Hometown Plate

Savor the Flavor, Discover the Best

Best Restaurants in Ithaca, New York

Nestled amidst the rolling hills of New York’s Finger Lakes region, Ithaca stands as a culinary gem waiting to be explored. Known for its vibrant food scene, this town is home to an eclectic mix of restaurants that cater to every palate, from farm-to-table eateries featuring locally sourced ingredients to international cuisine that transports diners around the globe with every bite. Ithaca’s commitment to sustainability is evident in its dining establishments, many of which prioritize organic and eco-friendly practices. The town itself, with its scenic gorges and a prestigious educational institution, adds a unique charm and intellectual flair to the dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers. Whether you’re in the mood for an intimate café ambiance or a lively, upscale dining room, Ithaca’s culinary landscape promises an unforgettable gastronomic journey.

1. Maru Ramen

Maru Ramen in Ithaca is a culinary gem that promises a flavorful journey through Asian cuisine. Renowned for its Tonkotsu ramen, patrons rave about the generous portions of protein and authentic flavors that transport taste buds to the bustling streets of Japan. The hangover ramen adds a delightful twist with a perfect balance of spice and rich flavors. Guests appreciate the attentive wait staff and the speedy service, which perfectly complement the fresh and delectable dishes served. The fried dumplings steal the show, leaving diners craving more with each bite. Maru Ramen not only offers a delightful dining experience but also surprises with its budget-friendly prices, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors exploring Ithaca’s vibrant culinary scene.

Rating:
Price:

2. Maxie’s Supper Club & Oyster Bar

At the heart of a bustling, vibrant scene, this Southern-inspired hotspot not only draws a crowd with its boisterous blend of live music and late-night allure but captivates with a culinary charm that’s hard to forget. The blackened catfish sandwich and homemade cornbread are the stars of the show, enchanting diners with a taste of the South so authentic, you’d wish you lived next door. While most dishes receive high praise for their flavorful, spicy touches—like the unforgettable fried green tomatoes and a clam broth you’d consider bathing in—not all items hit the mark, with the fried chicken po’boy landing slightly off tune in an otherwise symphonous menu. Despite this, the ambiance, top-notch service, and a tempting selection of cold drinks ensure your evening here will be nothing short of fantastic, with fish tacos and jambalaya urging you to plan your next visit before the current one even ends.

Rating:
Price:

3. Liquid State Brewing Company

Situated in Ithaca, Liquid State Brewing Company is a culinary gem not to be missed. Boasting a unique concept of pairing their exceptional brews with a food truck experience, Silo, this brewery takes the dining scene to new heights. With a diverse range of beer styles and flavors, complemented by mouthwatering pizzas, Liquid State invites you to embark on a flavor adventure. The industrial yet inviting ambiance offers ample indoor and outdoor seating, perfect for sipping on innovative brews while engaging in lively conversations or challenging your friends to a game of Jenga. Whether you’re a local seeking a new hangout or a visitor exploring Ithaca, Liquid State promises a memorable experience filled with great food, friendly service, and an array of entertainment options. Venture to this vibrant brewery and savor the fusion of craft beer and delectable bites – it’s a journey worth taking!

Rating:
Price:

4. MIX

In the heart of Ithaca, MIX is a vibrant culinary gem that seamlessly blends artistry with gastronomy. Boasting a menu of eclectic small plates that resemble masterpieces and seasonal cocktails that tantalize the taste buds, this spot offers a sensory journey like no other. With a warm and welcoming staff, MIX creates an atmosphere where every visit feels like coming home. Don’t miss their renowned happy hour, where patrons rave about the artful presentation of dishes like the must-try onion rings. From the delectable short ribs to the indulgent turtle cheesecake, each bite is a symphony of flavors that leaves diners eagerly planning their return. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, MIX promises an unforgettable dining experience that will have you craving more.

Rating:
Price:

5. Taverna Banfi

Taverna Banfi, nestled within The Statler Hotel at Cornell University, emerges as a beacon of Tuscan-inspired cuisine that captivates both the palate and the heart. A journey to this dining haven guarantees an encounter with dishes that are nothing short of culinary masterpieces, from the succulent duck that reigns supreme in the memories of its patrons, to the tender, flavor-packed grilled octopus that leaves one savoring every bite. The ambiance, enriched by the diligent and enthusiastic service of hospitality students, complements the exquisite dining experience, making each visit not just a meal, but a cherished memory. Whether it’s for the expansive and decadent Sunday brunch, a casual yet sophisticated weekday lunch buffet, or an anniversary dinner that demands nothing less than perfection, Taverna Banfi stands out as a culinary gem in Ithaca, offering a dining experience that beckons for repeat visits.

Rating:
Price:

6. Mercato Bar & Kitchen

Nestled in the heart of Ithaca, Mercato emerges as a captivating haven for those seeking an exceptional Italian dining experience. From the moment you step inside, the cozy ambiance infused with the aroma of seasonal dishes sets the stage for a culinary journey that’s both delightful and memorable. The chef’s dedication to quality and detail is evident in every dish, whether it’s the perfectly cooked steak accompanied by shoestring fries with a rosemary twist or the thin, crispy, and juicy pork Milanese. Not to be overshadowed, the pasta dishes, like the gnocchi with eggplant ragu, showcase a mastery of Italian cuisine that can convert even the staunchest meat lovers. The attentive and personable service, coupled with a carefully curated wine list that promises to perfectly complement your meal, ensures that each visit is not just a dinner, but an experience to cherish. Mercato is not just a stop on the way through Ithaca; it’s a destination worth seeking out.

Rating:
Price:

7. Saigon Kitchen

Located in the vibrant town of Ithaca, Saigon Kitchen is a must-visit gem for Vietnamese cuisine enthusiasts craving an authentic culinary adventure. This cozy spot exudes warmth and charm while dishing out Vietnamese favorites like aromatic pho and flavorful vermicelli. The rave reviews speak volumes, with diners raving about the impeccable service and mouthwatering dishes like the chicken pho, fried squid appetizer, and a medley of beef and meatball pho that will leave you craving more. Whether you’re a soup aficionado or seeking a refreshing bubble tea smoothie, Saigon Kitchen’s delightful flavors and congenial atmosphere promise a dining experience that’s bound to impress. Don’t miss the chance to savor the delightful blend of sweet and savory flavors that keep patrons coming back for more!

Rating:
Price:

8. Simeon’s American Bistro

Nestled in a building that boasts both grandeur and a touch of whimsy, this American cuisine haven offers an unforgettable dining experience that’s both a feast for the eyes and the palate. With an ambience characterized by high ceilings, an open upstairs dining area, and the option to dine al fresco on lively sidewalk seating, it’s the perfect backdrop for culinary excellence. The staff, described as both attentive and constantly in motion, enhances the vibrant energy, making every visit memorable. The menu—a masterclass in American fare—features standout dishes like a New York strip steak that has diners raving and a grilled chicken sandwich that’s a flavor explosion. While one might hear a whisper of desire for a more illustrious lobster tail, such minor notes hardly detract from the chorus of praise. Whether it’s for a special occasion or just an ordinary day made extraordinary by great food and service, this spot is a testament to the art of dining well, inspiring creativity and satisfaction in equal measure.

Rating:
Price:

9. Purity Ice Cream Co.

Stepping into Purity Ice Cream Co. transports you to a retro paradise where indulgence in ice cream is not just encouraged, it’s practically mandatory. With an ambiance that marries the charm of yesteryears to modern-day ice cream wizardry, this parlor stands as a beacon of sweet, creamy delight in Ithaca. From the vibrant explosion of flavors in their mocha ice cream to the garden-fresh zeal of their strawberry scoop, every visit promises an adventure for your tastebuds. Not to be outdone by their dairy delights, their vegan options like the dark chocolate with Oreo topping cater to all preferences without skimping on the creamy, dreamy goodness. Beyond the frozen treats, their savory offerings – including hand-made chicken nuggets and customizable burgers – ensure that your visit to Purity Ice Cream Co. is deliciously rounded. Whether you’re seated inside savoring the retro vibe or taking a leisurely walk along the waterfront with your cone in hand, Purity Ice Cream Co. is a testament to the craft of making ice cream that’s seriously awesome.

Rating:
Price:

10. Ithaca Bakery

Nestled in the heart of Ithaca, this charming bakery and cafe emerges as a culinary haven for both early birds seeking a robust breakfast and evening dwellers in pursuit of happy hour delights. From the first sip of their nuanced hazelnut coffee to the last crumb of their delectable cannoli, each bite and gulp is a testament to quality and creativity. The vast menu, sprinkled with daily specials, offers a delightful dilemma with its array of sandwiches (do not miss the Ira with its quality lox and cream cheese), baked goods, and an impressive selection of local beer and cider. The ambiance, enhanced by the option of cozy greenhouse seating, complements the culinary experience, making it a must-visit destination for anyone craving a fusion of traditional bakery warmth and innovative cafe fare.

Rating:
Price: