Best Restaurants in Herkimer, New York

Located in Herkimer, Crazy Otto’s Empire Diner is a culinary gem worth the drive! The diner boasts a vibrant atmosphere with eye-catching decor and a friendly, efficient staff. Indulge in their western sandwich with massive chunks of ham and perfectly cooked hash browns, followed by a heavenly slice of banana cream pie. Whether you’re in for a quick breakfast stop or a leisurely meal, the generous portions and impeccable service will leave you satisfied. Don’t let the area’s appearance deceive you; this diner is a delightful surprise that promises a delicious step back in time. Give Crazy Otto’s a try and experience the magic for yourself!

Located in Herkimer, TokaBocca Restaurant is a culinary gem that promises a unique dining experience. With a diverse menu brimming with fresh and flavorful options, this spot has quickly won the hearts of patrons. The “joints,” including the Burrito’s Pork Belly and Paul Bunyan with mac n cheese and pulled pork, are touted for their rich flavors and fresh ingredients. The fish fry is described as light and crunchy, perfectly complemented by a nice selection of draft beers, creating a well-rounded meal. Moreover, the standout margaritas and tacos, paired with a cozy ambiance and attentive service, make TokaBocca a must-visit destination. The restaurant’s rotating specials, like the crispy spring rolls, tender meatballs, and cheesy sliders, showcase a commitment to variety and quality. And let’s not forget the attention to detail, like the quality paper napkins, adding an extra touch of care to the dining experience. In a nutshell, TokaBocca is a vibrant dining spot that promises a delightful culinary adventure worth revisiting.

Asteroga Ale House in Herkimer is a true gem for food enthusiasts and beer aficionados alike. The menu boasts an array of delectable dishes that have left patrons raving. From their mouthwatering boneless wings to the savory broiled haddock and tantalizing mac & cheese, every bite is a flavorful adventure. The everything wings and best-ever burger are must-tries, according to delighted diners. With an impressive tap selection and attentive service, this funky spot promises a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re craving classic American fare with a twist or a refreshing brew, Asteroga Ale House is a culinary delight worth revisiting whenever you find yourself in the area.

Salvatore’s in Herkimer is a culinary gem worth exploring. Guests rave about the grandma slice, a fan favorite that promises a savory delight with each bite. The steak sandwich is a standout, boasting a perfect balance of flavors accentuated by a toasted roll, garlic butter, and parmesan. The mediterranean sandwich is a hit as well, appealing to diverse palates. With a focus on quality ingredients and friendly service, Salvatore’s guarantees a memorable dining experience for all. Whether you’re a local looking for a quick bite or a traveler seeking authentic flavors, Salvatore’s is a must-visit destination to satisfy your food cravings in Herkimer.

Located in Herkimer, Tren De Villa Mexican Restaurant is a gem for travelers seeking a delicious pit stop along their journey. With rave reviews about their generous portions and flavorful dishes, it’s no surprise this restaurant has quickly gained a loyal following. The “Super Burrito” stands out as a must-try, packed with fresh toppings and bursting with flavor. Guests also praise the complimentary bowl of tortilla chips and salsa, a perfect prelude to their authentic Mexican fare. From the La Palma burritos to the delectable chili rellenos, each dish is crafted with care and served with a smile. Whether you’re passing through or a local foodie, Tren De Villa promises a culinary experience that will keep you coming back for more. Indulge in the flavors of Mexico right here in Herkimer!

Located in Herkimer, Tony’s Pizzeria is a gem awaiting discovery for pizza enthusiasts. With a dedication to quality evident in each savory bite, Tony’s boasts a thicker crust that perfectly complements their generous portions of fresh, flavorful toppings. What truly sets this establishment apart is their unparalleled customer service, as displayed by their meticulous attention to food allergies and willingness to go above and beyond to ensure a safe and enjoyable dining experience for all patrons. It’s no wonder why locals and visitors alike rave about Tony’s, making it a must-visit spot for a slice of the best pizza in the entire valley. Come savor the essence of hospitality and delectable cuisine at Tony’s Pizzeria, where every visit promises a delightful culinary journey.

Located in Herkimer, the Waterfront Grille is a culinary gem off exit 30 that promises an unforgettable dining experience. The menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options, from the must-try calamari to the heavenly Caesar salad that will leave you craving more. The ambiance is described as nothing short of familial, with attentive staff ensuring your satisfaction just like the owner who personally engages with diners. Indulge in their sumptuous dishes, like the flavorful tripe and perfectly fried lamb chops, showcasing the chef’s expertise and a commitment to quality ingredients. Whether you opt for a light bite or a full dinner, this establishment offers a dining experience that matches its stunning view of the river, making it a top contender among the best restaurants in Herkimer.

Get ready to embark on a culinary journey at Yetty’s Pizza, located in Herkimer. This gem stands out in a town bustling with Italian eateries, boasting the best sauce that will tantalize your taste buds. From gigantic paninis to generous portions, this spot offers a delightful array of options to satisfy any craving. The impeccable service, as highlighted by patrons, ensures a seamless dining experience. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to savor homemade goodness and enjoy top-notch hospitality at Yetty’s Pizza – a must-visit hotspot for both locals and visitors seeking a delectable Italian feast in Herkimer.

Located in Herkimer, Borunda Asian Buffet is a culinary gem worth discovering. With a delightful array of dishes like freshly made sushi and flavorful entrees, this spot promises a feast for the senses. From attentive service to a welcoming atmosphere, diners rave about the friendly staff and clean facilities. While some mention the occasional need to request condiments, the quick response and overall experience make it a top choice for families and date nights alike. Affordable pricing and a diverse menu ensure a return visit is on the horizon for many patrons. Don’t miss out on this Asian culinary adventure in the heart of Herkimer!

In the vibrant town of Herkimer, you’ll discover the culinary gem known as Dunkin’. Renowned for its signature breakfast delights and diverse range of coffee concoctions, this long-standing establishment has captured the hearts of locals and travelers alike. Patrons rave about the delectable pastries that practically melt in your mouth, while the aromatic coffee brews offer the perfect pick-me-up any time of day. With a reputation for friendly service and consistent quality, Dunkin’ in Herkimer stands out as a must-visit destination for foodies seeking a comforting and satisfying dining experience.