Best Restaurants in Hayward, Wisconsin

Situated in the charming town of Hayward, McCormick House Inn & Restaurant is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. This historic establishment not only offers impeccable service but also a menu that leaves taste buds tingling with delight. The crab soup is a definite standout, a must-try that keeps guests coming back for more. From the battered white fish that melts in your mouth to the fresh and generous house salad, every dish is crafted to perfection. With a serene outdoor atmosphere and a wide selection of top-notch beers on tap, McCormick House promises an unforgettable dining experience that will have you planning your return before you’ve even left. Don’t miss the chance to savor elevated cuisine and create lasting memories with friends and family at this unique culinary haven in the heart of Hayward.

Louie’s Bar and Bites in Hayward, a hidden gem that stands out among the bustling bar and grill scene, offers a neighborhood feel with exceptional service. Immaculately clean and boasting a variety of beers and delicious bites, this spot is a must-visit for locals and travelers alike. Dive into their infamous Lou’s pizza, hailed as the best in town, or indulge in hearty broasted chicken and homemade coleslaw. Don’t miss out on their daily specials and scrumptious cheese curds. With a welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and top-notch cleanliness, Louie’s Bar and Bites is sure to become your new favorite dining spot in Hayward.

Main Street Tacos in Hayward is a hidden gem that promises a delightful culinary experience. With a warm ambiance and an impressive array of classic Mexican delights, this low-key restaurant has been winning hearts and taste buds alike. The steak taco, hailed for its generous portion of meat and flavorful salsa, stands out as a must-try. Moreover, the burritos, tacos, and quesadillas have garnered rave reviews for their mouthwatering taste and size, perfect for satisfying even the heartiest of appetites. Whether you’re a foodie on the hunt for authentic Mexican flavors or catering to various dietary needs, Main Street Tacos has you covered. Don’t miss out on this local favorite that promises a quick and delicious dining experience on Main Street in Hayward.

Situated in Hayward, Lynn’s Custom Meats & Catering is a culinary gem that continuously delights patrons with its exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes. From catering weddings with precision and flair to crafting delectable pork chops and German potato salad, Lynn’s truly embodies culinary excellence. The rave reviews speak volumes about their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, exemplified by their diverse menu offerings and attention to detail. Whether savoring their signature meat sandwiches or relishing in the delightful cheese and sausage platters, Lynn’s ensures that every bite is a flavorful journey worth savoring. For an unforgettable dining experience in Hayward, look no further than Lynn’s Custom Meats & Catering.

Located in Hayward, the Hayward Family Restaurant is a hidden culinary gem that has been garnering rave reviews for its delectable offerings. Guests are welcomed with warmth and charm, ensuring a delightful dining experience from the get-go. The menu boasts standout items like the Mediterranean chicken sandwich, a BLT club with top-notch bacon, and unique cheesecurds that marry crunch and creaminess flawlessly. Patrons have praised the spotless presentation and quick service, with the Clean Grill Award highlighting the restaurant’s commitment to quality. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this spot is a must-visit for a truly friendly and scrumptious breakfast or lunch that will leave you planning your next visit before you’ve even left the table.

Situated in Hayward, the Lakewood Cafe is a gem worth discovering! From the moment you step inside, the ambiance exudes sophistication and cleanliness, making you feel like you’re in for a treat. The Parmesan Meatballs are a standout, boasting flavorful meatballs perfectly cooked to perfection, complemented by a delicious sauce. Guests rave about the generous portions, with the Lakeshore Cafe Chicken Sandwich on Ciabatta being a crowd favorite. Alongside impeccable service, including attentive staff and a friendly owner who ensures your satisfaction, this spot is a must-visit in Hayward. Whether you’re craving a classic fish fry or indulging in mouthwatering onion rings, Lakewood Cafe promises a delightful dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

Serving up a slice of history since 1979, Coop’s Pizza in Hayward is a must-visit for pizza aficionados and casual diners alike. Boasting a cozy log cabin setting, this restaurant has garnered rave reviews for its delectable pizzas and Italian sandwiches. Patrons can’t get enough of the cheesy bread that perfectly complements the mouthwatering pizzas, which can also be enjoyed at home thanks to their convenient frozen pizza offerings. With friendly service and attention to detail, including an array of options like the 1919 Root Beer, Coop’s Pizza ensures a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by Coop’s for a slice of pizza perfection that even impresses Chicago natives.

Located in Hayward, Angler’s Bar and Grill is a gem that seamlessly blends timeless charm with a modern twist, offering a delightful fusion of pub grub and Mexican cuisine. Renowned for their mouthwatering chicken fried steak special, patrons rave about the dish’s delectable flavor, ensuring a memorable dining experience. The friendly service and vibrant atmosphere make it a perfect spot for both casual outings and special occasions. With a beer garden and even a bowling alley, this circa-1930s tavern is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking fresh, hot, and tasty dishes. Whether you’re a sports enthusiast or simply a food lover, Angler’s Bar and Grill is a must-visit hotspot in Hayward, promising a culinary adventure that will leave you craving more.

Located in Hayward, The Ranch is a historic steakhouse exuding warmth and charm since 1932. Boasting a menu filled with classic cocktails and delectable dishes like the seafood trio that “just melted in my mouth” according to one patron, this gem is a standout in the lively culinary scene. Guests rave about the impeccable service, with Hailey at the bar shining brightly, ensuring a delightful dining experience. From perfectly done 16oz ribeyes to the Pink Squirrel dessert, every bite at The Ranch promises a flavorful journey. Don’t forget to make a reservation, or pull up a seat at the bar and immerse yourself in the welcoming ambiance that treats you like family. Make sure to try the old fashioned with a twist or the Manhattan with 46 parallel rye whisky for a memorable sip that complements the succulent dishes. With a blend of tradition and modern hospitality, The Ranch is a must-visit spot for food enthusiasts in Hayward.

Located in Hayward, Los Portales is a Mexican food gem that has diners raving. Their queso dip is hailed as a must-try, with patrons suggesting anything smothered in it is a winner. From the tantalizing Cameron’s Ala Diabla to the mouthwatering nacho Supreme, each dish is crafted with flavorful perfection. The service is top-notch, ensuring a delightful dining experience. Whether you fancy street tacos, chimichangas, or fajitas, Los Portales promises a culinary journey that will keep you coming back for more. This restaurant is definitely a standout in the vibrant food scene of Hayward.