Best Restaurants in Islip, New York

Located in Islip, The Pizzeria of Islip is a bustling hotspot for pizza aficionados, garnering rave reviews from both locals and those willing to travel for a stellar meal. Diners have praised the friendly and efficient staff, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable dining experience. The star of the show, their pizza, has been described as nothing short of amazing, with patrons lauding the quality and taste. Whether you’re participating in one of their special events like LI Pizza Strong Day or simply ordering their pizza kits for a fundraiser, this gem of a restaurant promises a 10/10 experience in both food and customer service, making it a must-visit for all pizza lovers in search of perfection.

Situated in Islip, the Irish Coffee Pub is a culinary gem that delivers an exceptional dining experience. With a menu boasting Continental and Irish classics, this white-tablecloth restaurant exudes charm and sophistication. Rave reviews highlight the impeccable service and delectable dishes, such as the perfectly cooked Salmon, flavorful Sliced Steak, and juicy Chicken Cordon Bleu. The warm apple crumb cake ala mode is a sweet treat not to be missed. The legendary service, spacious setting, and attention to detail make this spot a must-visit for any occasion. Whether you’re planning a special celebration or simply craving a top-tier burger with hand-cut fries, the Irish Coffee Pub promises a memorable dining experience that exceeds expectations.

Located in Islip, Tellers: An American Chophouse is a refined steakhouse housed in a former bank, boasting a unique charm with a copper bar and terrace seating. Renowned for its impeccable dining experience, Tellers has garnered praise as the best restaurant on Long Island. Guests rave about the delectable dishes, such as the beef wellington, rack of lamb, and Parmesan-crusted petite filet mignon. The culinary journey continues with standout sides like the phenomenal potato croquettes and the must-try mac & cheese. Service at Tellers is not just good; it’s exceptional, with mentions of friendly staff like Luke and Kyle, who elevate the dining experience. Whether you’re craving a perfectly cooked steak or a delightful burger, Tellers promises a memorable meal that exceeds expectations every time. Don’t hesitate – indulge your taste buds at this top-notch chophouse for a dining experience that truly stands out in Islip.

Situated in Islip, the Oconee Diner is a festive paradise for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful dining experience. Embracing every holiday with zeal, this diner transforms into a magical wonderland, with enchanting decorations that extend from roof to lawn, infusing a jolly spirit into every meal. The extensive menu offers delectable dishes in generous portions, ensuring you never leave unsatisfied. From perfectly cooked eggs to savory entrees, each bite is a celebration of flavor and quality. The attentive staff, with standout service from servers like Emily, elevate the dining experience, making every visit a joyous occasion. With a blend of delicious food, cozy ambiance, and friendly service, Oconee Diner truly embodies the essence of a top-tier culinary destination in Islip.

Dive into a flavorful fiesta at Bubba’s Burrito Bar in Islip, where Tex-Mex meets Cali-style eats in a vibrant setting adorned with local art and surf vibes. The surf boards hanging overhead set the tone for a laid-back experience, while the counter-serve setup adds a touch of convenience to your dining escapade. Embrace the generous portions that leave diners unable to function (in the best possible way), with burritos that are stuffed to the brim and bursting with deliciousness. The friendly and accommodating staff amplify the fantastic atmosphere, ensuring speedy service and pocket-friendly prices that make Bubba’s a must-visit for all food enthusiasts craving a taste of the extraordinary. Whether you’re a solo beverage explorer or part of a hungry squad, Bubba’s Burrito Bar promises an unforgettable gastronomic journey that beckons you to return time and time again for a flavorful adventure!

Located in Islip, Americano Pie Bar is a gem not to be missed for those craving a delightful culinary experience. Rave reviews flood in for its margarita pizza with tantalizing vodka sauce, a dish that seems to hold the power to captivate taste buds instantly. The brunch scene at this spot is no less impressive, with bottomless Bloody Marys and delectable mussels stealing the show. The halibut, grilled to perfection, and the irresistible old-fashioned cocktail further solidify this place as a must-visit. And let’s not forget about the Breakfast Pizza, a dish that seems to have patrons singing its praises. With a winning combination of great food, attentive service, and a welcoming atmosphere, Americano Pie Bar has undoubtedly earned its place in the hearts of food enthusiasts in Islip.

Located in Islip, Harp & Hound is a vibrant culinary gem that promises a delightful dining experience. The restaurant boasts an energetic atmosphere with live music, offering guests the option of a cozy enclosed heated patio or a beautifully decorated interior complete with a warm fireplace. Delight your taste buds with the must-try lamb meatballs in pita, infused with tantalizing Moroccan spices and complemented by a flavorful aioli. For traditional favorites, indulge in the hearty Shepherd’s Pie or savor the generous portion of perfectly crispy onion rings. With attentive servers like Kristen and Nicole, who ensure a seamless dining experience, Harp & Hound is a definite go-to spot for flavorful burgers, refreshing cocktails like the Moscow Mule, and a delectable array of bar bites. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Harp & Hound promises a culinary journey worth revisiting time and time again.

In the vibrant town of Islip, Chili’s Grill & Bar stands out as a beacon of delectable Tex-Mex and American cuisine. Boasting a welcoming and spotless ambiance, this family-friendly eatery has garnered praise for its attentive service and generous portions. From the mouthwatering shrimp tacos to their signature Tex-Mex classics, every dish is served with a touch of Southwestern flair that keeps diners coming back for more. Whether you’re a late-night guest savoring the last bites of the day or joining the bustling crowd on Cinco de Mayo, Chili’s Grill & Bar in Islip promises a delightful dining experience that tingles taste buds and leaves patrons planning their return visit.

With a laid-back and welcoming vibe, J&R’s Islip Steak House in Islip is a must-visit gem for families looking for a delicious dining experience without breaking the bank. Raving reviews highlight the phenomenal steaks that are described as “out of this world” and the friendly staff who go above and beyond to cater to your needs. From the cowboy steak to the signature steak sauce, every dish is a culinary delight that keeps patrons coming back for more. The Midwest rustic hometown feel adds to the charm of this no-frills steakhouse, where good food, great prices, and attentive service create the perfect recipe for a memorable dining experience. Don’t miss out on the early-bird specials and kids-eat-free deal that make J&R’s a top choice for a satisfying meal in Islip.

If you find yourself in Islip and craving a hearty BBQ feast, look no further than Dang BBQ. This small gem is a hidden treasure trove of classic BBQ delights and mouthwatering sandwiches paired with indulgent sides, milkshakes, and a selection of chilled beers. With generous portions that arrive piping hot and drinks that are a perfect blend of strong and delicious, Dang BBQ promises a truly satisfying dining experience. The attentive and friendly staff, like John, Greg, and Mechele, add a personal touch that elevates your visit, making it feel like a warm, welcoming gathering. Don’t miss out on their must-try dishes like the 3 Little Pigs combo or the pulled pork and bacon jam empanadas – each bite is a flavorful adventure. Whether you’re a BBQ enthusiast or simply seeking a cozy spot for a date night, Dang BBQ comes highly recommended by visitors who have found their new go-to spot for finger-licking good food and a family-friendly atmosphere.