Best Restaurants in Hillsdale, Michigan

Located in Hillsdale, Handmade is a sandwich haven that has left patrons raving about its artisanal creations. The bread and sauces here are not just accompaniments but stars of the show, elevating each bite to a symphony of flavors. From the Handie Sandie to the zucchini fries and the Colombian sandwich with its delightful coffee mayo, every dish is crafted with precision and passion. The atmosphere is vibrant, with a modern touch and a scenic view of St. Joes river, creating the perfect backdrop for savoring these delectable sandwiches. While parking may be a slight challenge, the culinary experience at Handmade is a journey worth taking, where every bite is a testament to their commitment to excellence.

Located in Hillsdale, Jilly Beans Coffee House is a cozy spot that offers not just a cup of coffee but a delightful experience. With a wide array of coffee blends and delectable food choices, it’s no surprise that patrons rave about the inviting atmosphere and top-notch service. From the heavenly iced Black Forest Coffee to the creamy frappes like caramel and peanut butter, every sip is a flavor journey worth savoring. Pair your beverage with a selection from their excellent food menu, where quality meets quantity in generous portions. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this charming coffee house is a must-visit destination for a truly enjoyable and affordable culinary adventure.

Located in Hillsdale, Here’s To You Pub & Grub is a hidden gem that food enthusiasts in search of a warm, welcoming atmosphere must discover. Boasting a stellar reputation for exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes, this spot is a must-visit for anyone exploring the local culinary scene. From the rave reviews highlighting the friendly service to the tantalizing descriptions of the Pub Burger, Timo’s Pipe Cleaner, and the signature Pub tots, it’s evident that the menu is a treasure trove of delights waiting to be savored. Pair your meal with a selection from their impressive craft beer lineup, and you’re in for a treat that goes above and beyond the ordinary dining experience. Don’t miss out on this cozy spot that promises to make you feel right at home with each visit!

Located in a bustling strip mall in Hillsdale, El’ Cerrito Mexican bar & grill is a culinary gem not to be missed. With a longstanding presence since 2005, this establishment has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike with its amazing Mexican cuisine and excellent service. Patrons rave about the prompt service and lively atmosphere, where waitstaff showcase impressive plate-carrying skills. The sizzling hot dishes bursting with flavor arrive promptly, accompanied by friendly and helpful staff creating an enjoyable dining experience. El’ Cerrito has cemented its place as a favorite spot for many, offering top-notch service, unbeatable prices, and consistently delicious food that keeps customers coming back for more. Indulge in a taste of Mexico right in the heart of Hillsdale at El’ Cerrito Mexican bar & grill.

Nestled in the vibrant town of Hillsdale, The Local Eatery has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a charming ambiance and a staff that exudes warmth and efficiency, this eatery is a true gem. The menu boasts delights like the Rum Custard French Toast, a dish that has diners coming back for more. And let’s not forget the irresistible cinnamon rolls that have garnered quite the reputation. Whether you’re in town for the Farmers Market or simply exploring the area, a visit to The Local Eatery is a must for a memorable dining experience that perfectly encapsulates the essence of Hillsdale’s culinary scene.

In the vibrant town of Hillsdale, Cavoni’s Pizza & Grinders stands out as a gem for those seeking an authentic dining experience. Boasting a diverse menu, this eatery has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering pizzas and generous portions. Patrons have praised the friendly staff, with one diner’s child even receiving a personalized interaction from the owner, showcasing a level of care that goes beyond the ordinary. Whether you’re craving a loaded pizza or a satisfying calzone, Cavoni’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction shines through in every bite. Don’t miss the chance to savor a meal at this culinary hotspot that promises to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds.

Located in Hillsdale, the Hillsdale Brewing Company is a standout gem in the culinary scene. Housed in a historic bank building, this spot offers more than just great food—it’s an experience. From the rave reviews about the fried asparagus, vegan pot stickers, and Cobb salad that “smelled amazing,” to the intriguing hybrid food options, like the churros with chocolate sauce, every dish seems to hit the mark. Not to mention the love for their peanut butter porter and blueberry cream ale, ensuring a delightful beverage selection. With friendly service being a common theme, highlighted by names like Kaylee and Allison, and unique activities like axe throwing, this place truly seems to have it all. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Hillsdale Brewing Company is a must-visit destination that promises a memorable dining experience.

Situated in the charming town of Hillsdale, Finish Line Family Restaurant is a true culinary gem that embodies friendly service and fantastic food. Visitors rave about the speedy service, with one patron mentioning only a brief 5-minute wait on a bustling Friday night. The menu boasts hearty classics like burgers and fries, as well as indulgent treats like ice cream sundaes and shakes that are not to be missed. The fish and chips steal the spotlight, described as not only visually appealing but also generously portioned. With glowing reviews highlighting attentive staff members like Shay and Liz, who elevate the dining experience with their exceptional service, Finish Line Family Restaurant is a must-visit for those in search of a welcoming atmosphere and delectable fare in Hillsdale.

Situated in the vibrant town of Hillsdale, Johnny T’s Bistro is where culinary dreams come true. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving a top-notch meal, this gem has it all. From impeccable service that makes you feel like a VIP to dishes that are crafted with love, each bite tells a story of passion and dedication. Guests rave about the prime rib that receives universal praise, and the homemade delights that leave taste buds yearning for more. Whether it’s a cozy anniversary dinner or a bustling wedding reception, Johnny T’s Bistro is the go-to spot for an unforgettable dining experience in Michigan. Don’t forget to ask for Jaime, the maestro behind the magic, and get ready to elevate your culinary journey to new heights!

In the bustling town of Hillsdale, coffee aficionados have found a true gem in BIGGBY COFFEE. This vibrant regional coffeehouse is a must-visit for those craving specialty drinks with a side of charm. The reviews rave about the delightful smoothies that are as refreshing as a summer breeze, while the baked goods are described as heavenly bites of indulgence. With a reputation for excellent service and a welcoming atmosphere, BIGGBY COFFEE is a beacon for anyone seeking a cozy spot to sip on a meticulously crafted beverage.