Best Restaurants in Lancaster, New York

Frosty’s is a fantastic and unique ice cream shop that offers a wide selection of flavors, including dairy-free and gluten-free options. The portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. The staff is friendly and provides great service. I had a POG float, which was a refreshing combination of pineapple, orange, and guava juice with vanilla custard and whipped cream. The ice cream itself is delicious and full of flavor, unlike some other popular chains. They also offer creative sundaes, such as the cannoli sundae and the panda paws. Whether you’re a fan of traditional flavors or looking for something a little different, Frosty’s has something for everyone.

If you find yourself in Lancaster craving authentic Mexican flavors that pack a punch, look no further than El Amigo Tacos and Mexican Restaurant. Situated in the heart of town, this hidden gem is a must-visit for foodies seeking a fiesta for their taste buds. From the savory carne asada street tacos to the mouthwatering Al Pastor and chicken street tacos, every bite at El Amigo is a flavor explosion. The menu boasts generous portions, with highlights like the OMG-worthy chimichangas that will leave you coming back for more. Pair your meal with their on-point margaritas, especially during the unbeatable $2.99 special on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. With a friendly and attentive staff, a salsa station brimming with freshness, and a cozy atmosphere, El Amigo Tacos and Mexican Restaurant is a fiesta waiting to happen – don’t miss out on this culinary delight!

Welcome to the Smokin’ Little Diner, where you’ll be transported back in time to the cozy vibes of the 1950s. This diner is known for its fantastic BBQ and delicious food, with a wide variety of barbecue sauces that will have your taste buds dancing. The staff here are incredibly friendly and engaging, making you feel right at home. From fluffy chocolate chip pancakes to perfectly cooked eggs, their breakfast options are a hit as well. Despite the small and cozy atmosphere, the service is quick and accommodating, even on busy days. The diner is beautifully decorated, especially during the holiday season, and the coffee mugs add a charming touch. Overall, the Smokin’ Little Diner is a must-visit for anyone craving mouthwatering food and a delightful dining experience. So come on over and enjoy a taste of the past with a modern twist!

Located in Lancaster, Margie’s Bar and Grill is a gem that surprises with its unassuming exterior but delights with its delicious offerings. The menu boasts homemade American staples and daily specials that have left patrons raving. From the tantalizing fish fry that’s been hailed as the best ever to the melt-in-your-mouth roast beef sandwich generously smothered in gravy, Margie’s leaves no taste bud untouched. The hot roast beef sandwich and medium fish fry have emerged as crowd favorites, with portions that impress and flavors that linger long after the meal is over. The friendly staff, led by Mary, adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making every visit a memorable experience. For a cozy neighborhood spot with outstanding food and impeccable service, Margie’s Bar and Grill is a must-visit for all food enthusiasts in Lancaster.

Lancaster’s Broadway Deli in Lancaster is a culinary gem that keeps patrons coming back for more. With rave reviews celebrating the Italian Assorted, Pastrami Reuben, and The Tuscan sandwiches, this deli knows how to satisfy taste buds. The menu boasts a mix of flavors that blend harmoniously, like the delightful Waldorf Chicken Salad Melt and the delectable homemade Hungarian cauliflower cheddar soup. Complemented by excellent potato salad and Voodoo chips, this spot offers a complete dining experience. Guests appreciate the quality of meats and bread, along with the warm ambiance set to the tune of Broadway music. Do yourself a favor and indulge in the fantastic dishes and generous portions at Lancaster’s Broadway Deli – a place where every bite is a flavorful journey worth savoring!

Welcome to this vibrant and relaxed restaurant, where the wood-burning oven takes center stage in the creation of delectable Neapolitan pizza and grilled fare. Located in the heart of the city, this place comes highly recommended by locals and visitors alike. One reviewer couldn’t stop raving about their famous Buffalo wings, claiming they were even better than the wings from their place of origin. The wings were crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and packed with flavor. They were the perfect balance of spiciness without being overwhelming. It’s no wonder this reviewer still dreams about them years later. Trust the locals and give this place a try – you won’t regret it!

Located in a warm and casual setting, this restaurant is a hidden gem that has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu offering all-day breakfast, homemade soups, and classic entrees, there is something for everyone to enjoy. The staff provides exceptional service, making you feel welcome from the moment you step foot through the door. The chicken finger sub is a must-try, bursting with flavor and satisfyingly crispy. The Belgian waffle with fresh strawberries and whipped cream is a sweet treat that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re a breakfast lover or seeking a hearty lunch or dinner, this restaurant is a true culinary delight. Don’t miss out on the chance to experience this fantastic dining establishment.

Located in the vibrant center of Lancaster, Skoob’s Village Grille is a gem worth discovering. With an inviting atmosphere that exudes charm, this spot is a culinary haven for food enthusiasts. One standout dish that beckons for attention is the breaded fish fry – a crispy delight that promises to tantalize taste buds. Pair it with their inventive sauces and make sure not to miss out on their house-made clam chowder, a beloved favorite among patrons. The friendly and efficient staff add a warm touch to the dining experience, ensuring that every visit feels like a reunion with long-lost family. Whether you’re craving juicy tenders or craving a decadent dessert like the apple bread pudding, Skoob’s Village Grille offers a delightful culinary journey that will keep you coming back for more. This restaurant truly knows how to make everyone feel like part of their extended family, making it a must-visit in Lancaster for both locals and visitors alike.

Welcome to Joseph’s, a hidden gem that offers much more than just a restaurant. Nestled in a beautiful 1880’s building, this venue is perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re planning a baby shower or a wedding, Joseph’s will exceed your expectations. The owners, Rich and Debbie, are incredibly accommodating, ensuring that every detail is tailored to your needs. The food is simply incredible, with a breakfast menu that will leave you wanting more. From the mouth-watering dishes to the attentive wait staff, every aspect of your dining experience will be exceptional. The venue itself is breathtaking, with stunning grounds and multiple rooms to choose from. The Meadows room, in particular, is a true fairytale setting. The staff, from servers to bartenders, goes above and beyond to make your special day unforgettable. So whether you’re looking for a place to celebrate or simply dine, Joseph’s is the place to be. Don’t miss out on this hidden gem – it’s a feast for the senses.

Located in Lancaster, The Pizza Heist is a culinary gem that has been stealing the hearts of locals and visitors alike with its mouthwatering pizzas. From the soft dough to the crispy crust and the slightly sweet sauce that keeps patrons coming back for more, this spot is a pizza lover’s paradise. Whether you opt for the 2 slice special that draws a crowd or indulge in their Monday large 1 topping deal, featuring generous portions of fresh toppings, each bite is a blissful experience. With a light and subtle sauce, along with a delicious oven taste, their pizzas are a steal at any price. The rave reviews speak for themselves, making The Pizza Heist a must-visit for anyone craving excellent food and top-notch service in Lancaster.