Best Restaurants in Greenville, New York

Greenville’s culinary gem, Lil’ Piece BBQ and Catering, is a haven for BBQ aficionados seeking a transcendent dining experience. Revel in the mastery of flavors crafted by Andrew and his dedicated team. Indulge in the irresistible bacon deviled eggs, wings that are a flavor explosion, and the tender, juicy beef brisket that sets a new standard. The sweet & sour cucumber salad is a delightful surprise that perfectly complements the smoky meats. With accolades like “best BBQ for a 100 miles” and “the most delicious meal ever eaten,” this spot is a must-visit hotspot. The picturesque view of the golf course adds a charming touch to your dining adventure, making Lil’ Piece BBQ a true standout in Greenville’s vibrant food scene.

Located in Greenville, The Tasting Lab is a delightful culinary gem that will tantalize your taste buds and quench your thirst for a memorable dining experience. Embracing a fusion of delectable food and craft beers, this spot is a must-visit for food enthusiasts and beer aficionados alike. Indulge in their signature elk burger, jalapeño poppers, and perfectly seasoned chicken wings as raved about by patrons. The flavorful burgers, whether beef, bison, or elk, are a definite highlight, ensuring each bite is juicy and satisfying. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly, attentive service, The Tasting Lab offers a dining escapade that promises to leave you planning your swift return to savor more of their culinary delights.

Located in the heart of Greenville, Modena is a culinary gem that boasts a warm and inviting atmosphere alongside exceptional food crafted with care. Renowned for its impeccable service, this restaurant has become a beloved staple in the community. Delight in dishes like the lobster ravioli and melt-in-your-mouth mussels, followed by the expertly prepared swordfish with a delightful tomato/olive sauce. The menu offers a tantalizing array of options, including the Veal Modena and Fresh Pasta with Boar Bolognese that leave taste buds tingling with delight. Conclude your meal with the irresistible homemade tiramisu, a true testament to the culinary expertise found at Modena. With each visit promising a memorable dining experience, Modena is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in Greenville.

Woodhouse Pizza in Greenville is a culinary treasure not to be missed. The staff, including the delightful Holly and Mallory, go above and beyond to make every visit special. The patio, complete with fire pits, provides the perfect backdrop for enjoying their fresh and tasty menu. The star of the show? Their mouthwatering pizzas boasting fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce that is simply unbeatable. Don’t let the quaint size fool you; the flavors here are larger than life. Woodhouse Pizza is a must-visit hotspot for those craving a unique and delicious dining experience in Greenville.

Located in the vibrant town of Greenville, Tommy’s Hot Dog Stand is a must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful culinary adventure. Receiving rave reviews for its iconic Matt Dog, a tantalizing creation featuring a harmonious blend of spicy brown mustard, sauerkraut, and grilled onions and peppers, this eatery promises a flavor explosion with every bite. Boasting a rich history dating back to 1969, Tommy’s Hot Dog Stand has stood the test of time, captivating patrons with its timeless offerings. Affordable and brimming with nostalgia, this gem is a testament to quality and taste, beckoning guests to savor the essence of authentic hot dog perfection.

Situated in the heart of Greenville, The Frozen Spoon is a dessert haven that promises a delightful experience for all ice cream enthusiasts. Overflowing with creamy goodness, their ice cream creations are not only delectable but also come at reasonable prices, ensuring a treat for your taste buds without breaking the bank. Whether you opt for the enormous and scrumptious peanut butter cup sundae or a simple cone that magically turns into a generous portion, each visit guarantees a sweet memory in the making. With a long-standing tradition of serving up deliciousness and a friendly staff that adds a personal touch to every order, The Frozen Spoon is a must-visit for anyone craving a scoop of happiness in Greenville.

Located in Greenville, Stewart’s Shops is a culinary gem that transcends the traditional convenience store experience. Renowned for its delectable ice cream, flavorful coffee, and an array of snacks that will tantalize your taste buds, Stewart’s is a haven for food enthusiasts and weary travelers alike. With patrons praising the friendly staff, the delightful lunch items, and the unexpected generosity exemplified by not charging for a simple cup of hot water, Stewart’s truly goes above and beyond to create a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a regular or just passing through, Stewart’s Shops is a must-visit destination for a culinary adventure that promises to delight and surprise.

Located in the heart of Greenville, Tiny Diner is a hidden gem that packs a flavorful punch. With dishes like the buttery Grilled Cheese, the hearty Burger, and the standout Brown Gravy that had patrons raving and indulging in every dip with their crispy French fries, it’s clear that this diner takes comfort food to the next level. The staff’s exceptional service, described as attentive and friendly, adds an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience. Plus, with an extensive menu catering to both vegetarians and meat lovers, there’s something for everyone at Tiny Diner. Despite the high quality of the cuisine, the prices remain modest, offering excellent value for a top-notch dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to Tiny Diner promises to be a delicious and satisfying culinary adventure.

Situated in the vibrant town of Greenville, Dunkin’ stands out as a beloved spot for breakfast enthusiasts and coffee aficionados alike. Renowned for their friendly and accommodating staff, this longstanding establishment is a haven for those craving fresh and delectable donuts. With the convenience of a drive-thru, Dunkin’ offers a seamless experience for patrons on the go, ensuring that a delightful morning pick-me-up is always within reach. Whether you’re a fan of their signature breakfast items or in need of a caffeine fix, Dunkin’ promises a satisfying visit that’s sure to leave you coming back for more.

In the heart of Greenville lies TJ’s Pizza, a local gem for pizza aficionados. The reviews speak for themselves, with patrons raving about the exceptional thin-crust pies that leave taste buds in awe. Beyond the delicious pizzas, guests have highlighted the restaurant’s catering services, making it a go-to spot for events where guests are sure to be impressed. TJ’s Pizza seems to not only serve up delectable slices but also a side of warm hospitality, as noted by the friendly owner and staff who add a personal touch to the dining experience. For those in search of more than just a meal, TJ’s Pizza in Greenville promises to be a slice above the rest.