style heaven. With a perfect balance of savory sauce, rich buttery Provel cheese, and toppings that hit all the right notes, each bite is a tantalizing journey back to the golden days of Imos, but with a modern twist that keeps you coming back for more. The crispy crust, reminiscent of a cracker, is the cherry on top of this culinary masterpiece. Not to mention, the attentive and friendly service adds an extra layer of delight to the dining experience. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite or a curious out-of-towner eager to explore the St. Louis pizza scene, Affton Pizza Company is a must-visit destination that promises to leave you craving another round of their delectable pies.

Rating:
Price:

2. Riverside Diner

Located in Lemay, the Riverside Diner is a hidden gem for breakfast and lunch enthusiasts. Boasting a charming ambiance and top-notch service, this diner has left patrons raving about its delectable offerings. From the mouthwatering 2 eggs, 2 pancakes, 2 bacon, 2 sausage, and biscuits and gravy platter to the flavorful chicken florentine skillet and massive pork tenderloin sandwich, every dish is a culinary delight. The Riverside Diner’s dedication to generous portions, home-cooked flavors, and a cozy atmosphere shines through in each glowing review. Don’t miss out on their famous carrot cake or the irresistible BBB (Big Biscuit Breakfast) for a truly satisfying dining experience. Plan your visit today and indulge in a feast that will leave your taste buds singing!

Rating:
Price:

3. Kabul Express STL

Situated in Lemay, Kabul Express STL promises a culinary journey like no other. With a divine mix of Indian and Middle Eastern flavors, this gem has left patrons raving about its perfectly seasoned dishes. From the tantalizing mixed meat over rice to the heavenly Butter Chicken and the crowd-favorite cheese fries, each bite is a symphony for the taste buds. The ambiance, described as clean and beautiful, pairs flawlessly with the attentive service that adds an extra layer of charm to the dining experience. An undiscovered treasure in St. Louis, Kabul Express STL is a must-visit for those seeking fresh, flavorful, and top-notch cuisine that will undoubtedly keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

4. Stacked STL

Located in Lemay, Stacked STL offers a build-your-own burger experience that has left diners raving. The atmosphere is described as welcoming and enjoyable, with a diverse menu of specialty burgers that rotate through, ensuring each visit is a culinary adventure. Standout dishes like the Wakey Wakey burger with jam and bacon, alongside the Bella Bleus, have received high praise for their flavors and creativity. Not to be missed are the BBQ nachos and fiery chicken wings that have customers urging others to “RUN” to this spot. With a fun touch like providing pencils for doodling on their art wall, Stacked STL promises not just a meal, but a memorable experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

5. The Neighbor’s Place

Located in Lemay, The Neighbor’s Place is a hidden gem that’s creating a buzz among food enthusiasts in Missouri. With a menu that boasts mouthwatering chicken wings, perfectly crisp fries, and fresh salads, this newly opened restaurant is winning hearts and taste buds alike. One reviewer raved about the addictive food that still holds its flavor even after a reheat – a true testament to the quality of their dishes. Beyond the delicious fare, the ambiance at The Neighbor’s Place is a standout feature, offering three levels of entertainment including a restaurant, a vibrant bar, and a game room with an ice cream parlor. The place exudes a modern charm and offers an array of activities from game nights to hookah sessions, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all. Whether you’re looking for a chill hangout spot or a place to indulge in delectable treats, The Neighbor’s Place promises a delightful visit that’ll keep you coming back for more.

Rating:
Price:

6. Mama Mel’s Pizzeria

In the vibrant town of Lemay, Mama Mel’s Pizzeria stands out as a true culinary delight. Renowned for their Detroit Style Pizza, Mama Mel’s has captured the hearts and taste buds of many patrons. The generous portion sizes had one reviewer struggling after just two slices, a testament to the hearty and satisfying nature of their dishes. Not only does Mama Mel’s excel in pizza, but their desserts also beckon, with a display case that has tempted even the most disciplined of diners. The recent introduction of Detroit style has garnered rave reviews, while classics like fresh battered mushrooms and onion rings continue to impress. With a friendly and efficient staff that exudes warmth and sincerity, Mama Mel’s offers not just a meal, but an experience worth returning for time and time again. Whether you opt for the Mama Burger or cheese fries, each bite at this Lemay gem is a culinary journey worth savoring.

Rating:
Price:

7. La Oaxaqueña

Located in Lemay, La Oaxaqueña is a delightful Mexican eatery that has been winning over patrons with its authentic flavors and warm hospitality. Diners rave about the rich and traditional Oaxacan dishes that transport them to the heart of Mexico. From the Arroz con Pollo bursting with flavor to the mouthwatering carnitas and tantalizing enchiladas smothered in mole sauce, every bite is a fiesta for the taste buds. The salsa here is touted as the best in town, paired perfectly with crispy chips to start your meal. Don’t miss out on their signature Choripollo or the flavorful tamales that keep customers coming back for more. La Oaxaqueña truly stands out as a must-visit gem in Lemay for those craving an authentic Mexican culinary experience.

Rating:
Price:

8. Fergie’s Bar & Restaurant

Located in Lemay, Fergie’s Bar & Restaurant is a hidden gem offering a delightful experience for both foodies and nostalgia seekers alike. Dive into their acclaimed chicken dinner, touted as the best in South County, or savor the mouthwatering turkey club sandwich that keeps patrons coming back for more. The charming old-timey ambiance sets the stage for memorable moments, where friendly staff members turn dining into an engaging affair. As you sip on craft cocktails or enjoy a cold beer on tap, immerse yourself in the community spirit that Fergie’s effortlessly embodies. Whether you’re a local looking for a new haunt or a traveler seeking authentic flavors, Fergie’s promises to be a warm and inviting haven where every bite tells a story.

Rating:
Price:

9. Monte Bello Pizzeria

Situated in Lemay, Monte Bello Pizzeria is a must-visit gem that has been delighting patrons with its mouthwatering offerings. Guests rave about the freshness of the toppings and sauce, particularly on the signature thin-crust pizzas that are perfectly seasoned and loaded with a blend of exquisite cheeses. The Buffalo cauliflower is a crowd-pleaser, offering a crispy delight that pairs impeccably with their house salad drizzled with their delectable ranch dressing. Whether you opt for their specialty pizzas or build your own, you’re in for a treat with every bite. Amidst the inviting ambiance and friendly service from this family-run establishment, Monte Bello Pizzeria stands out as a top contender for those seeking a flavorful and memorable dining experience in Lemay.

Rating:
Price:

10. The River Des Peres Yacht Club Deli

Located in Lemay, The River Des Peres Yacht Club Deli is a hidden gem that has captured the hearts of many food enthusiasts. With rave reviews praising their signature sandwiches like the Steamboat Willie and Beach Sub, this mom and pop deli has solidified its spot as one of the best in town. Not only is the food top-notch, but the friendly employees and cozy outdoor seating area create a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more. If you’re in the mood for a delicious meal and exceptional service, this charming deli is a must-visit when exploring the culinary scene in Lemay.

Rating:
Price: